- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This article presents a method named EDR-BAT to predict battery health (SOH) causal relationships. This method employs electrochemical feature embedding, series-specific learnable priors and cross-attention on historical observation. Moreover, low-rank bilinear interactions are also used. Besides, it utilizes the autoregressive memory on SOH and training based on memory to alleviate the deviation between training and inference. The effectiveness is validated through experiments of five battery datasets. It reduces average MAE by 12.9% and RMSE by 11.4% compared with the best deep learning baseline in each dataset.
Critical strengths
This paper discusses an important issue in predicting the SOH of battery: it's a real challenge for the lack of consistency between the training history of SOH and the autoregressive inference process. They conduct experiments on five datasets, many baselines and ablation studies are tested. The improvements are presented for the various battery degradation situations.
Critical weaknesses
-
The proposed method is basically a combination of existing methods such as handcrafted electrochemical features, cross attention mechanism, low-rank bilinear fusion and scheduled sampling. Especially the memory-based training method seems very similar to scheduled sampling. There are also recently proposed works about battery SOH prediction that exploit electrochemical features and attention-based historical information modeling. But, this work mainly compares with some general baseline methods and there is no real comparison against these closely related recent works.
-
The features used in this model are based on current cycle capacity, and labels (SOH) are also based on current cycle capacity. Even though the authors say that these features are different from true capacity, it's not well clarified how exactly those features are constructed and whether they are available in (so-called) online case or not. So, there is still possibility of information leakage issue.
-
The experiments are only conducted under a scenario where unseen batteries in given dataset are tested. As the proposed model needs to learn some priors for a given series (learnable), it's still not clear how well this method would work for unseen battery series without training/tuning, unless it can work in other than experimental environment.
Questions for authors
Same as the weaknesses.
4 comments
Condition-matched Mechanism Controls
Condition-matched mechanism controls.
We further evaluated Frozen query, History pooling, a Parameter-matched MLP, and a Dynamic MLP under identical inputs, SOH memory, training strategy, target cells, and splits. These variants respectively test the learnable query set, query-based historical adaptation, low-rank interaction, and a more flexible history-conditioned prediction mapping. Dynamic MLP was an early design explored during method development.
Controlled comparison of the learnable prior and interaction structure under identical inputs, training strategies, target cells, and data splits. MAE/RMSE are reported in percentage points, with small subscripts denoting standard deviations over five random seeds. Avg. denotes the equal-weight average across the five target cells. Best and second-best results are marked in bold and underlined.
| Target cell | Full | Frozen query | History pooling | Parameter-matched MLP | Dynamic MLP |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CS2_36 | |||||
| channel24 | |||||
| B0018 | |||||
| Cell4 | |||||
| In-house-3 | |||||
| Avg. | 0.51 / 0.61 | 0.68 / 0.78 | 0.64 / 0.77 | 0.66 / 0.77 | 0.66 / 0.78 |
The full model reduces average MAE/RMSE by 25.1%/22.0% over Frozen query, 20.9%/20.4% over History pooling, and 23.5%/21.0% over the Parameter-matched MLP, while also outperforming Dynamic MLP. Because all controls share identical information and training conditions, they isolate the learnable prior, history-conditioned representation, and low-rank interaction beyond historical access or generic fusion. Together with w/o Hist. and , these results distinguish the contributions of historical information, prediction-based SOH-memory training, and degradation-state construction. The complete controls are reported in revised Appendix E.
Capacity-related Inputs and Generalization Scope
2. Capacity-related inputs and information leakage
The SOH label, , is computed from complete-discharge capacity and used only for supervision. All model inputs are instead extracted from the current-cycle charging record before this label becomes available, without future-cycle information. Capacity-related inputs include charged throughput and IC-curve features derived from ; the remaining inputs describe charging duration, voltage rise, signal change, and distributional statistics.
The CALCE table below provides a representative example. Complete tables for CALCE, MIT, NASA, Oxford, and In-house, including every feature, extraction interval, definition, and earliest availability, are provided in the revised manuscript, Appendix A, “Input Feature Definitions and Availability.” Here, , , and .
CALCE input features. All quantities are extracted from the current-cycle charging record.
| Feature | Extraction interval and definition | Available after |
|---|---|---|
| CC voltage-rise time | over -- | At |
| CC charging duration | After CC | |
| CC current--time integral | ; this is charged throughput during CC, not the discharge-capacity SOH label | After CC |
| Minimum CC voltage-change rate | After CC | |
| CC voltage-rate standard deviation | At | |
| CC voltage skewness | At | |
| IC main-peak voltage | After CC | |
| IC main-peak height | , with searched over -- | After CC |
| IC main-peak area | , clipped to the available IC domain | After CC |
| IC main-peak FWHM | After CC |
The complete input is assembled after the latest required CC, CV, or IC interval. Thus, charging-cycle-level online prediction uses only available current-cycle charging observations and previous history, without subsequent discharge capacity or future cycles. In the in-house dataset, the full CC current--time integral is the most direct capacity proxy; we mask this standardized feature while preserving the input dimension, architecture, training protocol, and split. Results use five random seeds.
Sensitivity to the direct charged-capacity proxy on the in-house dataset. Small subscripts denote standard deviations over five random seeds. MAE and RMSE are reported in percentage points. Avg. denotes the equal-weight average across the three target cells. Better results are marked in bold.
| Target cell | Full MAE | Full RMSE | Capacity proxy masked MAE | Capacity proxy masked RMSE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| In-house-1 | ||||
| In-house-2 | ||||
| In-house-3 | ||||
| Avg. | 0.75 | 0.89 | 0.91 | 1.03 |
Masking increases average MAE/RMSE from to (). The proxy is informative, but the remaining nine features still support prediction, showing that EDR-BAT is not driven solely by it. The revised manuscript clarifies the label--input distinction, feature availability, masking analysis, and prediction time.
3. Generalization beyond observed battery series
In the current protocol, each dataset is an independent battery-series task: the shared prior is learned from source cells and applied to an unseen cell from the same series without target-cell labels or fine-tuning. Because the five datasets are trained separately, these experiments do not establish direct transfer to an entirely unseen series. Such transfer also requires physically aligned inputs, whereas the current datasets use different charging protocols and feature definitions. Future work could construct common online charging features or aligned dataset-specific encoders, jointly learn a cross-series prior, and evaluate it through leave-one-series-out or leave-one-dataset-out protocols. The revised Discussion states this scope and the need for validation under varying temperatures, dynamic loads, partial charging, and fleet data.
Thank you again for your detailed feedback. We have provided point-by-point responses and added the requested clarifications and experiments to the revised manuscript. As the discussion period is approaching its end, if these additions have addressed your main concerns, we would greatly appreciate your reconsideration of the paper in light of the new evidence. If any major concern remains, we would be happy to clarify it further.
Novelty and Closely Related Comparison
We thank the reviewer for the constructive assessment. We address the three concerns in the following comments.
1. Novelty and closely related comparison
EDR-BAT does not claim the individual attention, fusion, or sampling operators as new. Its contribution is their battery-specific organization: a shared query set is adapted through electrochemical history into a cycle-specific degradation representation, which then interacts separately with current-cycle evidence and SOH memory. Memory-anchored training is related to scheduled sampling, which we now cite explicitly; here it operates on an explicit SOH memory containing measured, missing, or stop-gradient predicted entries and works jointly with electrochemical-history querying.
Direct related-method comparison.
LSTM-LAM encodes multi-cycle electrochemical features using an LSTM and local attention. We implemented a controlled version preserving this core structure while using the same dataset-specific inputs, causal history lengths, target-cell splits, and training protocol as EDR-BAT; no target-cell SOH labels are used for fine-tuning.
Dataset-level macro-average results from the complete leave-one-cell-out evaluation. Each entry reports MAE/RMSE in percentage points. The final row gives equal weight to the five datasets. Best results are marked in bold.
EDR-BAT achieves lower dataset-level macro-average MAE/RMSE on all five datasets and reduces the equal-dataset average by 25.2%/34.5%. This indicates that local-attention reweighting of a unified sequence does not fully replace the explicit separation of current-cycle evidence, electrochemical history, and autoregressive SOH states. Complete per-cell results are reported in revised Appendix C.