- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies whether synthetic labels can improve the conditional coverage of conformal prediction when only a limited number of trusted labels are available. The authors propose prediction-powered quantile learning, which uses a bias-corrected pinball-loss objective to incorporate synthetic labels into conditional quantile estimation, followed by independent conformal calibration to preserve finite-sample marginal coverage. Theoretically, the paper analyzes the effect of final conformalization using a profiled pinball risk and a post-conformal influence map. It further derives a three-resource asymptotic error decomposition and an optimal synthetic-power rule. Experiments on eight regression datasets and HelpSteer2 demonstrate improvements in conditional coverage and prediction-set efficiency.
Critical strengths
-
The paper goes beyond studying conditional quantile estimation accuracy and analyzes how learning errors propagate through the final conformal calibration step. In particular, the global-shift invariance and density-weighted post-conformal influence analysis provide useful insights into which components of estimation error affect downstream conditional coverage.
-
The three-resource expansion separates the contributions of trusted learning data, synthetic-pool estimation, and final calibration. The resulting optimal-power rule provides a theoretical explanation of when synthetic labels can improve downstream efficiency and why synthetic-label quality alone does not determine their usefulness.
-
The paper evaluates the proposed approach on eight regression datasets and an LLM-generated rating task. The experiments include comparisons with several existing conformal prediction methods and investigate synthetic-label quality, synthetic-pool size, and label scarcity.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited novelty of the core learning algorithm: The prediction-powered quantile-learning objective in Eq. (6) appears to be a relatively direct application of existing PPI control-variate techniques to the pinball loss, followed by established CQR or RCP calibration procedures. Related work on prediction-powered semi-supervised learning has already investigated bias-corrected learning objectives and power selection. Therefore, the main novelty of this paper seems to lie primarily in its post-conformal theoretical analysis rather than in the proposed learning algorithm itself.
-
Insufficient empirical validation of the optimal synthetic-power analysis: Although Corollary 3.8 derives a theoretically optimal synthetic power, the main experiments use a fixed . The RCP-PPI-CV baseline selects based on trusted pinball validation, rather than the proposed post-conformal efficiency criterion. A systematic sensitivity analysis of , together with experiments using the theoretically motivated power estimator, would help demonstrate the practical value of the theoretical results.
-
Insufficient justification of the augmentation baseline: RCP-Aug uses a fixed synthetic-loss coefficient of 0.5 without a clear justification or sensitivity analysis. This choice may influence its comparison with RCP-PPI, especially since RCP-Aug achieves better MSCE on some datasets. Furthermore, in the oracle-label experiments, the synthetic labels correspond to hidden true outcomes, making uniform pooling over the correctly labeled samples a natural reference. Although RCP-Pool is discussed in the appendix, its results are not included.
-
Limited analysis of the connection between theoretical efficiency and empirical conditional coverage: Theorem 3.7 characterizes stochastic error around the population-calibrated reference , whereas total MSCE under model misspecification also includes approximation and interaction terms. Although the paper acknowledges this distinction, its practical implications are not thoroughly investigated. In particular, it remains unclear how well the theoretically optimal power predicts the best downstream conditional coverage performance on real datasets.
Questions for authors
-
Could the authors clarify the methodological differences between Eq. (6) and existing prediction-powered semi-supervised learning objectives, particularly those employing bias-corrected losses and adaptive power selection? Beyond the post-conformal theoretical analysis, what are the main algorithmic innovations?
-
Could the authors provide a -sensitivity analysis on the main regression benchmarks and explain why is used throughout the main experiments instead of the theoretically optimal power derived in Corollary 3.8 or used in RCP-Aug?
-
What motivates the fixed coefficient of 0.5 in RCP-Aug? Would the conclusions change under different augmentation weights? In Table 11, since oracle labels correspond to hidden true outcomes, could the authors include uniform pooling over all correctly labeled observations as a reference?
-
In Table 1, RCP-Aug achieves lower MSCE than RCP-PPI on SGEMM and WEC and sometimes outperforms RCP-PPI-CV. Could the authors further investigate these cases, particularly whether the differences arise from synthetic-label bias, estimation variance, or the choice of ?
-
Since the optimal-power rule is derived from the leading stochastic error around , how sensitive is it to misspecification of the conditional quantile model? Could the authors provide additional experiments examining whether minimizing the theoretical efficiency criterion also improves total MSCE?
Thank you for the detailed and thoughtful rebuttal. I appreciate the additional experiments and the careful clarification of the theoretical contributions, which address many of my concerns.
I have one further question regarding scalability to high-dimensional covariate spaces, such as long-form LLM responses in LLM-as-a-judge evaluation or high-dimensional feature embeddings in scientific discovery.
Since the proposed method relies on learning an input-dependent conditional quantile through a PPI-corrected objective, I wonder whether limited trusted labels could lead to unstable optimization, high-variance bias correction, or overfitting as the covariate dimension increases. Estimating the curvature and covariance terms required for optimal synthetic-power selection may also become challenging. Although marginal coverage remains valid through independent calibration, would meaningful improvements in conditional coverage still be expected in these settings?
I understand that additional experiments may be difficult within the rebuttal period, so a conceptual discussion of these challenges, possible remedies, and expected performance would be sufficient. I would be happy to reconsider my assessment based on further clarification.