acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

LIFT: Library Integration of Formalized Theorems for Reusable Mathematical Knowledge

Abstract

Automatic formalization produces growing collections of definitions and proofs in Lean, but differences in assumptions and representations impede reuse across projects. We present LIFT, a method for jointly constructing public interfaces and adaptations that recover the original results and prescribed constructions. Existing results are aligned by their full types, common arguments are exposed through general interfaces, and concrete constructions are connected by representation maps. An asynchronous multiple-producer, single-consumer (MPSC) algorithm constructs candidates in parallel and reconciles each change with the current library. Revised candidates can use newly incorporated content; verified releases preserve earlier source recoveries as public interfaces evolve. Integration determines shared statements and adaptations before proof search addresses the remaining obligations. We organize from the public components of 20 previously formalized developments, whose records contain 5,061 accepted integration items. Three checked cases exhibit canonical reuse, general interfaces, and explicit structural data. A promoted normal-cone interface supports a later research proof, while a recorded online revision reuses a newly accepted theorem in its source proof.

Primary area:
neurosymbolic & hybrid AI systems (physics-informed, logic & formal reasoning, etc.)
Keywords:
Theorem Library Construction, Formal Mathematics, Mathematical Abstraction, Knowledge Reuse

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_11GgOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

The paper presents a framework for integrating independently formalized mathematical developments into reusable Lean libraries. It addresses the problem that mathematical results formalized in different projects may use different definitions, assumptions, representations and theorem interfaces, making cross-project reuse difficult.

The paper considers three integration mechanisms: (1) canonical alignment (2) common abstraction, and (3) representation transport LIFT employs an asynchronous multiple-producer, single-consumer (MPSC) workflow to construct candidate integrations concurrently and reconcile them with the evolving library. The framework also specifies conditions for preserving source specifications and existing client applications during library evolution.

The evaluation uses historical integration records from 20 projects (10,922 source items, of which 5,061 have been successfully integrated). The authors additionally present checked mathematical interfaces in calculus and topology, trace proof obligations from integration into subsequent proof tasks, and provide examples demonstrating the reuse of a generalised theorem and the use of newly integrated mathematics.

Critical strengths
  • A practically relevant research problem
  • A coherent integration mechanism
  • Consideration of online library evolution and compatibility
  • Concrete examples with machine-checked evidence
Critical weaknesses
  • Very limited novelty

    The main mechanisms (e.g., identifying related formal declarations, constructing generalised mathematical interfaces, introducing representation mappings, and preserving existing results through adaptation proofs) are well-established ideas in formal mathematics and proof engineering.

  • No comparative baselines.

    A major issue of the submission is the absence of a systematic comparison against alternative library integration/refactoring methods. It does not even compare simple approaches such as direct theorem reuse, independent integration without abstraction, conventional library refactoring or integration without source-recovery-guided planning.

  • The experiments do not sufficiently demonstrate actual cross-project reuse and its benefits.

    The primary motivation is to enable reuse across independently formalized mathematical projects. However, the large-scale evaluation mainly reports integration decisions (publishing, reusing, retaining or removing declarations). These counts do not directly measure how often an integrated theorem is subsequently reused by an independent project, how much duplicated mathematical development is eliminated or how much proof effort is saved.

  • Insufficient ablation for asynchronous MPSC integration

    The paper focuses on concurrent candidate construction, protected scopes, queue ordering, conflict resolution and three-way merging. However, the MPSC architecture is inherited from M2F, and the evaluation does not quantify its contribution.

    There are no measurements of throughput, wall-clock time, parallel speedup, contention, merge-conflict frequency, failed revisions or additional computational overhead. (The Beck example uses four producers, but a single successful revision does not demonstrate the overall scalability or efficiency.)

Questions for authors

Q1. What are the specific technical contributions of LIFT beyond existing approaches?

Q2. Can the authors provide experimental comparisons with simpler integration strategies or existing library-refactoring approaches?

Q3. Of the 5,061 successfully integrated source items, how many have fully discharged proof obligations and complete source-recovery evidence? How many correspond to truly new shared interfaces?

Q4. What are the measured benefits of MPSC? Please report parallel speedup, integration throughput, conflict rates, revision overhead and resource consumption, etc. Does MPSC improve integration quality, or primarily execution efficiency?

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 11Gg

Thank you for asking us to identify the algorithmic contribution and to separate evidence of reuse from evidence of efficiency.

Q1. What is technically new? LIFT couples the choice of a public theorem to the construction of its source applications. A candidate generalization must support the common argument while admitting an application under each project’s original hypotheses. For a construction, the application must return the prescribed data and establish their laws. This criterion guides both library construction and subsequent updates: when a public statement changes, the affected applications become proof obligations again. The contribution is this algorithm for selecting and maintaining shared results across independent formalizations. It builds on established methods for theorem application, abstraction, and transport, and on M2F’s concurrent execution mechanism (Sections 2–3).

Q2. What do simpler approaches achieve, and where is reuse visible? In two paired construction runs on three May items, Generic accepted all three in both runs and LIFT accepted two and three, respectively. Both complete libraries supported the three original applications. We also inspected downstream proof terms. On the two-torus task, both proofs built the required results locally from Mathlib. On a separate conditional three-torus task, Raw, Generic, and LIFT all produced checked proofs. Raw and Generic extracted two witnesses from imported existence theorems. The LIFT proof called the May product isomorphism twice, once on two circles and once on a circle and a product of circles. The calls establish actual reuse across the May and Hatcher materials. The target was selected with the interface in view, so this example does not estimate reuse frequency on independently sampled projects or proof effort saved. Table 5 and Appendix B give the comparison.

Q3. How many recoveries and genuinely new interfaces are established? Of 5,061 source items accepted at integration, 4,182 have a documented correspondence to compiled results, and 152 have verified complete recoveries under their original assumptions. Separately, 249 distinct obligations in seven batches link to successful proof tasks. An item can generate several obligations, so the latter figure cannot be added to the recovery count. We do not have a corpus-wide count of genuinely new interfaces: assigning a declaration to a public module can also promote an existing source result. Section 4.1 and Appendix D give the item-level results.

Q4. What was measured for MPSC? In the four-producer Beck run, 6,570 seconds elapsed from source arrival through the source check. Three candidates were accepted in that window, including two mathematical updates and one comment-only change. This gives 1.64 accepted candidates per hour, or 1.10 mathematical updates per hour, including checking time. One of four queued candidates was returned for conflict revision. Its revised proof used a theorem accepted in the meantime, and all 22 original Beck calls checked afterward. The 27 completed CLI sessions reported 4,807,037 tokens. These measurements establish the observed throughput, resource use, and one instance of reuse during revision. We have no matched serial run from which to estimate parallel speedup, incremental revision cost, or a causal effect on proof quality.

Reviewer_oUDGOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies how to merge independently formalized Lean developments, mostly produced by the M2F autoformalization pipeline, into one reusable library. It formulates integration as the joint construction of public interfaces and "recoveries" that re-derive every original theorem or construction from the shared content, guided by typed alignment, common abstraction and representation transport. Language-model producers propose candidates in parallel and a single consumer merges them, reusing M2F's multiple-producer, single-consumer mechanism. The evaluation reports that 5,061 of 10,922 items from 20 developments were integrated into ReasLib, inspects three completed interfaces, and traces one online revision of a Beck strong-convexity development.

Critical strengths

The recovery requirement is a useful correctness criterion for library integration. A shared library is valid only if every source specification is re-derived from public content without relying on the old proof (Eqs. 1 and 2). This rules out trivial "integration" that keeps old answers side by side, and it is relevant as automatic formalization produces many overlapping projects.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The evaluation does not compare LIFT with any alternative or measure library quality. All evidence is descriptive (item counts, three hand-selected interfaces, one revision trace), with no baseline, no ablation of the three refinement patterns, and no measure of deduplication or downstream benefit. The headline coverage of 5,061 of 10,922 items is also very uneven: three number-theory projects and Stacks account for 3,157 integrated items, while the other 16 developments integrate only about 25% (e.g., 3 of 547 for Symmetric pairs). The failures are not analyzed.

  2. The delta over M2F is unclear and the results are hard to reproduce. M2F already supplies candidate construction and MPSC coordination, and Section 4 evaluates "historical M2F outputs", so it is unclear which outcomes come from the proposed method. The historical runs do not record which models were used, and the only controlled run relies on a commercial model (Grok-4.7). The dense notation and prose also make the end-to-end algorithm hard to reconstruct from the main text.

Questions for authors

The following clarifications could change my assessment.

  1. Which components and reported numbers are new in this submission, and which come from M2F and its historical runs?
  2. Does "successful integration" require completed recovery proofs (Eq. 4), and how many of the 5,061 items are fully proven?
  3. Why does coverage range from 3 of 547 to 1,722 of 1,730 across developments?
  4. Is there any comparison against a simpler integration strategy, or a measure of how much duplication ReasLib removes?
1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer oUDG

Thank you for separating four questions that the original presentation treated together. We address them in order.

Q1. What does LIFT contribute beyond M2F, and where do the numbers come from? M2F supplies candidate construction and the multiple-producer, single-consumer workflow. LIFT uses that machinery to make a different decision: which mathematical statement should several projects share? It constructs a proposed public theorem together with its applications in the source projects. Its hypotheses must suffice for the common proof and must be derivable in every intended application. When the interface changes, those same applications determine which proofs must be rebuilt. Sections 2 and 3 now present the algorithm in that order. The 5,061 acceptances come from the project-stage records. The compilation of a single merged library, the correspondence and recovery counts, and the downstream proof comparisons are separate analyses. Appendix B gives the paired experiments’ inputs, model, environment, and per-item costs. Model identities are available for those experiments and the Beck run, but are incomplete across the historical exports.

Q2. Does acceptance establish a complete recovery? Acceptance records a decision about how to integrate a source item. Proof search can follow that decision. Among 5,061 accepted items, 4,182 have a traceable counterpart in the compiled library. We located pre-integration source text for 2,511 items and verified complete recovery under the original assumptions for 152. Each of those 152 checks covers the item’s full specification, including all required components of a construction. The corpus-wide total of complete recoveries remains unknown. Appendix D reports the counts by project.

Q3. Why does coverage vary so much? Your observation about concentration is borne out by the project-level data. Across the three number-theory projects and Stacks, 3,157 of 3,197 catalogue items were accepted. These four projects account for 62.4% of all acceptances. The remaining 16 projects account for 1,904 of 7,725 items (24.6%). The stage records clarify the two extremes: of 547 Symmetric Pairs items, 3 were accepted, 474 were marked blocked, 44 were uncovered, and 26 were cancelled. Stacks had 1,722 accepted and 8 uncovered out of 1,730. Thus the largest category in Symmetric Pairs was already blocked before an attempt. The records do not identify the underlying cause of those blocks. Section 4.1 gives the grouped results alongside Table 1.

Q4. What does integration remove, and how does a simpler strategy compare? Across the public module sources, named declaration occurrences fell from 131,399 to 127,795. Sharing identical files removed 2,085 occurrences. Replacing duplicated implementations with imports across 98 files removed another 1,339. Other changes accounted for a net reduction of 180, giving 3,604 fewer occurrences overall. This measures duplication in the source code. Counting mathematically equivalent theorems would require a different analysis. In the paired May comparison, LIFT accepted 2/3 and then 3/3 items, while Generic accepted 3/3 in both runs. All three source applications checked in both completed libraries. Section 4.5 and Table 5 examine how the resulting kinds of interface can be used in proofs. These experiments compare integration procedures. They do not isolate the effects of the three individual mechanisms.

Reviewer_F8JuOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The authors propose a method called LIFT to merge existing formalized libraries together while minimizing reuse. This is done by identifying common declarations, finding an abstraction common to both, and constructing "recoveries" which when paired with the abstraction, imply the original declaration(s). The authors run this method on several libraries and find success in deduplicating declarations.

Critical strengths

The problem is well-motivated, and the authors propose a sound way to mitigate duplicated work in a library while ensuring correctness. This is an interesting and intuitive method. Some of the case studies are interesting proofs-of-concept for the method.

Critical weaknesses
  1. First, the paper is very difficult to understand. There are several terms which are used and not defined until later, or not at all. I am unsure if these are terms from an adjacent area which are being used here, or if the authors use them specifically for this paper. I would suggest that the authors revise for clarity and simplicity over technicality, which can be left to the appendix for additional details if needed. For example, "source specification" and "recovery" among others are terms I am not familiar with, but were able to eventually understand from context. However, I am still not clear on what "publication", "local-retention", mean in this context. I find it very difficult to critically evaluate the work without knowing these terms.

  2. There is no comparison of LIFT's efficacy to baselines - whether that be prior work or some ablation. This makes it difficult to assess whether LIFT's reported numbers (e.g., 5,061 integrated items) are impressive or weak. To be clear, I am not stating that a comparison to every single possible baseline is warranted, but some sort of placement of this work in the context of prior research is relevant.

Questions for authors

I am confused as to whether ReasLib is a single unified library, or 20 separate libraries with a single shared public library? If the latter is the case, then are there 5,061 items in the shared library, with the remaining items and "recoveries" being present in each of the original projects? Assuming my understanding here is correct, it's not clear that all 5,061 shared items have successful recoveries.

In the abstract, the authors claim that new releases preserve source recoveries. If I understand correctly, this means that if a shared theorem is updated, private theorems which depended on will still be guaranteed to be correct. However, I do not see any evidence of this, and it is not obvious to me that this is true. Table 4 seems to show something similar, where an item was integrated and then used elsewhere. But, what if instead the integrated item was changed in some way, e.g., made more general? If such a change is possible, this breaks the guarantee of correctness.

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer F8Ju

Thank you for pointing out where the terminology obscured the main idea. Your questions led us to rewrite Sections 2 and 3 around a concrete criterion: after extracting a shared result, what must each original project still be able to prove or construct?

What is shared, and what stays in the source project? ReasLib is a single Lean library assembled from the public modules of 20 independently maintained project libraries. A public module contains theorems and constructions that other projects can import. A lemma used only to specialize a theorem to one project can stay in that project. A step needed by only one proof can stay inside that proof. This is what we mean by publication and local retention. For a theorem, recovery means deriving its original conclusion under its original hypotheses. For a construction, it also requires producing the specified data and proving their defining equations and laws.

What does 5,061 count? The 20 projects contain 10,922 source items. Of these, 5,061 had a proposal accepted at the integration stage. A proposal can reuse an existing theorem, introduce a shared declaration, or leave proof obligations for a subsequent task. The merged library compiles, and we traced 4,182 accepted source items to corresponding library results. Checking against the original Lean statements and construction requirements established complete recovery under the original assumptions for 152 items. The total number of complete recoveries among all 5,061 remains undetermined. Section 4.1 and Appendix D give the project-level results.

What happens when a public theorem changes? Generalizing a theorem can invalidate an earlier application. Section 3.3 makes the release condition explicit. If a project derived its result from the old theorem, LIFT must either derive the old statement from the new theorem and compose the proofs, or prove the original result directly. For a definition whose value occurs in a client’s type, the update must also preserve that value by computation or supply an equality that the client can use. Table 4 shows a revised Beck proof using a newly accepted theorem. A separate whole-library merge tested compatibility more directly: the candidate supplied compatibility provisions for 13 public declarations, and Lean checked both input environments’ original specifications against the merged library (Section 4.4 and Appendix A).

How does LIFT compare with a simpler procedure? Section 4.5 compares LIFT with a generic integration procedure on the same three May topology items from the same starting library. LIFT accepted two items in the first run and three in the second. The generic procedure accepted all three in both runs. In the run where both completed all three, the original applications checked against both libraries. Table 5 then examines what downstream proofs actually used. On the conditional three-torus task, all three approaches produced checked proofs. The LIFT proof instantiated the public product isomorphism twice and composed the resulting maps. This identifies a concrete use for the interface beyond the item that motivated it.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.