- Rating
- 4(+3)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2(+1)
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
This proposes a two stage pipeline for the single-step retrosynthesis. At the first stage, the pipeline predicts the reaction centers to get the synthons. A dynamic selection rule is applied to preserve the RC candidate for the next stage. Unlike previous works. the pipeline do not breaks the bonds according to the RC predictions, but merge and mark the predictions on the input product mole as virtual synthons. A flow matching conditioned on the virtual synthon is applied finally for the generation of the products.
Critical strengths
- The motivation that hard construction of the synthons might have the multi-stage error accumulation is very reasonable. The paper is well motivated.
- The presentation is clear, the paper is easy to follow.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper's core idea is not new, see the questions for details.
- The evaluation in the article is chemically unreasonable, and the performance is overestimated. see the questions for details.
Questions for authors
-
According to the supplementary material, the molecular graph representation includes atom types and chemical bond types but does not explicitly encode stereochemical information. However, baselines such as Graph2SMILES and Chemformer use stereochemistry-aware canonical SMILES exact matching for evaluation. Since approximately 20% of USPTO-50K test reactions involve stereochemistry, ignoring it during evaluation may substantially inflate the reported performance and lead to unfair comparisons.
- Could the authors clarify whether stereochemistry is considered during evaluation and,
- if so, how it is recovered from stereochemistry-free graph predictions? The authors should also provide results under a consistent stereochemistry-aware evaluation protocol.
-
The evaluation lacks many powerful baselines like [3, 4, 5, 6]
-
The idea that mark the reaction center on the reactant the perform conditional generation for product are not new too. Most recently, the one combines the soft RC mark with the conditional flow matching for single-step retrosynthesis are provided at ICML2026[3]. For Smiles generation we also have the previous work like [2] and can even date back to 2023[1]. The author do not discuss them, and the major contribution of this paper do not holds.
[1] Thakkar, Amol, et al. "Unbiasing retrosynthesis language models with disconnection prompts." ACS Central Science 9.7 (2023): 1488.
[2] Xiong, Jiacheng, et al. "Bridging chemistry and artificial intelligence by a reaction description language." Nature Machine Intelligence 7.5 (2025): 782-793.
[3] Wang, Chenguang, et al. "Order Matters in Retrosynthesis: Structure-aware Generation via Reaction-Center-Guided Discrete Flow Matching." ICML 2026
[4] Zhong, Zipeng, et al. "Root-aligned SMILES: a tight representation for chemical reaction prediction." Chemical Science 13.31 (2022): 9023-9034.
[5] Han, Yuqiang, et al. "Retrosynthesis prediction with an iterative string editing model." Nature Communications 15.1 (2024): 6404.
[6] Zeng, Kaipeng, et al. "Ualign: pushing the limit of template-free retrosynthesis prediction with unsupervised SMILES alignment: K. Zeng et al." Journal of Cheminformatics 16.1 (2024): 80.
15 comments
Response to Reviewer GvRh — Critical Weakness 2: Evaluation fairness
Critical Weakness 2
The evaluation in the paper is chemically unreasonable, and the performance is overestimated. Please see the Questions section for details.
Thank you for identifying this issue. We acknowledge that the original manuscript did not clearly distinguish evaluations with and without stereochemistry, which could lead to inappropriate comparisons across different evaluation criteria. In the revised manuscript, we report and discuss these results separately and have updated the experimental descriptions, result tables, and performance conclusions accordingly.
Specifically, the original model results are now explicitly categorized as graph-structure evaluation without stereochemistry. We no longer present them as strict stereochemical matching results for direct comparison with the corresponding baselines. For RetroVirtSyn-Stereo, we explicitly model and predict atom chirality and double-bond stereochemistry, and evaluate exact matches of canonical SMILES that preserve stereochemistry. A prediction is counted as incorrect if stereochemistry is missing or incorrect, even when connectivity is correct.
Under this strict criterion, the extended model achieves Top-1/Top-10 accuracies of 70.96%/83.64% on all 5,007 test reactions and 69.49%/81.21% on the 990 reactions with explicit stereochemical annotations. We also evaluate the same predictions with their ranking fixed, both with and without stereochemistry, to isolate the effect of the evaluation criterion.
The revised manuscript explicitly distinguishes correct connectivity from correct connectivity together with correct stereochemistry, rather than conflating them into a single metric.
Response to Reviewer GvRh — Question 1: Stereochemical modeling and evaluation (Part 1/2)
Question 1
According to the supplementary material, the molecular graph representation includes atom and bond types but does not explicitly encode stereochemical information. However, baselines such as Graph2SMILES and Chemformer are evaluated using exact matching of canonical SMILES that account for stereochemistry. Since approximately 20% of the USPTO-50K test reactions involve stereochemistry, ignoring it during evaluation could substantially inflate the reported performance and lead to unfair comparisons. Could the authors clarify whether stereochemistry is considered during evaluation? If so, how is stereochemical information recovered from graph predictions that do not contain it? The authors should also provide results under a unified evaluation protocol that accounts for stereochemistry.
Thank you for pointing out the inconsistency between the stereochemical representation and the evaluation criterion. We acknowledge this issue and agree that reliable comparisons require consistent treatment of stereochemistry. The original manuscript did not explain this sufficiently. Below, we clarify the limitations of the original implementation and report new stereochemistry-aware experiments.
(1) Did the original evaluation account for stereochemistry?
Our inspection confirmed that the original molecular graphs did not explicitly encode atom chirality or double-bond stereochemical states, and molecules reconstructed from these graphs did not fully preserve the original stereochemical information. The original evaluation therefore cannot be regarded as strict stereochemistry-aware exact matching against the original reactants using canonical SMILES. Enabling a stereochemistry-preserving option during graph-to-SMILES conversion cannot automatically restore stereochemical labels already lost from the graph representation.
We agree that this evaluation may count predictions with identical connectivity but inconsistent stereochemistry as correct, thereby overestimating strict exact-match accuracy. To address this issue, we have revised the comparison tables to present results with and without stereochemistry separately, avoiding direct comparisons across different evaluation criteria.
(2) How can stereochemistry be recovered from graph predictions without stereochemical information?
Once stereochemical labels have been lost, atom types and connectivity alone generally cannot uniquely recover the originally specified configuration. We therefore did not attempt to repair the original model outputs through SMILES canonicalization or by copying ground-truth reactant labels. Instead, we extended the model state representation and retrained a stereochemistry-aware version, referred to below as RetroVirtSyn-Stereo.
Specifically, we added tetrahedral chirality labels to atom states and double-bond stereochemical configurations to bond states. Atom chirality uses a local representation with a consistent neighbor ordering, and double-bond stereochemistry uses a relative representation with consistent reference neighbors, to prevent node reordering from changing the meaning of the labels. This information is incorporated into the product conditions, reactant supervision labels, and model output space.
During generation, the model jointly predicts reactant structures and stereochemical states. The decoder then assigns the predicted chirality and double-bond configurations to the molecules and outputs canonical SMILES that preserve stereochemistry. Ground-truth reactant stereochemical labels are not used during inference. This is therefore explicit prediction of stereochemical states, rather than post hoc recovery of the answer from the original graphs lacking stereochemical information.
(3) Strict stereochemistry-aware evaluation and comparison with existing methods
To address the concern about evaluation fairness, we evaluate RetroVirtSyn-Stereo using exact matching of canonical SMILES that preserve stereochemistry. Ground truth is obtained from the original reactant SMILES. Predictions and ground-truth reactants undergo the same canonicalization procedure, with atom-mapping numbers removed but atom chirality and double-bond stereochemistry retained. A prediction is correct only if the complete predicted reactants exactly match the ground truth. Missing or incorrect stereochemistry is counted as a mismatch even when connectivity is correct.
Response to Reviewer GvRh — Critical Weakness 1: Novelty
We thank the reviewer for carefully reviewing our work and for the valuable suggestions on the experimental analysis and methodological presentation. We have revised the manuscript to address all the issues you raised and marked the corresponding changes in blue for ease of reference. Our point-by-point responses follow.
Critical Weakness 1
Thank you for raising the concern about novelty. Our central contribution addresses the practical problem of prediction errors in the first stage by converting uncertainty in reaction-center predictions into a structural probability input for the second stage. This representation is used both as a generation condition and to construct the starting distribution of the probability bridge. Describing our method as simply marking reaction centers and then performing conditional generation does not capture this distinction.
By a “soft interface,” we mean that the input preserves predictive uncertainty as a probability distribution over possible structural states, rather than directly converting a selected center into a deterministic structural modification. Softness does not depend on whether centers are marked through atom labels, sequence ordering, or positional encodings. For a candidate bond to be broken, e, the virtual synthon converts the center weight qe intoGS(e)=(1−qe)δbond+qeδnone.
When 0<qe<1, this representation retains probability mass for both the original bond and the no-bond state, rather than deciding in advance that the bond must be broken. These probabilities describe uncertainty over discrete structural states; the sampled graphs and final reactants remain discrete.
The three related studies organize reaction-center information through disconnection prompts, explicit editing instructions, and center-first ordering, respectively. Their contributions have different emphases, but they differ from our mechanism, which converts first-stage center confidence into categorical probabilities over the original-bond and no-bond states and uses these probabilities to construct the generative probability bridge. In particular, an upstream predictor producing center scores does not imply that those scores are retained as structural probability inputs to the generator after candidate selection.
The virtual synthon therefore specifies not only where a reaction may occur, but also the probability with which a predicted structural change enters the starting distribution. It serves as an explicit condition and defines the starting distribution of the linear categorical probability bridge, thereby changing the distribution of intermediate training states. Combined with adaptive retention of multiple centers, this interface addresses two sources of error. It avoids committing an incorrect center prediction to a deterministically broken bond, and it preserves opportunities to recover a true center omitted by the top-ranked candidate. This is a probabilistic structural interface designed to address error propagation between stages, rather than a replacement for a center-annotation scheme.
This design is supported by experiments. On the full test set, the single-center virtual synthon achieves a Top-1 accuracy of 63.50%, compared with 60.30% for the hard bond-breaking interface and 60.48% for the full product plus center prompts. On the subset with incorrect center predictions, its Top-10 accuracy is 53.08%, compared with 33.97% and 52.72%, respectively. We also added transfer experiments with G²Retro and RetroSynFlow to examine the adaptability of the interface across generative frameworks. The distinctions from the three studies, the three-way interface comparison, recovery from incorrect centers, the complementarity of multiple centers, and the transfer experiments are detailed below.
To address stereochemistry, we incorporated tetrahedral chirality and double-bond stereochemistry into the discrete flow-matching model in this revision, including its state representation, training supervision, and output decoding. We implemented and retrained the resulting stereochemistry-aware version, RetroVirtSyn-Stereo. Under strict evaluation that preserves stereochemistry, its Top-1 accuracies on the full test set and the stereochemical subset are 70.96% and 69.49%, respectively. The implementation and evaluation of this new extension are detailed below.