- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
PRISM combines measured or modeled IT energy with regional environmental intensities and allocated hardware-manufacturing impacts to characterize energy, carbon, water, and biodiversity consequences of LLM serving. It distinguishes configuration selection from regional placement, derives ranking invariance under a separable operational model and a lifecycle crossover condition, and solves normalized minimax-regret routing problems. The evaluation includes offline regional routing, rolling-horizon routing, and a joint configuration-region extension with agent completion time. The main reported result is a 50.2% median reduction in worst-case regret relative to the adapted WaterWise baseline.
Critical strengths
The paper evaluates an important trade-off with explicit functional units
There is meaningful implementation and sensitivity work
Critical weaknesses
a) The claimed decision theory and optimization evidence do not yet establish a substantial methodological advance. Under Eq. 2 , operational impacts are positive scalar multiples of the same energy, making Propositions 1-2 consequences of the assumed model; the crossover condition is the corresponding rearrangement after adding emodied terms. Likewise, an exact four-dimensional minimax solver is expected to perform best on its own worst-case-regret objective against single-objective or carbon-water policies. The 50.2% result quantifies the effect of changing the decision objective, but does not by itself demonstrate a superior optimization method.
b) The water-accounting formulas are not equivalent as written, and the reported uncertainty test does not resolve this issue. Tab. 1 is repeated in Tab. 3, uses [WUE(r,t)+PUE(r,t) EWIF(r,t)] WSF(r), applying the datacenter-region stress factor to electricity-related water. Appx A.1 (i.e., Eq 14 -15) instead weights each electricity-related water flow by WSF at its location, explicitly not uniformly at the datacenter region; EWIF is defined there as the unweighted total water intensity. These formulations require an additional co-location/equal-stress assumption or a different EWIF definition to agree. The distinction can affect regional water rankings and the 4.637% regret headline. The rolling-horizon 20% noise experiment perturbs future inputs while observing the current hour exactly and knowing deman/capacity; it does not validate the underlying water-flow geography or current environmental coefficients (Appx. A.7.1).
Questions for authors
a) Which water formula is implemented? Please reconcile Tab. 1/3 with Eqs. 14 & 15, and identify the locations assigned to electricity-related water flow, and show whether the main water-regret and routing conclusions persist under the consistent formulation.
b) Under the same normalized minimax decision rule, what consequential decisions change when biodiversity is added to energy/carbon/water? A matched-objective dimensional ablation would isolate the benefit of the fourth dimension from the benefit of replacing a weighted-sum objective with minimax regret.
c) How stable are the selected regions and the headline regret improvement to uncertainty in the current water-stress/electricity-water/biodiversity coefficients, rather than only independent future forecast noise? A bounded sensitivity analysis on the existing routing instance would materially affect my assessment.
6 comments
Response to Reviewer nWEW (Part 2)
2. Water formula used in the implementation
Which water formula is implemented? Please reconcile Tables 1/3 with Eqs. 14–15, identify the locations assigned to electricity-related water flows, and show whether the main conclusions persist.
The implementation uses the formula in Tables 1/3, a regional approximation of Eqs. 14–15. It applies one regional water-stress factor, , to both direct cooling water and electricity-related water:
Electricity-related water comes from the datacenter region's own grid. combines the region's hourly generation mix [1] with per-source water-consumption factors [2], without electricity imports or exports. In Eqs. 14–15, indexes where each water flow occurs, such as a power plant's watershed. Setting for all of region 's electricity-related water reduces Eqs. 14–15 to the formula above. The reviewer is correct that the paper did not state this condition.
We use this approximation because plant-level water consumption linked to source watersheds is not available across regions. Prior work makes the same choice: WaterWise [8] and ThirstyFLOPS [9] also apply the datacenter region's factor to both direct and electricity-related water. The water-stress factors come from AWARE 2.0 [3].
All results, including the 4,637% energy-to-water regret and the routing results, use this formula. We agree that the rolling-horizon forecast experiment does not test water-use locations; our response (part 3) addresses uncertainty in the current coefficients.
Appendix A.1 now states the location-based scope, defines and , states the approximation , and derives the Table 1 formula from Eqs. 14–15 (new Eq. 16).
3. Decisions that change when biodiversity is added
Under the same normalized minimax decision rule, what consequential decisions change when biodiversity is added to energy, carbon, and water?
Adding biodiversity has almost no effect in the original 12-region experiment, but changes routing in a selected four-region set where biodiversity matters.
We compare PRISM restricted to energy, carbon, and water, called PRISM-ECW, with PRISM using all four dimensions. Both use the same minimax rule, workload, service constraints, and regional capacities. Only the set of dimensions changes.
In Figure 7 (12 regions, 24-hour Azure trace), carbon and water have the largest regrets and thus determine the tradeoff. Adding biodiversity changes worst-case regret and biodiversity regret by less than 0.02 percentage points in every capacity setting. Thus, biodiversity does not explain the reported improvement over WaterWise in Figure 7.
To test a case in which biodiversity can determine the worst-case regret, we select four regions from Table 10 using their measured environmental data: Sydney, Paris, Tel Aviv, and Johannesburg. The same Azure workload, hourly environmental data for June 24, 2024, capacity-generation procedure, and 20 capacity seeds are unchanged. We selected this set to test a case where biodiversity can affect the decision. The table reports median regret across the 20 capacity seeds. Regret is the increase above the best feasible value of each dimension.
| Policy | Energy | Carbon | Water | Biodiversity | Worst-case |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PRISM-ECW | 7.2% | 7.2% | 6.5% | 11.3% | 11.3% |
| PRISM | 7.6% | 6.5% | 2.0% | 7.6% | 7.6% |
Adding biodiversity also changes where requests are served. We present the mean share of GPU demand for each region across the 20 settings for both policy:
| Policy | Sydney | Paris | Tel Aviv | Johannesburg |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PRISM-ECW | 34.6% | 35.2% | 19.7% | 10.4% |
| PRISM | 33.6% | 35.2% | 27.8% | 3.5% |
These are mean shares of GPU demand across the 20 capacity settings.
PRISM-ECW uses Johannesburg partly because its low PUE reduces energy use. However, Johannesburg has the highest modeled biodiversity intensity among these four regions. PRISM moves most of this demand to Tel Aviv, and Johannesburg's share falls in 19 of the 20 settings. Biodiversity regret falls from 11.3% to 7.6% and water regret from 6.5% to 2.0%, while energy regret rises from 7.2% to 7.6%. Worst-case regret falls in all 20 settings.
This is a concrete decision change: PRISM moves demand away from the region whose grid harms biodiversity most, at a small energy cost. PRISM finds from the data whether biodiversity matters, so operators do not need to know this in advance.
Section 7 now reports both results in Table 2. Appendix A.7.6 gives the per-dimension regrets (Table 15) and the routing change (Table 16).
Response to Reviewer nWEW (Part 3)
4. Sensitivity to uncertainty in current environmental coefficients
How stable are the selected regions and the headline regret improvement to uncertainty in current coefficients, rather than only future forecast noise?
The findings hold under uncertainty in the current environmental coefficients. These coefficients are the paper's operational impact intensities, and their uncertainty comes from the per-source electricity factors behind them.
Uncertainty model
Each regional intensity is the generation-weighted sum of per-source factors, , where is the generation share of energy source and is its factor. We now state this equation in Appendix A.1 (Eq. 20).
Following RHODES [7], these per-source factors have data-availability uncertainty: each is published as a range over a few estimates, too few to fit a distribution. For example, hydropower water consumption ranges from 5.4 to 68.1 L/kWh across three estimates [4]. We therefore bound each factor by its published range.
- Varied: carbon, water, NOx, and SO2 factors of 8 of the 10 energy sources (32 factors), with water ranges from [4] and the others from [5]. Biodiversity is recomputed from these through ReCiPe [6].
- Fixed: generation shares [1], water-stress factors [3], PUE, and WUE, which have no published ranges.
One factor vector applies to all regions and hours. For Figure 6, we compute the exact range of each cross-regret over the full set by linear programming. We also evaluate 2,048 extreme factor combinations (stress points).
Regional choices and cross-dimensional regret
For annual intensities (Figure 6, left), most cross-regrets move above and below their point estimates but stay positive. The energy-to-water regret ranges from 2,303% to 6,888%, compared with 4,637% at the point estimates. Only the carbon–biodiversity and water–biodiversity regrets can reach zero, at 1.3% and 2.3% of the stress points. Each dimension's selected region (Melbourne, Los Angeles, Kuala Lumpur, and Frankfurt) also has the smallest worst-case regret over the full range, so the regional selection is stable.
For hourly intensities (Figure 6, right), the disagreement persists over the full range in all 72 hours for pairs involving energy, and in 64 and 60 hours for carbon–water and water–biodiversity.
Routing performance with fixed decisions
For Figure 7, we fix each policy's allocation and evaluate it at the 2,048 stress points, recomputing the four per-dimension optima at each point. Robust PRISM bounds the regret at 256 separate training combinations and remains a linear program. Ideal routing re-solves PRISM with the true factors known, which gives a lower bound for any policy. The table reports worst-case regret as the median over the 20 capacity settings.
| Policy | Point estimates | Median over stress points | Maximum over stress points |
|---|---|---|---|
| WaterWise | 157.8% | 151.9% | 252.0% |
| PRISM | 75.1% | 95.8% | 146.1% |
| Robust PRISM | 85.2% | 104.2% | 130.7% |
| Ideal routing | — | 75.5% | 128.6% |
PRISM keeps both statistics well below WaterWise, in 19 and 18 of the 20 settings. Much of its remaining regret is inherent: ideal routing has a median of 75.5%, and PRISM exceeds it by a median of 25.3 percentage points, compared with 76.2 for WaterWise. Robust PRISM lowers the maximum from 146.1% to 130.7% in all 20 settings, close to the 128.6% lower bound. In exchange, its regret is higher at the point estimates and at the median stress point, so operators can choose by risk preference.
Appendix A.1 adds the intensity equation. New Appendix A.6 gives the uncertainty model and the Figure 6 range table (Table 13), and Figure 6 now shows the hourly ranges as shaded bands. Sections 6 and 7 summarize the results, with routing in Table 2. Appendix A.8.1 gives robust PRISM and ideal routing (Table 17).
Response to Reviewer nWEW (Part 1)
Thank you for the detailed comments. We have clarified the contribution, explained the water formula used in the implementation, and added the two requested experiments.
The new comparisons separate the effect of the decision rule from the effect of adding biodiversity. The sensitivity analysis tests uncertainty in current electricity-related coefficients, rather than only future forecast errors. We explain the scope and limits of each test below. All changes are highlighted in the revised PDF.
1. Contribution of the propositions and optimization results
We agree. PRISM does not introduce a new accounting model or a new optimization algorithm. The 50.2% result measures the effect of changing the decision objective. It does not show that PRISM has a better solver. We have revised the text to make these claims explicit.
Under fixed deployment conditions, each operational impact is IT energy multiplied by a fixed impact intensity (Eq. 2). It is how operational impacts are defined in established accounting methods in both iterature and industry practice:
PRISM’s contribution is the combined analysis of serving decisions across energy, carbon, water, and biodiversity. It compares these dimensions under common service requirements and accounting boundaries, identifies when they select different configurations or regions, and measures the resulting penalties.
PRISM uses an established minimax method to select a compromise. The optimization experiments show the tradeoffs produced by the selected objective, rather than solver superiority. The new comparison below also separates this effect from the effect of including biodiversity.
We have revised the contribution statement in Section 1 to make this scope clearer.
References