- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes MapVAE, a hierarchical autoencoder that learns a structured latent space for vectorized HD maps, enabling diffusion models to generate realistic road networks while preserving fine-grained geometry and global layout consistency.
Critical strengths
Strong reconstruction results and comprehensive ablation studies.
The method shows substantial improvements over Scenario Dreamer, reducing lane reconstruction RMSE from 0.462 m to 0.180 m and improving curvature fidelity from 0.593 to 0.885. The paper also provides extensive ablations covering most major design choices, which helps demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed components.
Critical weaknesses
- Insufficient comparisons with representative prior methods.
The paper mainly compares against Scenario Dreamer (CVPR 2025), while other relevant HD map generation methods, such as HDMapGen (CVPR 2021) and SLEDGE (ECCV 2024), are discussed in the Related Work section but excluded from the experiments. Since these methods explore different generation approaches, including graph-based generation and raster-based latent diffusion, the limited baseline comparison makes it difficult to assess whether the proposed structured latent representation offers a meaningful advantage over existing alternatives.
- Lack of evaluation on public benchmarks.
All experiments are conducted on a private dataset, without any evaluation on established public benchmarks. While the dataset is large and diverse, the authors do not clearly explain why public datasets are excluded. This makes it difficult to independently reproduce the results, verify the reported improvements, or assess how well the proposed method generalizes beyond the authors’ internal data distribution. This is particularly concerning given the paper’s broader claims about learning a general-purpose structured latent representation for vectorized HD maps.
Questions for authors
Q1 Missing baseline comparisons
Given that HDMapGen and SLEDGE (mentioned in related work as previous sota) have publicly available implementations, could the authors explain why these representative graph-based and raster-latent generation methods are excluded from the quantitative comparisons?
Q2 Evaluation on public benchmarks
All experiments are conducted on a private dataset. Could the authors clarify why no experiments are provided on established public benchmarks, such as nuPlan or nuScenes? This makes it difficult to independently verify the reported improvements and compare against existing methods.
We sincerely thank you for your constructive review. We have substantially revised the manuscript (highlighted in blue) to address every point you raised.
Summary of Manuscript Restructuring & Presentation Improvements (Addressing W1 & W4)
Following your feedback on Presentation (W4) and Generation Evaluation in the Main Text (W1), we overhauled the manuscript structure so that the main paper is self-contained and easy to follow: