- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes CACR for restoring combinations of low light, haze, rain, and snow without training a restoration network. It detects degradations using physical cues and an optional few-shot classifier on frozen DINOv2 features, then applies illumination correction, dehazing, and particle removal in a fixed order. Its central idea is to account for degradation interactions by re-estimating parameters from intermediate images and selecting operators according to the detected weather. Evaluation includes comparisons with classical and diffusion-based training-free baselines on CDD-11, component ablations, and tests on independent single-weather datasets.
Critical strengths
Not provided.
Critical weaknesses
1.The writing quality and experimental validation of this manuscript are far below the standards for submission to ICLR. Specifically, regarding experimental validation, the visualization section of the experiments not only lacks comparisons with other methods, but the provided examples also fail to demonstrate any clear advantages of the proposed method. In terms of writing quality, the author frequently and indiscriminately used italics and other special fonts in the manuscript, which seriously affected the reading experience. The aforementioned issues not only affect the quality of presentation but also impact readers' understanding and judgment of the experimental results, leading me to believe that the authors lacked sufficient thoroughness in their checks before submitting the manuscript.
2.The design of the core method lacks sufficient justification, and its substantive contributions remain unclear. The authors provide a qualitative explanation of the fixed degeneration process order, but do not fully explain how this order is derived from the mentioned formula. While existing ablation experiments can demonstrate that coupling brings additional benefits, they do not explain the contribution of each mechanism separately, and therefore are insufficient to support the conclusion that "the main benefits come from coupling rather than operators". Therefore, it is currently difficult to determine the substantial advantages of this method compared to a well-designed series of traditional operators.
Questions for authors
Besides the above weaknesses, the following lists some other concerns:
1.Section 3.3 states that the removal order “low → haze → particle” follows from the physics of Eq. (1), but the manuscript does not establish this connection. Please provide the derivation or evidence supporting this specific order.
2.Since composite weather restoration is evaluated only on CDD-11, what evidence supports generalization to composite weather beyond this benchmark?
3.Why does Figure 2 omit visual results from all competing methods?
4.The PSNR in Figure 1 is labeled as 17.41 → 11.38 → 20.15 → 20.07, but the caption claims that it is monotonically increasing. In Table 3, the PSNR of rain and snow also decreased from 23.1 to 21.8 and 23.9 to 20.9 respectively, why is it still referred to as "do-no-harm" in the manuscript? Please reconcile these inconsistencies and clarify which conclusions remain supported.