acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Readable Constraints, Unreliable Decisions: A Constraint-Instantiation Lens on Language Model Errors

Abstract

Natural answers expose a model’s final judgment, but may not express all task-relevant information recoverable from its internal states. We study whether suchrecoverable information tracks the truth required by the current input and whetherdisagreement between recoverable truth and the model’s decision can diagnoseerrors. In a verifiable Fact–Rule–Action (FRA) setting, we distinguish task-definedlocal truth, hidden-state readouts, and natural responses. Correct local truth remainsrecoverable under answer errors, and frozen readouts systematically track truth-changing edits to facts, rules, and action arguments across new worlds. On aheld-out controlled cohort, readout–answer disagreement strongly ranks natural-answer errors. We further extend the same truth-readout principle to natural QA,where the model’s realized answer instantiates the proposition to be evaluated. Theresulting error-oriented post-answer readout, FRA-ER, improves error ranking overother baselines on several tasks across several model families.

Primary area:
interpretability and explainable AI
Keywords:
language model interpretability, mechanistic interpretability, constraint reasoning, internal representations, error detection, planning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_22pzOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates whether task-relevant truth can be recovered from LLM hidden states even when generated answers are incorrect, using controlled Fact–Rule–Action tasks and semantic interventions. The authors further propose FRA-ER, a hidden-state-based error detection method that improves error prediction over existing baselines across multiple QA tasks and model families.

Critical strengths

The paper provides well-designed controlled experiments and extensive empirical evaluations, demonstrating the effectiveness of hidden-state-based error detection across multiple tasks.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited novelty and missing citation. The paper overlooks closely related prior work, such as Reasoning Models Know When They're Right (COLM 2025), and does not clearly establish its novelty beyond existing hidden-state correctness probing methods.

  2. Disconnect between contributions. The controlled FRA experiments and natural QA error detection seem loosely connected, as FRA-ER essentially reduces to supervised correctness probing without explicit constraint instantiation.

Questions for authors

What evidence connects the truth–decision disagreement observed in controlled FRA tasks to the effectiveness of FRA-ER on natural QA, where error detection is performed through direct supervised probing?

Reviewer_GDQfOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper addresses a relevant problem concerning the relationship between internal representations and language-model errors. Although the results are promising, I have significant concerns about the novelty, methodological justification, and presentation of the work. In particular, the central motivation substantially overlaps with existing literature, and the proposed Fact–Rule–Action (FRA) framework does not clearly establish a sufficiently distinct scientific contribution. Moreover, the connection between the controlled experiments and natural-QA error detection is not convincingly demonstrated.

Critical strengths
  • The paper addresses an important problem in understanding language-model errors and the information contained in hidden representations.
  • The controlled experiments provide useful evidence that internal readouts respond to semantic changes in facts, rules, and action arguments.
  • The natural-QA experiments report promising error-detection results across several datasets.
Critical weaknesses
  • The central motivation closely overlaps with Truth as a Trajectory (Damirchi et al., ACL 2026), which investigates how internal representations reveal reasoning validity beyond final model outputs. The absence of this relevant work makes the novelty difficult to assess. Furthermore, the proposed approach relies on static probing, whose limitations have already been investigated in prior work.
  • The proposed framework is essentially a structured procedure for constructing prompts and assigning ground-truth labels. Its use of action preconditions, argument binding, and symbolic evaluation is closely related to established planning formulations (Fox and Long, 2003). The authors do not sufficiently explain what new scientific insight this construction provides beyond existing evaluation approaches. -The controlled experiments investigate the recoverability of independently defined truth, whereas FRA-ER is directly trained on generated-answer correctness labels. These objectives are related but not equivalent. The natural-QA results demonstrate supervised error detection, but do not necessarily establish that correct information remains internally represented when the model produces an incorrect answer.
  • The main experiments are restricted to two model families, although additional Qwen scaling experiments are provided.
  • The method introduces approximately 46% additional generation latency for feature acquisition. This is a substantial overhead, and its practical justification is insufficiently discussed. The computational evaluation also excludes the larger models considered in the scaling experiments.

References

  1. Damirchi, H., et al. (2026). Truth as a Trajectory: What Internal Representations Reveal About Large Language Model Reasoning. ACL 2026.
  2. Fox, M., & Long, D. (2003). PDDL2.1: An Extension to PDDL for Expressing Temporal Planning Domains. Journal of Artificial Intelligence Research, 20, 61–124.
Questions for authors
  • What is the fundamental novelty of FRA compared with existing symbolic planning frameworks and correctness-labeled probing approaches? What scientific conclusions are enabled specifically by this formulation?
  • How does the proposed approach differ from Truth as a Trajectory (Damirchi et al., 2026), particularly regarding the recoverability of correctness information from internal representations? Why is this closely related work not discussed and not compared as a baseline?
  • How do the authors justify treating controlled truth recovery and post-answer correctness prediction as evidence of the same underlying phenomenon?
  • Why do the evaluated sample counts differ between models, and how does this affect the fairness of the comparisons? Additionally, why is generation confidence particularly weak in the controlled experiments?
  • Could the required hidden-state representations be collected during the original generation pass to reduce computational overhead?How does the cost scale to the 14B and 32B models?
Reviewer_94nLOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The authors propose a method to read out internal states of the model and cross-check a classifier trained on them with the model's generated answer. They study this in a synthetic Fact–Rule–Action planning-style task, finding that the probes can often recover the correct answer even when the model makes a mistake, and that probe–answer disagreement appears to be a useful signal for flagging errors. They also study a related probe in QA settings, trained to directly predict whether the answer is correct, which outperforms generation confidence in most cases but shows only modest gains over other probing baselines.

Critical strengths
  • The authors provide a controlled setting to study this with the FRA task, providing more insights than just relying on probe answer accuracy alone.
  • The authors cover both binary and free form answer forms in their study.
Critical weaknesses
  • The writing is very dense and difficult to follow at times. Many of the phrases used throughout the paper could be simplified, and noticed excessive hedging (especially where it is contrastive and does not need to be)
  • Novelty of the method is limited, ultimately being a linear probe on hidden states. That you can recover the answer from hidden answer states of a model seems apparent already. The paper would also benefit from a direct comparison with probe proposed in the following paper, which is quite similar: https://arxiv.org/html/2410.02707v2.
Questions for authors

Have the authors studied this in longer free-form generation? And how does this scale to tasks where there is more complex information in the context (the FRA tasks are small with few facts and rules)?

Does the query in the experiments consistently name the grounded condition being checked (as in the provided examples)? This could be recovered by just cross-checking with the fact list, making the probe's success largely a look-up/matching problem. The appendix also mentions both 'role' and 'grounded' versions (the latter being in the main results), but 'role' appears to potentially be more useful since the model at least has to make the connection between the rule and the action's arguments; please report those results.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.