The evaluation does not establish added value over straightforward source access. Retrieval is restricted to earlier declarations in the same file, and 40/50 targets have at most 50 legal candidates under a per-channel budget of K=50. Baseline discovery already covers 37/37 observable source-proof premise occurrences, while Cards change only 2/50 final Top-10 sets. Candidate discovery is therefore largely saturated.
Source prefixes are a relevant baseline: across the 50 targets, the median prefix contains 329.5 lines and 4,909 tokens. For the highlighted e₂_subseq_converge_zero case, an adjacent preceding proof matches the original target proof after variable substitutions. Comparisons should include complete prefixes, a file-tool agent, reranking all legal declarations, and established retrievers on the same Optlib scope. The existing raw-relevant control fixes selected premises and leaves these alternatives unevaluated.
Cost effectiveness also remains unclear. Rich increases mean context from 1,592 to 15,431 tokens for 27 versus 22 successes, with a paired 95% interval of [-4,24] percentage points. Without independent identical-input repeats and complete execution costs, the evidence does not establish a reliable benefit that justifies the additional expense.
The provenance-isolation guarantee for Rich lacks independently verifiable implementation and examples. A legal declaration identity does not ensure legal evidence for its annotations. If an earlier lemma's summary sees the target or later proofs during whole-library preprocessing, it may absorb solution hints without retaining the target's name. Deleting a target reference from used_by at evaluation time does not guarantee removal of those hints. Lean verification that a usage example is valid also does not establish that it was available before the target.
The paper states that target-time filtering is applied, but the actual masker, field-level transitive provenance, verified-use materialization, and complete Rich inputs are unavailable, as acknowledged in Appendix J. It is therefore unclear whether filtering precedes generation or operates on already-generated summaries, and how information derived from unavailable evidence is handled. The paper's projection example has a source preceding the target and is not itself evidence of leakage. The concern is an inability to audit a guarantee directly affecting the validity of the Compact/Rich comparison, rather than an established leakage finding.
We thank the reviewer for the constructive assessment and for highlighting the need to better isolate Library Card's contributions. To address these concerns, we conducted two additional controlled evaluations that provide more direct evidence of the benefits of repository-grounded knowledge and historical usage examples.
Additional Experimental Evidence.
First, we evaluated Compact retrieval context against a theorem-only No-Card baseline on the same 50 Optlib targets, with three independent runs per target and arm. Compact achieved 69/147 (46.94%) Lean-verified successes versus 51/147 (34.69%) for No-Card. Across 144 complete pairs, the equal-target-weighted improvement was +12.33 percentage points (target-cluster bootstrap 95% CI [+2.00,+23.00] pp). This provides repeated evidence that explicitly supplying retrieved repository knowledge improves observed downstream proof performance.
Second, to investigate the contribution of historical usage examples, we completed a new 450-trajectory, three-arm ablation (50 targets × 3 arms × 3 runs), comparing:
Unlike our earlier compiled/raw comparison, this experiment controls the underlying source occurrences, allowing us to distinguish the value of additional usage information from that of its representation.
The original execution produced 423 scientific outcomes and 27 infrastructure-unresolved cases. A separately documented supplemental recovery obtained scientific outcomes for 26 additional cases while preserving the original records.
In the supplemental analysis, VERIFIED_USAGE achieved 85/150 (56.67%) successes versus 78/150 (52.00%) for FORMAL_ONLY, an improvement of +4.67 percentage points. More importantly, among the 37 example-eligible targets defined before execution, VERIFIED_USAGE improved over FORMAL_ONLY by +9.91 percentage points, with a descriptive target-cluster bootstrap 95% interval of [+1.80,+18.92] pp.
These results provide encouraging evidence for our central motivation: concrete historical usage patterns can help provers apply retrieved declarations beyond simply supplying their formal statements.
Interpretation and Future Improvements.
The reviewer also noted the limited advantages observed in our earlier structured/flat and compiled/raw comparisons. We believe the new experiments help clarify this observation.
The structured/flat comparison examined different presentations of similar information, and its comparable results suggest that the prover can utilize such knowledge without requiring a particular layout. Similarly, in the new source-matched ablation, VERIFIED_USAGE and RAW_USAGE both achieved 67/111 (60.36%) successes on the 37 eligible targets.
Since both conditions provide the same underlying historical usage occurrences, these findings are consistent with the interpretation that the additional theorem-application knowledge, rather than its particular presentation format, is the primary source of the observed benefit. We will make this distinction clearer in the revised manuscript.
Regarding retrieval efficiency, Library Card primarily aims to improve how retrieved knowledge is utilized in downstream proving, rather than introduce a faster search algorithm. The new ablation demonstrates the practical value of usage information under identical Top-10 premise selection and prover settings, without increasing the number of retrieved formal premises. We also appreciate the reviewer's suggestion concerning retrieval efficiency and plan to investigate more efficient indexing, retrieval, and context selection strategies in future work.
Summary.
Together, these two evaluations strengthen the empirical foundation of Library Card. The repeated No-Card comparison demonstrates the incremental benefit of retrieved repository knowledge, while the new source-matched ablation provides evidence that historically grounded, Lean-verified usage examples improve proof success beyond formal premises alone, particularly when eligible examples are available.
These findings reinforce Library Card's central contribution: automatically constructing reusable repository knowledge and providing automated provers with concrete, verifiable theorem-application experience. We will incorporate these experimental findings and the refined mechanism analysis into the revised manuscript.