- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper focuses on the direction of recursive reasoning models and investigates the problem of attraction-basin trapping. It proposes a test-time intervention method that does not require retraining the model—a training-free guided intervention approach. Specifically, it computes the FTLE along the unperturbed original reasoning trajectory, identifies locally unstable regions, and applies targeted perturbations at these steps to encourage the model to escape erroneous attraction basins.
Critical strengths
-
The paper is well written and complete, and the experiments are sufficiently thorough.
-
The proposed method is intuitive and concise, and it is very solid.
-
The paper connects the failure problem of recursive reasoning models with attraction-basin trapping in dynamical systems, which provides the paper with a certain theoretical basis and an analyzable perspective.
Critical weaknesses
-
The writing is somewhat misleading, as it gives the impression that the paper uses recursive reasoning models and FTLE to solve LLM reasoning problems, whereas LLMs are actually introduced to illustrate the advantages of recursive reasoning models. However, since recursive reasoning models also require a series of methods such as those you propose to address their problems, I think this model actually has similar issues. The tasks used in the experiments seem to be ones that LLM agents can already perform very well. I think the advantage of recursive reasoning models lies in their smaller parameter size and lower cost. The paper may need to be rephrased.
-
From my rough understanding, the proposed method can be regarded as adding perturbations to steer the model away from incorrect convergence points. Do you think the most important difficulty of the method is identifying the so-called attraction-basin trapping? Can we identify it from experimental results?
-
Does the proposed method or idea also apply to other deep models? For example, if I find that a model performs poorly or keeps getting stuck at a certain error (e.g., an LLM keeps repeating a sentence), I add some perturbation to it. What do you think is the most distinctive feature of your method compared with this kind of practice?
Questions for authors
I am very sorry, but I have no knowledge of recursive reasoning models. I have included my questions and concerns in Critical Weaknesses. My comments are for reference only.
4 comments
2. Experimental identification of attraction-basin trapping
Your "rough" understanding captured the gist of our work accurately. And yes, the most important/challenging point addressed in our method for untapping the trapped capacity is exactly how to identify the attraction-basin, including when to intervene, such that the probability of finding better reasoning routes is higher. Experimentally, we have provided complementary evidences of its identification in three forms:
- Persistence under continued recursion. In Table 8, deterministic TRM accuracy on Maze remains approximately 85% from 3 through 16 ACT steps. Appendices F.2–F.3 show individual examples where the baseline remains incorrect while a perturbed trajectory reaches the correct solution.
- Geometry separating different outcomes. Figure 3 shows an interior FTLE maximum between successful and unsuccessful trajectories at matched reasoning steps. Figure 7 presents the corresponding pattern across five Sudoku examples. These observations support the interpretation of a sensitive transition region between different attraction basins.
- Controlled intervention evidence. Table 4 demonstrate the positive effect on choosing the point of intervention with FTLE, it varies the timing while keeping the rollout budget, noise scales, and selection procedure fixed.
Although our steering also uses an ensemble of rollouts (so these are improvements with additional inference computation) its ensemble outperformed other methods by using FLTE to decide when to perturb. To support this, we provide a detailed comparison of computational costs across TRM, PTRM, and our method. We evaluate all three methods on Maze, Sudoku, and PPBench using the same ACT steps for each dataset. The results are summarized in the table below.
| Dataset | Method | Accuracy | TFLOPs/example | GPU-hours | Mean peak allocated GPU memory (MiB) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Maze | Ours (FTLE-max) | 91.00% | 209.01 | 3.09212 | 3,836.18 |
| Maze | PTRM | 88.90% | 210.19 | 3.07218 | 3,671.33 |
| Maze | TRM | 85.30% | 3.82 | 0.09461 | 102.95 |
| Sudoku | Ours (FTLE-max) | 98.50% | 13.17 | 0.17644 | 185.55 |
| Sudoku | PTRM | 98.20% | 13.07 | 0.15570 | 162.77 |
| Sudoku | TRM | 85.10% | 0.26 | 0.05044 | 38.38 |
| PPBench | Ours (FTLE-max) | 71.43% | 167.59 | 0.08530 | 262.49 |
| PPBench | PTRM | 65.31% | 168.24 | 0.09320 | 225.10 |
| PPBench | TRM | 53.06% | 1.65 | 0.01982 | 54.96 |
| ARC-AGI-2(pass@5) | Ours (FTLE-max) | 7.50% | 9,927.02 | 18.85762 | 4,778 |
| ARC-AGI-2(pass@5) | PTRM | 5.00% | 9,912.90 | 17.86032 | 4,730 |
| ARC-AGI-2 | TRM | 6.67% | 381.27 | 1.15783 | 4,708.56 |
In this new experiment, owing to the high computational cost of ARC-AGI-2, we performed cost accounting on a subset, where our method and PTRM incur comparable overheads; notably, PTRM falls below the vanilla TRM baseline, suggesting that its persistent noise injection may lead to over-perturbation.
FTLE itself measures sensitivity, thus intervening at its maximum make it more likely to generate alternatives belonging to different basins, from which our Gibbs-weighted selection would have a better chance.
Together, these evidences support the interpretation that some failures arise from the inference trajectory rather than an absence of usable capacity in the trained model and the point of intervention to acquire correct trajectories is important.
Related phenomena have also been identified in language models. Holtzman et al. report a repetition rate of 73.66% under greedy decoding versus 0.36% under nucleus sampling (better selection) with , using the same GPT-2 Large model. This demonstrates how strongly an inference procedure can affect repetitive failure behavior without changing model parameters. More directly, Wang et al. observe attractor cycles during successive LLM paraphrasing: their two-step periodicity score reaches 0.81 for GPT-4o and 0.92 for Qwen2.5-72B in English. These scores measure recurrence of similar text, not error rates (Wang et al., 2025, Table 1). However, these work still leave open on what's a better framework to release the potential of LLMs during inference, which also support our broader motivation.
3. Distinction from generic perturbation and applicability to other models
As the reviewer correctly points out, introducing perturbations to escape undesirable inference outcomes and explore alternative trajectories is a natural and widely used strategy, as exemplified by PTRM. However, the dynamical mechanisms underlying its effectiveness, particularly when and why perturbations are most useful, remain insufficiently understood.
Our key contribution is to provide a dynamics-based understanding of this strategy and use it to guide more effective interventions. Specifically, FTLE identifies regions of high dynamical sensitivity, suggesting where perturbations may be particularly effective.
Importantly, our controlled ablations demonstrate that FTLE-guided intervention consistently outperforms first-step and random-step perturbations, with rollout budgets, noise scales, and selection procedures held fixed (Table below). This provides direct evidence that dynamical information improves intervention timing, and helps explain why indiscriminate perturbation throughout inference may be suboptimal.
| Task | ACT | K (rollouts) | FTLE-max | First-step | Random-step | PTRM |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Maze-TRM | 16 | 50 | 91.00% | 87.20% | 88.70% | 88.90% |
| Sudoku-TRM | 10 | 50 | 98.40% | 97.63% | 97.70% | 97.53% |
| PPBench-TRM | 48 | 100 | 71.4% | 65.31% | 69.39% | 69.39% |
| ARC-AGI-2 | 10 | 25 | 8.33% | 6.67% | 7.50% | 5.83% |
We believe this perspective may also offer insights into broader reasoning systems. For example, multi-agent LLM reasoning explores alternative solution paths through parallel exploration and discussion. Our findings suggest that not only the diversity of explored trajectories, but also when to initiate such exploration, may be important. Extending this principle to LLMs remains an interesting direction for future work.
We sincerely thank the reviewer again for their thoughtful and constructive feedback, which has helped us strengthen our work and its positioning. We hope the our clarifications and additional experiments have adequately addressed the concerns and respectfully ask the reviewer if they could reconsider their overall assessment in light of the new evidence.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for taking the time to carefully understand our work, despite coming from a different research background. We particularly appreciate your strong expertise in LLMs and the valuable insights you have offered from a broader, cross-disciplinary perspective. Your comments have helped us recognize important opportunities to improve the motivation, positioning, and presentation of our work. We believe that addressing these points will make our contributions more accessible and relevant to a broader research community.
1. Motivation for studying TRM and relevance to LLMs
We thank the reviewer for highlighting the need to clarify our motivation and the relationship between TRM and LLM reasoning. We agree that our original presentation did not sufficiently distinguish the broader motivation from the specific model and setting investigated in this work.
Our motivation is a general phenomenon also observed in LLMs: different inference procedures can produce substantially different outcomes from the same trained model, as demonstrated by alternative CoT decoding and self-consistency (Wang and Zhou, 2024; Wang et al., 2023). This raises the question of how inference dynamics may limit the utilization of a model's learned capabilities.
We study this question in TRM because its explicit recurrent hidden-state dynamics allow us to track trajectories, quantify their local sensitivity using FTLE, and experimentally investigate targeted interventions. We do not claim to solve LLM reasoning problems directly, but believe that understanding this mechanism in a tractable model may offer insights relevant to more general reasoning systems.
We also agree that TRM's compact architecture and computational efficiency are important motivations for its study. Our method introduces additional test-time computation, and we do not claim to retain the inference cost of vanilla TRM. Rather, our contribution is to improve how this additional computation is allocated, achieving better performance than perturbation-based alternatives such as PTRM under comparable computational budgets. The benchmarks serve as controlled testbeds for studying these inference dynamics, rather than demonstrating superiority over LLM agents.
We will revise the introduction to clarify this motivation, the scope of our contribution, and its potential relevance to the broader reasoning community.