- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
Regular online conformal prediction targets marginal coverage and may fail on several subgroups. Recent work on group online conformal prediction addresses this issue; performance depends on the learning rate. To address this, this paper borrows the idea from Liu et al. (2026), i.e., online conformal prediction without learning-rate tuning, and extends it to group online conformal prediction. This paper provides a coverage rate theorem, conducts convergence analysis and comparisons, and runs experiments on both synthetic and real datasets.
Critical strengths
- The narrative is logically clear and friendly. The method is clean and easy to understand.
- The paper’s detailed analysis and comparisons in the theorem sections are strong.
Critical weaknesses
- Although the parameter-free online group conformal is new, the contribution is not big. This paper is a modest extension of the existing work Liu et al. (2026), i.e., from marginal to group-wise coverage.
- The abstract’s bold claim “the strongest group-coverage guarantees among existing methods” actually cannot be fully supported by the theoretical bound (the author acknowledges that in line 267).
- The empirical results, especially in Figure 2, show that POGO has a larger gap to the target coverage, contradicting the claim in the conclusion: “experiments on synthetic and real-world data show that POGO consistently attains the target coverage level for every group”
Questions for authors
- Line 215: What do you mean by this augmentation? Will the be augmented accordingly? Could you articulate this?
- Line 428: This is a gap compared to what the authors did for with time-indexed. Here, the authors even train the base model first and then compare the method on the test dataset. Can you train f at the same time?
- Can you provide the trajectory of the online sequence instead of the terminal step's () results? The worst group at is not necessarily the same as earlier. The full sequence can provide more information.