- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
GFC introduces a geometry-aware corruption process for generative imitation learning, using learned trajectory dependencies and random metric deformations to produce structured perturbations for reverse policy learning.
Critical strengths
The controlled comparisons are valuable and the evaluation is comrehensive.
Critical weaknesses
-
The relationship between response learning, metric refinement, random deformation, source fitting, and reverse generation should be explained more intuitively.
-
The practical specification of the terminal source remains insufficiently clear. The paper notes that the proposed forward process does not automatically converge to a known Gaussian, but the conditional source model used for robot experiments requires further implementation details and validation.
-
The real-world Diffusion Policy baseline performs unexpectedly poorly, achieving only 2/100 successes on T-block pushing and 0/100 on box uprighting. Further evidence that the baseline was adequately trained and evaluated is important for interpreting the large performance gap.
-
Some experimental descriptions are inconsistent. For example, Section 4.4 reports 200 demonstrations per real-world task, whereas Appendix E.6 reports 100 demonstrations for box uprighting.
Questions for authors
please address the concerns above
Thanks for your response. So far, I don't see any revisions in the paper. As such, I will consider this concern still open and will wait for the revision to determine if the concern is resolved.
PS: please highlight the updated lines in a different color so that its clear whether something has changed.