- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a graph-enhanced representation based on auto-regressive paradigm on vectorized floorplan generation task. It adopts the design of GraphMAE2 on bubble diagram inputs to achieve a more powerful graph encoding, and utilizes a functional order to process the native unordered floorplan sequence. The model is trained end-to-end based on the canonical auto-regressive transformer pipeline with the reconstruction loss and geometric loss. Extensive experiments are conducted on RPLAN benchmark dataset under multiple (mixed, separate) setting following the typical evaluation protocol.
Critical strengths
- Overall the paper is well written and easy to follow, on motivation introduction, task formulation as well as experimental designs.
- The graph-based representation is suitable for the conditional generation task based on bubble diagram, since the connectivity constraint is an important rubric for measuring the fidelity of the interior floorplans.
- The ablation studies are comprehensive and well-designed.
Critical weaknesses
-
To me the most critical downside is on the novelty of the method. Overall the paper's main contribution is a discriminative graph-enhanced representation on the node of the bubble diagram, however the key design follows an existing work of GraphMAE2, which diminishes the originality of the method. The remaining pipeline overall follows existing works (Liu et.al 2022 and LayoutTransformer), which limits the technical soundness of the paper.
-
Although the proposed functional ordering (FO) achieves notable improvement from the ablation study, I have not fully aware of the key methodological difference from the prefix ordering used in Liu et.al 2022, which also ensures a deterministic order for generation different types of the rooms.
-
The paper uses the causal Transformer based on Llama architecture, which is a more advanced design compared with the most relevant work Liu et at 2022 and LayoutTransformer. Both works are based on the earlier version of GPT-series. Although leveraging better foundation models are encouraged and understandable, it would be better to see the improvement gain brought from the architecture upgrade from the ablation study.
Questions for authors
Does LayoutTransformer shown in the experimental study mean the floorplan generation paper of Liu et.al 2022 or LayoutTransformer: Layout Generation and Completion with Self-attention? I suggest to make it clear before making an abbreviation.