- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies template-free single-step retrosynthesis and argues that atom-level and functional-group-level features affect bond changes differently. MGSEKformer encodes an atom-level SMILES/graph pair and a pooled-subgraph pair produced by a pretrained MESPool module with parallel graph-injected Transformers, injects ElementKG element knowledge through an attention branch in the FFN, fuses the two granularities with bidirectional cross-attention and gating, and decodes reactant SMILES. It reports results on USPTO-FULL against 13 baselines, together with USPTO-50K results. The motivation is chemically reasonable, but the comparison protocol and the component evidence do not yet support the claimed breadth of improvement.
Critical strengths
Chemically grounded multi-granularity motivation. The paper explains why granularity matters with concrete chemistry, such as the acidic site of β-dicarbonyl compounds and positional activation effects, which is more specific than the usual multi-scale helps argument. Explicit alignment and gated cross-granularity fusion give a coherent way to combine local structure with sequence context.
Critical weaknesses
(i) The paper builds a new deduplicated random 8:1:1 split of USPTO-FULL, while the baseline numbers appear to be taken from papers that used the original split, so the small margins over RXNGraphormer may compare different test sets. Training uses R-SMILES augmentation, yet R-SMILES itself is not compared.
(ii) USPTO-50K is a subset of USPTO-FULL, overlap between its test reactions and the FULL training data needs to be ruled out. On USPTO-50K the model is below several baselines at every k, which is not discussed and conflicts with the claim of optimal multi-candidate performance in the abstract. I think the conclusion should be scoped to strong multi-candidate results in the reported USPTO-FULL setting.
Minor
The main text points to a theoretical derivation in the appendix, which contains architecture details only.
The paper's topic is fair enough for a chemical journal, but these papers are usually hard to accept for ICLR, unless you are solving a new direction in chemistry with AI-adapted modules. Currently, this does not affect my scoring, and I will recheck other reviewers' comments.
Questions for authors
See weaknesss