- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper considers the problem of multi-objective service orchestration of ML and AI workloads, considering the energy cost of orchestration. The proposed GENO framework uses decomposition-dominance coordination (DDC) along with an energy-augmented state encoder to encourage finding a Pareto optimal solution that is energy optimal.
Critical strengths
The paper puts forward an interesting argument that existing methods leveraging multi-objective service orchestration result in diversity collapse, potentially resulting in a conservative exploration of the solution space.
Critical weaknesses
The novelty of the paper is unclear, both in terms of the problem considered and in terms of the methodology.
The main claim made in the abstract that the proposed method results in a monotonic improvement of the green-weighted objective is never referenced again and is not supported by evidence provided in the paper.
The use of the Tchebycheff scalarizing function to scalarize multiple objectives (5) is far from novel. Yet, the paper does not discuss the related works.
The problem description as part of the system model is not well-motivated. The system model simply states the objectives (2)-(3) without any motivation.
The description of the methodology is vague; key details of the steps in the proposed algorithm, such as decision pruning and complexity of solving the optimization, have been omitted.
The writing at several places is very verbose but at the same time the paper does not introduce the concepts or the terms discussed, making it extremely hard to follow the arguments.
The experimental evaluation does not discuss the evaluation methodology. This makes it hard to assess the relevance of the evaluation.
Questions for authors
Does the system model account for the CPU energy consumption induced by AI workloads? Eqn (1) states that only non-AI workloads lead to CPU utilization.
Why does the choice of guarantee properly Pareto-optimal minimizers (line 198)? This claim appears to be unsupported.
Why does the proposed objective lead to a monotonic improvement? How does this differ from existing methods?
What was the evaluation methodology for the results presented in Section 5? What were the considered workloads, the load imposed, and the requirements - latency, resource utilization, etc?