- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper is concerned with the limitations of "personal memory", and analyzes failure cases in various ways.
Critical strengths
Compared to lots of papers at ICLR, trying to evaluate some specific failure cases, and draw attention to some important issues is a nice contribution, and different from what most other papers are looking at.
The basic thrusts that are being analyzed (i.e., the different failure types, etc.) are reasonable and cover some of the main bases.
Critical weaknesses
The actual technical presentation of the technical sections is okay but difficult to follow, and really weighed down with notation. It is hard to tell how much the analysis here really gets at the main "points" it's trying to analyze, versus how much the results are due to some slightly arbitrary technical choice. Perhaps this is something the authors could address in rebuttal.
While I think the basic flavor of the analysis is interesting enough, I think a paper like this one that is more based on analysis and less based on having a specific technical contribution, will struggle to gain traction among the thousands of papers at ICLR.
In places the actual technical contribution here (the way the analysis is performed, etc.) is not all that deep. I think it's fine and serves its purpose but the paper could probably have gone further here.
Questions for authors
see above