acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Mistake-Bounded Language Generation

Abstract

We investigate the learning task of language generation in the limit, but shift focus from the traditional time-of-last-mistake metric of a generator's success to a new notion of *mistake-bounded generation*. While existing results for language generation in the limit focus on guaranteeing eventual consistency, they are blind to the cumulative error incurred during the learning process. We address this by shifting the goal to minimizing the total number of invalid elements output by a generation algorithm. We establish a formal reduction to the Learning from Correct Demonstrations framework of Joshi et al., enabling a general recipe for deriving mistake bounds via weighted update rules. For finite classes, we provide an algorithm that simultaneously achieves an optimal last-mistake time of and a mistake bound of , whereas for the non-uniform setting of countably infinite streams of languages, we prove a fundamental trade-off: achieving logarithmic mistakes necessarily precludes convergence guarantees established in prior work. Finally, we show that our framework can be extended to accommodate noisy adversaries and guarantee mistake bounds that scale with the adversary's suboptimality.

Primary area:
learning theory
Keywords:
language generation in the limit, online learning, learning theory, mistake-bounded, generation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 4%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 3.33 over 3 reviews, above 96% of the others.
Reviewer_aB8BOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies cumulative mistake bounds for language generation and their relationship to convergence time. It develops finite- and countable-class guarantees and claims a trade-off between achieving few mistakes and preserving fast convergence.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper asks a well-motivated theoretical question. While prior work focuses on when a generator stops making errors, this paper asks how many errors it makes in total, and whether minimizing cumulative errors forces them to occur later.
  2. The finite-class result successfully achieves both goals at once. With NN candidate languages, the proposed algorithm makes at most ⌊log⁡2N⌋\lfloor\log_2 N\rfloor mistakes while still matching the optimal convergence deadline (subject to the indexing clarification noted below). Moreover, this logarithmic mistake bound is tight against a matching worst-case lower bound.
  3. The claimed trade-off for infinite classes is compelling. It suggests that an algorithm cannot always simultaneously achieve a logarithmic mistake bound and the convergence deadline established in prior work.
Critical weaknesses

The proof of Theorem 6.4 needs clarification. It attempts to force a mistake late enough to violate the assumed O(max⁡{i,m(Li)})O(\max\{i, m(L_i)\}) bound on the time of the last mistake. However, for fixed nn, the constructed mistake time is only a constant multiple of m(Li)m(L_i): m(Li)+nim(Li)⟶n.\frac{m(L_i) + n^i}{m(L_i)} \longrightarrow n. Since the O(⋅)O(\cdot) bound allows an unspecified constant factor, this does not yield a contradiction. Choosing nn larger than the hidden constant might address this for a given algorithm, but then the hard language class would depend on the algorithm. This would not establish the theorem’s claim that a single fixed class suffices for all qualifying algorithms. Could the authors clarify how the proof establishes this claim?

Questions for authors

Please see weakness part.

2 comments

Thanks for your positive review! With regard to your point about the proof of Theorem 6.4, we believe you are referring to Theorem 6.3. In that proof, m(Li+1)=m(Li)+22im(L_{i+1})=m(L_i)+2^{2^i}, rather than m(Li)+nim(L_i)+n^i. Consequently, m(Li+1)/max⁡i,m(Li)→∞m(L_{i+1})/\max{i,m(L_i)}\to\infty, so the same fixed class works for every finite CGC_G. Please let us know if you still have concerns about the proof.

Thanks for the author's response. Now I have no concerns about the proof.

Reviewer_yZ2mOpenReview ↗
Rating
4
Confidence
4
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies mistake-bounded generation in the language generation model of Kleinberg and Mullainathan. In contrast with previous notions of uniform generation that consider the time of the last incorrect generation, this paper introduces the study of mistake-bounded generation where the algorithm tries instead to make the fewest number of mistakes possible. They show that for any finite collection L\mathcal{L}, there exists an algorithm that both achieves the optimal last-mistake Cdim(L)+1\text{Cdim}(\mathcal{L}) + 1 while achieving a mistake bound of ⌊log⁡2∣L∣⌋\lfloor\log_2{|\mathcal{L}|}\rfloor, which can be arbitrarily smaller than the closure dimension. This bound is also tight in that there exists a language class of every size NN on which any algorithm can be forced to make at least ⌊log⁡2N⌋\lfloor \log_2 N \rfloor mistakes. For infinite collections, the paper shows a bound of O(log⁡i)O(\log i) where ii is the index of the language is some ordering of L\mathcal{L}. Finally, they extend these results to the noisy setting.

Critical strengths

The paper introduces the notion of mistake-bounded generation, which is a natural new definition to study within the model of language generation in the limit. They also show compelling results that this definition is meaningful by proving that one can achieve much better bounds for the total number of mistakes compared to the time of the last mistake. Overall, the paper introduces a new framework that leaves open many interesting directions of future exploration.

Critical weaknesses

None

Questions for authors

(This question is more for my curiosity and won't affect my evaluation.) In Section 6, you say for infinite collections that “we cannot hope for a uniform bound on mistakes across the entire class.” Have you explored whether such a uniform mistake bound can exist for uniformly generatable infinite collections that is better than the guarantee given by closure dimension?

2 comments

We're glad to hear you enjoyed the paper! To your question, you are right that specific infinite classes can have a uniform mistake bound better than the closure-dimension guarantee. An example is an augmented version of Example 1, where infinitely many languages share a finite core and have pairwise disjoint infinite tails. The closure dimension is the size of the core, but a generator can make at most one mistake by outputting core elements until a tail element identifies the target or the core is exhausted.

Thank you for the answer to my question! I maintain my positive evaluation of the paper.

Reviewer_uD5HOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes evaluating language generation in the limit by the total number of invalid outputs, alongside the time of the last mistake. Example 1 shows that these metrics can differ arbitrarily.

Its main tool is a weighted-majority-style generator, formulated through a reduction to Learning from Correct Demonstrations (LfD), with a prior and a growth function for countable classes (Theorem 4.1). For finite classes, it makes at most min⁡⌊log⁡2∣L∣⌋,Cdim(L)+1\min\\{\lfloor\log_2|\mathcal{L}|\rfloor,\mathrm{Cdim}(\mathcal{L})+1\\} mistakes while retaining the optimal last-mistake guarantee (Theorem 5.1).

For countable classes, the generator makes O(log⁡i)O(\log i) mistakes on the language at index ii (Theorem 6.1). Theorem 6.3 establishes an Ω(i)\Omega(i) lower bound for algorithms matching the Charikar–Pabbaraju convergence rate. The authors also derive noise-dependent bounds for noisy adversaries (Section 7).

Critical strengths

The paper introduces a natural and well-motivated metric. Counting mistakes is the generation analogue of Littlestone’s mistake-bound model, and Example 1 clearly demonstrates information that the last-mistake time does not capture. Q1 and Q2 provide an effective organizing framework. The distinction between finite classes, where the stated guarantees can be achieved simultaneously, and countable classes, where a trade-off arises against the Charikar–Pabbaraju rate, is an interesting conceptual contribution.

The paper provides a unified analysis of finite and countable classes through a prior and growth-function parametrization (Theorem 4.1). For finite classes, Algorithm 1 achieves the cardinality-based mistake bound while retaining the optimal last-mistake guarantee, and Lemma 5.2 establishes worst-case tightness as a function of ∣L∣|\mathcal{L}|. For countable classes, Lemma 6.2 and Theorem 6.3 show that a linear mistake bound at the Charikar–Pabbaraju rate is necessary and achievable up to a factor of two.

The LfD formulation also provides a systematic route to noise-dependent guarantees. The extension of the guarantees of Joshi et al. to infinite streams of reward functions (Theorems E.4–E.5) may be of independent interest. The paper is clearly written and acknowledges important limitations, including the absence of a per-class optimal finite-class bound, while identifying natural open problems in Section 8.

Critical weaknesses

My main concern is the scope of the countable-class convergence and optimality claims. Theorem 6.1 gives an O(log⁡i)O(\log i) mistake bound, but no stream-independent last-mistake bound is proved for that instantiation. A finite mistake bound guarantees generation in the limit on each stream; it does not by itself establish non-uniform generation with a last-mistake bound depending only on the language. The introduction’s statement that the algorithm achieves logarithmic mistakes “by allowing for a slower convergence time” therefore suggests a guarantee that is not established. Conversely, Theorem 6.3 rules out the rate CGmax⁡i,m(Li)C_G\max\\{i,m(L_i)\\}, but does not resolve whether logarithmic mistakes are compatible with some slower non-uniform convergence guarantee. In fact, on the class constructed for Theorem 6.3 (Appendix D.1), a generator that outputs from the intersection of all consistent languages when possible, and otherwise from the intersection of all consistent languages except the lowest-indexed one, makes at most one mistake on each LiL_i, and only at time m(Li+1)+1m(L_{i+1})+1; the trade-off thus hinges on requiring the Charikar–Pabbaraju rate. The paper should distinguish optimality of the mistake count from the joint mistake–convergence trade-off, and qualify the claim that minimizing mistakes “does require sacrificing” convergence.

The computational model also needs clarification. Algorithm 1 takes an argmax over the infinite set X∖x1:t−1\mathcal{X}\setminus x_{1:t-1}. Exact maximization can require determining which intersections of the active languages still contain unseen elements, information that membership queries alone do not generally provide. The uniform and non-uniform generators the paper builds on (Algorithms 2 and 3) rely on similar nonemptiness checks, so this requirement is shared with prior work in this line. This access requirement should be distinguished from the membership-oracle model used by Kleinberg and Mullainathan (2024) and the computational barriers studied by Arenas et al. (2025). In particular, the growth function bounds the number of active languages, rather than the computational cost of each step. The statement that it allows the algorithm to “handle infinite streams with finite computational resources” should be qualified, and the assumed oracle should be stated explicitly.

For finite classes, the bound is worst-case optimal as a function of cardinality, but does not characterize the optimal mistake count for an individual class. For example, consider NN languages sharing a finite set of size nn and otherwise disjoint. The optimal mistake count is one, and Algorithm 1 achieves it, while the stated bound gives min⁡⌊log⁡2N⌋,n+1\min\\{\lfloor\log_2 N\rfloor,n+1\\}. The contribution heading “Optimal Bounds for Finite Classes” should make the scope of this optimality explicit. A per-class lower bound, or even a characterization of classes admitting zero or one mistake, would help clarify the complexity measure introduced by the paper.

The relationship to established proof techniques could also be positioned more precisely. Because the adversary’s next element is unseen when the generator acts, it provides a feasible comparison point, and Lemma A.1 follows the classical halving/weighted-majority potential argument (Littlestone, 1988; Littlestone and Warmuth, 1994). The dual guarantee of Theorem 5.1, which uses Algorithm 1 itself, rests on a one-line observation: whenever the consistent languages share an unseen element, every max-weight output lies in their intersection, since all consistent languages have positive weight (Appendix B.1); the Cdim+1\mathrm{Cdim}+1 term then follows from the last-mistake bound. Moreover, Appendix A proves the realizable results directly without the LfD reduction. Its substantive role is in the noisy setting, where Lemma 7.1 follows from Theorem 5 of Joshi et al. The abstract should distinguish the conceptual contribution of the LfD formulation from the proof ingredients needed for the realizable bounds.

The hallucination motivation would benefit from a discussion of breadth. Algorithm 1 favors intersections of consistent languages and may generate with little breadth, while prior work establishes tensions between breadth and consistency (Kalavasis et al., 2025). The noisy extension also provides upper bounds without matching lower bounds. As Section 7.1 acknowledges, under infinite but vanishing noise the bounds need not imply finitely many mistakes, whereas Mehrotra et al. (2025) guarantee a finite number of mistakes in that regime.

Minor comments: the definition of f−1f^{-1} in Theorem 4.1 could be simplified to f−1(i)=sup⁡t≥0:f(t)<if^{-1}(i)=\sup\\{t\ge0:f(t)<i\\} with f(0):=0f(0):=0. Algorithm 1 permits w0:N→R≥0w_0:\mathbb{N}\to\mathbb{R}_{\ge0}, whereas Theorem 4.1 requires strictly positive weights; this distinction should be clarified. “Proceeding” should be “following” in Appendix B.2, and “e.g.” should be “i.e.” in Section 3, Theorem E.1, and the proof of Lemma E.2. Section 4 states that the reduction to LfD is given in Appendix E.3, but it appears in Appendix E.1 (Lemma E.2).

Overall, the paper introduces a natural metric and a useful distinction between mistake count and last-mistake time. My main reservations concern the scope of the convergence and optimality claims, the unspecified oracle model, and the limited per-class characterization of mistake complexity. Clearer positioning relative to classical online-learning arguments would also help assess the technical contribution. I currently lean toward rejection, but would raise my score if the authors clarify the convergence guarantees of the logarithmic-mistake algorithm, qualify the trade-off claims accordingly, and state the assumed oracle model.

Questions for authors
  1. Does the instantiation in Theorem 6.1 achieve non-uniform generation? Does the lower-bound construction in Theorem 6.3 extend to any convergence rate fixed in advance, and can O(log⁡i)O(\log i) mistakes coexist with some slower non-uniform convergence guarantee?

  2. Does Theorem 4.1 yield a log⁡2i+O(log⁡log⁡i)\log_2 i+O(\log\log i) mistake bound with f(t)=22tf(t)=2^{2^t} and w0(i)∝1/[ilog⁡22(i+1)]w_0(i)\propto 1/[i\log_2^2(i+1)]? Can embedding the tree classes of Lemma 5.2 yield a matching log⁡2i−O(1)\log_2 i-O(1) lower bound for infinitely many indices ii, establishing an asymptotically tight index-dependent mistake bound separately from last-mistake guarantees?

  3. What oracle access does Algorithm 1 assume? Can an index-dependent mistake guarantee be achieved using membership queries alone?

  4. Is Algorithm 1 per-class optimal for finite classes? Can the classes whose optimal mistake count is zero or one be characterized?

  5. Can the mistake guarantees be combined with breadth requirements? How does imposing breadth affect the achievable mistake count?

2 comments

Thank you for the detailed review! We have uploaded a revised version of the paper with edits highlighted in blue. The main change is that we have extended the analysis of our existing mistake-bound algorithm (Algorithm 1) to also provide a sufficient condition for a stream-independent upper bound on last-mistake time using a quantity we term the look-ahead closure dimension. We have also made the optimization oracle explicit and clarified the worst-case cardinality scope of the finite-class mistake bound. Please let us know if any questions remain that would help you better assess the paper.

Thank you for the revision.

The new last-mistake bound, the qualified trade-off claims, the explicit oracle, and the clarified finite-class scope address most of my concerns, and I am raising my score.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.