- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
AMPLE predicts five antimicrobial peptide activities using sequence, physicochemical, protein language model, and structural experts. A router selectively runs the expensive experts, and a separate gate combines their predictions.
Critical strengths
- AMPLE-Best matches the 76.1% mAP of the full four-expert model while reducing reported latency from 95.37 to 23.89 ms/sample.
- Adjustable routing thresholds allow a single trained model to support different computational budgets without retraining.
Critical weaknesses
- The architectural novelty modest. The framework combines existing experts with cost-aware routing and prediction fusion. The paper does not convincingly establish a methodological advance over existing approaches or demonstrate why a simpler fusion would be insufficient.
- Evaluation is limited to aggregate results on one benchmark, without concrete routing cases or detailed failure analysis.
Questions for authors
- What specific methodological contribution distinguishes AMPLE from existing active feature acquisition or dynamic modality selection approaches? Can the authors compare AMPLE with these methods under matched computational budgets?
- How does AMPLE handle missing modalities at inference time, such as unavailable structural information, when the corresponding expert cannot be executed?
- Why is the router trained without accounting for upstream structure-prediction costs? Would including ESMFold costs during training change the routing decisions?
- How were the Efficient and Best configurations chosen? Were they fixed before evaluating on the test set?
- The generalization ability of AMPLE remains unclear, as it is evaluated on only one benchmark. The authors should evaluate the model on additional AMP datasets to demonstrate its generalizability.
- The paper should provide representative successful and failed routing cases showing when acquiring an expensive expert helps or harms the prediction.
- The paper does not provide publicly available code or implementation details.