- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a physical manifold regularization and a reweighting technique for the degradation prognostic problem. Tests are done on some battery benchmarks, by comparing the proposed method with iTransformer and causalLSTM.
Critical strengths
The tests are done on some realistic battery benchmarks. It seems that the method is better than iTransformer and causalLSTM.
Critical weaknesses
The paper is very hard to follow for readers without prior knowledge. The novelty is limited, and the comparisons are insufficient.
Questions for authors
- Some notations are used without explanations. E.g., (I,V,T) for the raw operational profiles, f_3, k-1, and so on. Some concepts are not defined as well, such as the latent physical variants. The author should do proofreading.
- The quality of Fig. 1 and 2 is low. They seem to be be AI-generated: too many elements that are trivial and non-technical. It’s not suitable for a top-tier conference like ICLR.
- Many sections are hard to understand for readers without prior knowledge. For example, in Section 3, what are linear probing evaluations, candidate physical descriptor, parameter-minimal linear head, physical target space, key metric f_3 (IC peak area reflecting active lithium loss)? In Section 4, what is the LUPI paradigm (there is no citation)? Can you also explain Eq. (2)? Many concepts, notations, and equations are hard to understand.
- The novelty seems to be limited. It seems that the innovation is to introduce an additional physical-manifold-supervised loss and some reweighting techniques. This seems lies in the conventional physics-informed learning.
- The baseline methods in the Experiment are limited. Only causallstm and itransformer are used. However, in terms of deep sequence models, there are many categories. The author should consider some of them.
- There are no limitation discussion and future work statement.