- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates the relationship between the generative space and the geometry of actions within Vision-Language-Action (VLA) models. Building on HoloBrain-0, the authors propose Action-Manifold VLA (AM-VLA), which reformulates diffusion-based action generation as conditional flow matching, and instantiate two variants: AM-VLA-J and AM-VLA-E. Experiments in simulation and on real robots show modest performance gains over HoloBrain-0.
Critical strengths
The paper features a clear structural design that explicitly distinguishes between generation states and conditional information. By developing generation schemes for both joint space and task space within a shared architecture, it offers a valuable research perspective for understanding the relationship between the generation space and the geometry of actions.
Critical weaknesses
- The main concern is that the advance over existing work is not yet sufficiently clear. RFMP/SRFMP[1] already performs manifold action generation on product spaces containing position, rotation, and gripper variables, but is not discussed. HoloBrain-0 also includes joint/pose prediction and task-space supervision. Distinguishing inherited designs from new ones, and identifying the experiments supporting the latter, would clarify the contribution. While the provided ablation studies demonstrate the utility of these components, they do not adequately prove that the new designs are superior to the existing designs already present in the base model.
- The performance gains are limited: showing improvements of only 0.4 and 1.0 percentage points on full benchmarks—and no significant benefit is observed in real-world grasping tasks. Are these gains consistently beyond random fluctuation, and can they be replicated across a broader range of tasks?
- The differences between the two generation schemes in terms of computational cost and control efficiency are not discussed, nor is it addressed whether the marginal performance gains are sufficient to justify the additional costs.
- The AM-VLA-E relies on a task-space controller; however, its controller or inverse kinematics (IK) implementation, handling of unreachable targets, and behavior in the event of execution failure are not sufficiently described.
[1] Fast and Robust Visuomotor Riemannian Flow Matching Policy arXiv:2412.10855
Questions for authors
- What is the central contribution beyond HoloBrain-0 and RFMP/SRFMP, and which experiment independently supports it?
- How do AM-VLA-J, AM-VLA-E, and HoloBrain-0 compare in inference latency, and effective control frequency?
- What controller or IK solver is used to execute AM-VLA-E outputs? How are unreachable poses, joint-limit violations, IK failures, and execution failures handled?
- The long-horizon benefit claimed in Section 4.2 is not reliably established, as it is supported mainly by a single stacking task. Could the authors validate this claim on additional multi-stage tasks (Sim or Real world)?
I think the author has given up on rebuttal; I will keep my current rating.