acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Stale, Misattributed, or Late: Where Personal Memory Fails Before Generation

Abstract

Personal memory for language agents is usually judged by whether the final answer is correct. That score hides errors that arise before generation: the memory block may contain an obsolete value, a fact about the wrong person, or no useful fact before the serving deadline. We measure these failures directly. Using Personal Fact Memory (PFM) as a reference layer, we find that temporal validity is primarily a property of memory construction in our setting. On a controlled revision benchmark, serving only the active value of each correctly keyed slot eliminates observed stale exposure; without update resolution, 70.3% of prompts expose a superseded value. Once retrievers share the same active store and participant information, participant-aware BM25 is equivalent to the reference ranker within a prespecified margin. The harder problem is assigning revisions to the right slot. Missed merges leave stale values active, whereas false merges silently remove current values; four LLM key assigners achieve higher key recall than a rule extractor yet produce lower clean-retrieval rates, and open-domain merge recall on LongMemEval never exceeds 0.062. Misattribution survives validity filtering: an entity posterior reduces same-name exposure on controlled data but cannot distinguish identically named speakers in LoCoMo. Two frozen language models reproduce prompt errors in generated text. Retrieval latency varies across rankers, but prompt prefill dominates turn-level latency on our hardware. These results argue for evaluating agent memory before generation, separating stored-state validity, identity resolution, abstention, and serving latency.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
LLM agents, long-term memory, agent memory, temporal memory, memory evaluation, retrieval-augmented generation, entity resolution, inference latency

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_2iswOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper is concerned with the limitations of "personal memory", and analyzes failure cases in various ways.

Critical strengths

Compared to lots of papers at ICLR, trying to evaluate some specific failure cases, and draw attention to some important issues is a nice contribution, and different from what most other papers are looking at.

The basic thrusts that are being analyzed (i.e., the different failure types, etc.) are reasonable and cover some of the main bases.

Critical weaknesses

The actual technical presentation of the technical sections is okay but difficult to follow, and really weighed down with notation. It is hard to tell how much the analysis here really gets at the main "points" it's trying to analyze, versus how much the results are due to some slightly arbitrary technical choice. Perhaps this is something the authors could address in rebuttal.

While I think the basic flavor of the analysis is interesting enough, I think a paper like this one that is more based on analysis and less based on having a specific technical contribution, will struggle to gain traction among the thousands of papers at ICLR.

In places the actual technical contribution here (the way the analysis is performed, etc.) is not all that deep. I think it's fine and serves its purpose but the paper could probably have gone further here.

Questions for authors

see above

Reviewer_5ZwXOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates failures in personal memory systems that occur before LLM response generation, focusing on stale information, misattribution, and retrieval latency. Using PFM as a reference framework, the authors evaluate memory validity, key assignment, identity resolution, abstention, and serving efficiency. Their results show that correctly keyed memory updates eliminate observed stale exposure in controlled settings, while imperfect key assignment and identity ambiguity remain major challenges. The paper emphasizes the importance of evaluating memory quality at the retrieval stage rather than relying solely on final-answer accuracy.

Critical strengths
  • The problems statement and motivation is clear, where it separates failure modes that answer accuracy metrics conflate by introducing the three variations of errors: stale, misattribution, retrieval being late. The implications, when the paper is well supported with extra experiments and modifications mentioned below, might be promising, where the importance of memory update or participant information can be shown through the paper.
Critical weaknesses
  • The paper is really difficult to follow compared to the details or formulations that are needed to explain concepts. I believe that most of the mathematical notations are excessive compared to what the authors are trying to explain. For instance, proposition is near-trivial. Moreover, some figures describing the whole process or motivation would benefit the paper.

  • Regarding the results and experiments, the findings and results are somewhat expected than informative. For instance, prefill dominating latency, BM25 matching PFM with the same active store are easily expected. Although the authors do some evaluation and find some challenging aspects such as abstention difficulties or entity resolution problems having the namesake problems, no methodologies to overcome these are proposed. The key mechanisms are already established in this field. Considering this part, this paper should be seen as an evaluation resource or benchmarking paper. However, this paper does not provide broad evaluation settings as a benchmark paper. Most quantitative conclusions come from a generator with three templates per slot, globally unique values, a known six-slot inventory, and correct participant metadata. More diverse settings with variations in models and datasets (beyond controlled synthetic datasets; more public benchmark experiments) are needed to strengthen the paper.

Questions for authors
  • Can the analyses be more scalable? Not only using the whole LongMemEval questions, but also on other datasets. As mentioned in the weakness section, it is hard to say that the findings have generality.
Reviewer_qn9nOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies failures of personal memory for LLM agents that happen before generation: stale values, facts about the wrong person, and memory that arrives too late. The authors define prompt-level metrics, including current-value recall, stale exposure, misattribution, abstention, and clean retrieval by deadline. They evaluate them using a reference store (PFM) that applies standard keyed supersession. On a synthetic templated benchmark, they show that serving only active facts removes stale exposure, and they study the effects of key noise, LLM key assignment, an entity posterior for same-name ambiguity, and abstention gates. They also report smaller studies on LongMemEval and LoCoMo, response-level experiments with two small quantized LMs, and latency measurements.

Critical strengths
  1. Separating memory failures at the prompt level is a reasonable diagnostic idea. The observation that missed merges leave stale values visible, while false merges silently delete current values, is a clear way to describe the trade-off in key assignment.
  2. The statistical treatment on the controlled benchmark is careful. The authors use chain-clustered bootstrap intervals, a TOST equivalence test with a stated margin, leave-one-out ablations, and reweighting by revision depth. However, this rigor is mostly applied to a setting where the main conclusions follow from the design of the benchmark.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper has no clear central thesis. It covers prompt-level metrics, key noise, LLM key assignment, open-domain key discovery, identity resolution, abstention gates, query-time model baselines, response-level effects, a snapshot-serving bound, CPython scheduling, store-size scaling, and lexical-versus-dense crossover points. Each topic gets a short result, and the conclusions often differ between corpora. The reference system shows the same lack of focus: Table 13 shows that the graph, usage term, term cap, and usage inheritance in PFM change none of the 1,200 query outcomes, yet they are still presented as part of the method. The reader is left with many small observations but no single claim that the paper establishes.
  2. The key-assignment comparison is strongly influenced by the benchmark design. The rule extractor is tailored to the templates, while shared slot vocabulary causes many of the LLM errors. Rejected paraphrases also retain the original templates. These choices make it difficult to generalize the observed advantage of rules over LLM-based assignment.
  3. Validation beyond the controlled setting is limited. The filtered LongMemEval subset is small and does not clearly separate the methods. On LoCoMo, answer retrieval is poor, and the same-name failure partly reflects the system’s entity representation. The latency analysis is also specific to one laptop and a CPython implementation. Together, these experiments provide limited evidence that the findings extend to broader memory systems.
Questions for authors
  1. What is the single main claim of the paper, and which experiment establishes it? In particular, beyond MemStrata and TOKI, what does Section 7.1 show that does not follow directly from the definition of keyed supersession? If the authors can state a contribution that is new and not determined by the benchmark design, I would be open to revising my assessment.
  2. How do the results in Section 7.2 change if the room and meeting slots no longer share nouns, if only accepted rewrites are used, and if a current strong model assigns the keys? If the ranking between LLM keys and rule keys reverses under these controls, the main message of that section would not hold.
  3. Please explain the reporting inconsistencies: the LongMemEval turn counts (2,369 vs. 2,587), the PFM clean retrieval values (0.877 vs. 0.894), and the empty Appendix J. Are these reporting errors, or were different query subsets or calculation methods used?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.