acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

QVRMem: Query-Time Validation and Reanswering for Evolving Memory

Abstract

Retrieving an update does not ensure that generated answers reflect it. We present QVRMem (Query-time Validation and Reanswering for Memory), a query-time method that separates dependency validation from question-directed reanswering. Validation checks facts that may shape the response before answer construction. For eligible queries, reanswering acquires associated records and reassesses the question using accumulated raw evidence. This readout distinguishes refuting an outdated proposition from identifying the current value, while handling applicable withdrawal requests. By retaining raw records, the method avoids generation-model token usage during memory construction. With Qwen3.5-9B, QVRMem reaches 73.00% accuracy on STALE and 38.50% on MEME's evolving-information tasks, exceeding the strongest evaluated baselines by 23.52 and 15.94 percentage points, respectively. Ablations show different strengths in stale-premise handling and state-sensitive answering. With DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash, the full method reaches 79.17% accuracy on STALE and 48.99% on MEME.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
long-term memory, conversational question answering, memory retrieval, large language models

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_eYFbOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces QVRMem, a "Query-time Memory Reasoning" framework designed to address a common issue in Large Language Model (LLM) agents: the tendency to generate responses based on outdated facts or assumptions, even after retrieving updated information. The framework consists of two complementary components: "Dependency Validation" (V), which verifies potentially outdated facts before a response is generated; and "Question-directed Reanswering" (R), which re-evaluates the original query by leveraging previously accumulated memory evidence.

Critical strengths
  1. Clear and Practical Motivation. The paper addresses an important limitation of existing memory systems: retrieving updated information does not guarantee that the generated answer reflects the latest state.
  2. Useful Ablation Studies. The authors evaluate the contributions of validation and reanswering separately, providing insights into their effectiveness across different types of memory tasks.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited methodological novelty. The proposed QVRMem framework primarily combines existing techniques, including query decomposition, evidence verification, iterative retrieval, and answer refinement, into a multi-stage prompt-based pipeline. Although the overall performance is promising, the core operations appear largely achievable through relatively straightforward prompt engineering. More importantly, the paper lacks comparisons with simpler iterative prompting or self-refinement baselines under comparable inference budgets.

  2. High Inference-Time Computational Overhead and Lack of Budget-Matched Comparisons. QVRMem introduces substantial inference-time overhead due to its multi-stage validation, retrieval, and reanswering pipeline.

Questions for authors

See weakness.

Reviewer_KqoCOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies long-term conversational memory when information changes over time. Its premise is that retrieving an update does not guarantee the answer reflects it. QVRMem is a training-free, query-time pipeline over raw dialogue records (no LLM-based memory construction) with two modules:

  • V (dependency validation): before the shared reader writes a draft, the model proposes one factual check (including explicit premises in the query), retrieves evidence with three views (original query, the check, and a fixed "changed/updated/no longer current" expansion), answers the check, and passes verification notes plus raw records to the reader.
  • R (question-directed reanswering): for queries routed as current factual lookups that also have a qualifying associative retrieval path, the method expands evidence through semantic-neighbor hops, recognizes withdrawal requests (and then returns a fixed "This information is no longer available."), and either runs a three-way proposition validator (SUPPORTED/REFUTED/INSUFFICIENT → Yes/No/"I don't have enough information") or re-reads the evidence with the draft treated as a fallible proposal.

With Qwen3.5-9B the paper reports 73.00% on STALE and 38.50% on five MEME evolving-information tasks (Exact Recall excluded), +23.52 and +15.94 pp over the strongest evaluated baselines (CUPMem and NaiveRAG). With DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash it reports 79.17% / 48.99%. A 2×2 V/R factorial ablation suggests V drives most of the STALE gain (especially Premise Resistance) and R drives most of the MEME gain (especially Deletion). Build-time generation cost is zero; QA cost is about 9–10k input tokens and about 7 calls per question.

Critical strengths
  1. Clear problem decomposition with a matching ablation. The paper names a real failure mode: the reader sees the update but still builds on the stale premise. It separates it into (a) dependencies that shape answer construction and (b) the judgment the question actually asks for. The 2×2 ablation (Fig. 3, Table 2) supports this split: V alone takes Premise Resistance from 2.75% to 70.93%, while R alone barely moves it (4.00%); R alone takes MEME Deletion from 0% to 82%. This is the most convincing evidence that the two components do different jobs and are not interchangeable.
  2. Strong accuracy at no build-time generation cost, with full transparency. Keeping raw records removes the expensive LLM-based memory construction of Mem0/CUPMem/EverMemOS (Table 1: e.g., Mem0 uses about 2.7M input tokens per STALE dialogue). QA cost is also well below CUPMem's (9.69k vs 32.25k input tokens). All prompts, output contracts, and serialization rules are given verbatim (App. B), which makes the method easy to reproduce and audit.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Risk of benchmark-specific tuning without a held-out evaluation. Both evaluation sets appear to have also been used for development, and several design elements look closely matched to individual benchmark task types:

    • Withdrawal recognition returns the fixed string "This information is no longer available.", which lines up with MEME Deletion. This is where R's 0% → 82% jump comes from.
    • The general-readout rule "If an old value is invalidated but no … raw statement supplies the replacement, report that the current value is unknown," together with the INSUFFICIENT rendering, lines up with Knowledge Absence.
    • The "raw conditional rule + condition ⇒ consequence; apply successive rules" instruction lines up with Cascading Updates.
    • The query-interpretation prompt has hand-written rules for "still / am I / does the user still" phrasings, which match STALE's question templates.

    The paper also says the MEME scope (dropping Exact Recall) "was selected after the initial experiments" (L245–247). With no development/test split, no third benchmark, and no check on general memory QA (e.g., LoCoMo, LongMemEval), I cannot tell how much of the +15–24 pp comes from a general method and how much from prompt engineering against these two test sets. There are also signs of regressions on ordinary questions. With DeepSeek, QVRMem is clearly worse than NaiveRAG on Aggregation (47 vs 66) and Tracking (70 vs 78) (L300–302). In the ablation, the full method is worse than single modules on Deletion (69.70 vs 82.00) and Cascading Updates (19.75 vs 24.07). This is central to my rating: the main claim is a general query-time method, but the evidence is consistent with a pipeline fitted to two benchmarks.

  2. Missing key controls and doubts about the baseline numbers.

    • Missing simple controls. The obvious alternatives are absent: (i) a full-context reader (MEME is a 32K-filler setting and the model has a 32K context), (ii) NaiveRAG with the same 24-record budget and the same number of calls (e.g., self-consistency or a CoVe/Self-Refine pass over raw retrieval). Without these, it is unclear whether the gains come from V/R's specific design or simply from about 7× more query-time compute and evidence.
    • Suspicious baseline values. CUPMem, the strongest baseline on STALE (49.48%), gets 4.69% on MEME, far below NaiveRAG (22.56%). That suggests misconfiguration or a format mismatch with the judge. The DeepSeek STALE comparison leaves out CUPMem, StructMem, Mem0, and EverMemOS.
    • Inconsistent denominators. Several Table 2 values (70.93, 56.39, 50.51, 60.61, 3.03, 69.70, 49.49) do not correspond to the denominators implied by other cells (STALE tasks look like n=400 elsewhere; MEME 49.00/60.00 look like n=100 while 50.51/60.61/3.03 look like n=99). This suggests some items were dropped or failed in some configurations but not others.
    • Weak statistics. There are no seeds, confidence intervals, or significance tests. The judge is Qwen3.5-35B-A3B rather than the benchmarks' original judge, and it is not validated against humans. The authors themselves note that "coupled benchmark judgments can change a score even when the corresponding answer is unchanged."
Questions for authors
  1. Were the prompts in App. B (routing rules, fixed withdrawal string, cascading-rule instruction, "still"-phrasing rules) iterated on STALE/MEME test items? Is there any held-out portion, or any evaluation on a benchmark not used during development? Results on LoCoMo or LongMemEval (including non-update categories) would address both overfitting and regression concerns.
  2. Please explain the per-task denominators in Table 2 (e.g., how is 70.93% on Premise Resistance or 3.03% on MEME Deletion obtained?). Were any items excluded, failed, or timed out, and does this differ across configurations and baselines?
  3. Why does CUPMem score 4.69% on MEME? Did you check its outputs against the judge's expected format? Why is CUPMem missing from the DeepSeek STALE comparison?
  4. What is the accuracy of (a) a full-history long-context reader and (b) NaiveRAG with a matched retrieval budget (24 records) and a matched number of calls?
  5. What are the results on MEME Exact Recall, which was excluded after initial experiments? Even a weak number would help readers judge the trade-off.
  6. How often does R trigger (fraction of queries with T=1), and how accurate is the routing (χ, withdrawal recognition) on its own?
  7. Have you checked the Qwen3.5-35B-A3B judge against the benchmarks' official judges or against human labels on a sample?
Reviewer_1XGtOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

One-line Summary.

This paper proposes QvrMem, a framework for better understanding evolving conversational memory. This is supported by two steps, dependency validation (V) and question-directed reanswering (R), while keeping raw records as the stored memory.

 

Limitation of Prior Work.

Existing memory approaches have a problem of "Retrieved but not reflected": an assistant can retrieve a later update but still answer from an outdated premise or state.

 

Core Idea: 2-step approach.

  • Dependency validation (V): derives a factual check from the query and initial evidence
  • Intermediate draft (B): written after V
  • Question-directed reanswering (R): expands evidence through associative retrieval over raw records

 

Effect.

With Qwen3.5-9B, QvrMem reaches the best performance on evolving-information tasks such as MEME and STALE, exceeding the strongest evaluated baselines (CUPMem and NaiveRAG) by 23.52 and 15.94 percentage points.

Critical strengths

(1) Impressive accuracy gains on both evolving-memory benchmarks (Table 1)

The performance gain is large and consistent across Qwen3.5-9B and DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash, evaluated on STALE and MEME.

 

(2) Clear and timely problem formulation

Memory for long-running agents has become an increasingly important topic. I agree with the authors' discussion on the limitation, where retrieval of new updates does not always guarantee correct answers.

 

(3) Clarity of figures

The figures in the paper (especially Figure 2) are clearly helpful for understanding the framework.

 

Critical weaknesses

(1) The efficiency claim is stated more strongly than Table 1 supports

  • While the authors claim "lower generation-token usage in both construction and answering", it holds only against a specific baseline (CUPMem). Against others such as NaiveRAG and LightMem, the proposed QvrMem uses roughly 4.7x and 9x the input tokens with 7.54 calls per question.
  • The above concern can be resolved when the authors narrow the claim, but the experiments are also unclear in showing the cost-performance trade-off. Although the authors analyzed token usage, token counts do not reveal the response time that can arise from the multiple retrievals in QvrMem. At minimum, I encourage the authors to include end-to-end latency per query.

 

(2) Limited evaluation on two benchmarks with no variance

Both benchmarks seem to be evaluated with a single run, and the number of questions per task is not stated. On MEME, each task has roughly 100 questions, which is small in scale in my view. Also, analysis on STALE usually includes a Type I / Type II breakdown, but it is missing in the paper. Overall, the evaluation leaves considerable room for improvement.

 

(3) Potential performance inflation in MEME Deletion and Absence by abstention

The authors of MEME acknowledge that in some tasks, abstention (e.g., the WITHDRAWN, UNCERTAIN, and INSUFFICIENT labels) can lead to unintended performance gains. Reporting this rate would help reduce this concern.

 

(4) No robustness analysis or hyperparameter analysis

  • Using raw records (e.g., E_B, E_V) can be a good strategy, but one concern is the noise in these records. Since the proposed QvrMem supports withdrawal in the reanswering stage (R), stress-testing these cases would further strengthen the authors' choice of storing raw records.
  • In addition, the framework includes many hyperparameters, for example, the number of retrieved records. A sensitivity analysis on these hyperparameters would be helpful for increasing usability.

 

Overall, I find the problem formulation and the empirical margins promising, but my score is driven mainly by (1), (2), and (3).

Questions for authors

Q1. Advantage over StateMem

StateMem (Fan et al., 2026) seems to apply a similar strategy, but with fewer LLM calls due to their "wrapper" design. I know that this work is concurrent given its publication date, but could the authors briefly clarify the relationship between the two works?

 

Q2. Judge and generator from the same model family

The generator is Qwen3.5-9B and the judge is Qwen3.5-35B-A3B for both benchmarks. I encourage the authors to avoid selecting an LLM judge from the same family as the answerer model, as it may introduce internal bias (output format, etc.). This is a widely known issue in the LLM-judge evaluation literature.

 

Q3. Exclusion of Exact Recall

The authors state that Exact Recall was excluded after initial experiments. Can you briefly explain why?

 

Reference: Fan et al., Can Agent Memory Systems Track Evolving State?, arXiv 2026.

Comments on the paper

1 comment

Dear Reviewers,

The authors have now submitted their responses. Please review them and indicate whether your concerns have been addressed. Please also update your scores if the responses have changed your assessment.

Thank you.

AC

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.