1. Limited novelty and scientific contributions.
The main finding that source-task improvements do not necessarily translate into target-task gains seems relatively unsurprising, especially given the differences in task definitions and data distributions. The source-based selection analysis mainly demonstrates the failure of two simple heuristics, without sufficiently investigating stronger alternatives. Moreover, the layer-wise LoRA adaptation and feature-preservation regularization are largely based on existing techniques, while the contributions of individual geometry objectives remain insufficiently characterized. Overall, despite extensive experiments, I find the new scientific insights rather limited, which is my primary concern regarding acceptance.
2. Poor clarity and organization of the experimental presentation.
The paper is difficult to follow. The historical candidate pool, different training and evaluation protocols, and extensive implementation details are presented in a confusing manner. The figures also fail to clearly communicate the main findings. This makes it difficult to distinguish the central experimental evidence from supplementary analyses and to understand precisely what each experiment establishes. Given that the paper's main contribution is empirical, the lack of a clear experimental narrative substantially weakens its presentation and overall impact.