- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposed a method for enforcing temporal consistency by guiding action sampling using energy gradient and also using energy for selecting the optimal action from a set of candidates as an inference compute scaling approach. The paper tests the algorithm on several control tasks in both simulation and real world.
Critical strengths
The greatest strength of this paper, in my opinion, is that it demonstrates a principled way of integrating verification into the action generation process itself such that temporal consistency is bolstered. The two crucial ingredients are: (1) temporal token and (2) the energy gradient. While I find it still, somewhat, dubious that the temporal token can be trained sufficiently accurately, the paper proposes a principled manner in which the energy gradient can be used during action chunk sampling as well as post-hoc action selection. This is strictly stronger than the naive approach the reader could have considered which is simply using the verifier at test-time.
The paper carries out a meticulous set of ablations to understand the strengths and weaknesses of each component. The part that I found particularly helpful is understanding whether the energy framework is being used in a guidance-only versus verification-only setting.
The paper showcases the strengths of the method on both simulation and real world tasks that are sufficiently difficult in my opinion. In particular, the water filling task is a somewhat more dynamic task, which is interesting. The results quantifying jerkiness in figure 6 are quite illuminating.
Critical weaknesses
Minor:
-
“Yet existing verification-based methods face two key limitations. First, they suffer from temporal myopia, generating and evaluating candidate actions based solely on the current observation. For generative policies, successful execution requires not only selecting high-quality candidates for the current observation, but also ensuring that consecutive action chunks form a coherent trajectory.” This part is misleading because both BID [1] and RTC [2] take into consideration temporal consistency. In particular, BID considers consistency with prior actions and also allowing for sufficient reactivity to unexpected changes. It is somewhat confusing because your introduction does cite these papers and, yet, says that existing methods fail on this front. If the claim is rather that these existing methods do not properly address such problems, then you should make that claim instead and provide sufficient justification for it.
-
The specificities of what is in equation (4) is unclear to me. Is this just the base pre-trained model? If not, what is it? How do you ensure that the temporal token is not excessively constrained by this “lightweight prediction model” ?
Major:
- Comparison to RTC is lacking. RTC [2] is known to be a very strong baseline and the lack of comparison to it in any setting is disappointing.
- All simulation testbeds are perfectly static environments. The authors can consider more stochastic environments such as multi-agent settings or even by simply adding stochastic noise to next state transitions in the static environments (similar to the experiments in BID).
- The paper observed that the gradient-based steering is unreliable without final candidate selection. It would be helpful to understand what exactly is the reason for it. In particular, I am interested in knowing whether this is due to the temporal token itself being sub-optimal or whether this is a modeling problem in .
Questions for authors
- “Task success does not increase monotonically with the number of sampled candidates, indicating that additional samples are not automatically beneficial.” It would be interesting to test an alternative distribution-aware method of selectin (as opposed to equation 8 which simply chooses the m that minimizes the energy). As such, out-of-distribution chunks could be ruled out.
4 comments
Rebuttal by Authors (2)
Major W3. Understanding the limitations of gradient-based guidance
Thank you for this insightful question. To investigate why gradient-based guidance is unreliable without final verification, we conducted additional experiments on LIBERO-Plus examining energy-gradient behavior, temporal conditioning, and guidance magnitude. Our findings suggest that the limitation is more closely related to the reliability of local energy-based refinement than to temporal conditioning alone. Specifically, contrastive training directly supervises relative rankings between expert chunks and constructed negatives, whereas guidance additionally requires local energy gradients to provide beneficial refinement directions during flow integration.
(1) Energy-gradient analysis. We first examine whether energy-reducing updates also improve action quality, evaluated through distance to the expert action. Across 300 held-out episodes, gradient updates reduce the learned energy in 100.0% of history-conditioned interventions and 99.1% of current-only interventions. However, among these energy-reducing updates, the distance to the expert action increases in 50.5% and 49.1% of cases, respectively. These results indicate that reducing the learned energy does not necessarily improve alignment with the expert action at each refinement step. Importantly, this diagnostic examines individual gradient updates rather than the quality of completed guided candidates, which can still benefit downstream performance when combined with final verification.
(2) Effect of temporal conditioning. To determine whether this limitation originates from the temporal token, we additionally train a current-observation-only verifier that excludes preceding observations and action history during both training and inference. Table R2 compares current-only and history-conditioned verification, with and without guidance, under the same candidate budget ().
Table R2. Effect of temporal history on verification and guidance (success rate, %).
| Benchmark | Base | Verification (current) | Verification (history) | Guidance + Verification (current) | Guidance + Verification (history) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| LIBERO-Plus | 73.2 | 78.0 | 79.2 | 78.7 | 79.8 |
| Adjust Bottle | 86.0 | 84.0 | 91.0 | 92.0 | 95.0 |
| Pick Bottles | 48.0 | 49.0 | 62.0 | 51.0 | 64.0 |
History-conditioned verification outperforms current-only verification across all three settings, with these advantages persisting when guidance is enabled. We further evaluate guidance-only execution () on LIBERO-Plus, where current-only and history-conditioned models achieve 56.2% and 55.9% success, respectively. Thus, removing temporal conditioning does not resolve the limitations of guidance-only execution, while incorporating history improves candidate evaluation.
(3) Effect of guidance magnitude. We also investigate whether excessive guidance strength contributes to the observed limitations. Varying the guidance cap from 0.0025 to 0.0075 yields success rates of 55.9–57.0%, while reducing guidance strength to 0.2 achieves 56.3%, all close to the default guidance-only result of 55.9%. Thus, simply weakening guidance does not consistently improve performance.
Together, these findings suggest that the limitations of guidance are more closely associated with the reliability of local energy-based refinement than with temporal conditioning or guidance magnitude alone. While provides useful relative rankings for candidate selection, its local gradients do not always improve expert alignment. Final verification complements guidance by selecting among completed candidates, allowing the policy to benefit from guided generation without relying solely on individual refinement directions.
Minor W1. Distinction from BID and RTC
Thank you for identifying this ambiguity. We agree that BID and RTC explicitly address temporal consistency, and our original statement was overly broad. Our intention was to highlight the limitations of existing verification-based methods that evaluate candidates using current-step information, such as TACO, rather than to suggest that prior decoding and execution methods overlook temporal consistency.
We have revised the introduction to distinguish these approaches more clearly. Specifically, BID and RTC promote temporal consistency through their decoding and execution mechanisms, with BID also balancing continuity against responsiveness to new observations. In contrast, TeV learns a history-conditioned energy verifier that evaluates candidate actions using recent observation–action history, incorporating both action plausibility and temporal compatibility into candidate selection. Our contribution is therefore not the introduction of temporal consistency itself, but its integration into learned action verification and generation-time guidance. We have clarified this distinction and removed the overly general claim from the introduction.
Rebuttal by Authors (3)
Minor W2. Clarification of the auxiliary prediction head
Thank you for this question. The function in Eq. 4 is a separate two-layer MLP prediction head, rather than the frozen pretrained VLA policy. It maps the temporal token to a prediction of the next actions and is trained jointly with the temporal encoder and energy verifier. This head is used only during training and discarded at inference time.
Regarding the potential constraint on the temporal token, future-action prediction serves as an auxiliary training objective alongside the contrastive verification loss, as defined in Eq. 6. The temporal token is therefore optimized not only for future-action prediction but also for distinguishing expert actions from negative candidates. Moreover, the token directly conditions the energy verifier without passing through . Thus, the auxiliary prediction head does not impose an architectural bottleneck on the information available for verification.
Q1. Distribution-aware candidate selection
Thank you for this insightful suggestion. To investigate whether incorporating distributional support improves candidate selection, we additionally evaluate a support-gated energy selection strategy while keeping the pretrained policy and verifier frozen. Specifically, we construct a reference bank of action representations sampled from the frozen policy at demonstration observations. For each candidate, we estimate its empirical support using the distance to its fifth-nearest neighbor in this bank, where smaller distances indicate greater support. We retain the 75% most-supported candidates before applying minimum-energy selection. This conservative threshold removes the lowest-support candidate(s) while preserving alternatives for energy-based ranking (retaining 3, 6, and 12 candidates for , respectively), without additional model training.
Table R3. Effect of distribution-aware candidate selection on RoboTwin 2.0 (success rate, %).
| Task | Candidates (M) | Energy-Only | Support-Gated Energy | Δ (pp) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Adjust Bottle | 4 | 95.0 | 93.0 | −2.0 |
| 8 | 88.0 | 87.0 | −1.0 | |
| 16 | 87.0 | 87.0 | 0.0 | |
| Press Stapler | 4 | 54.0 | 54.0 | 0.0 |
| 8 | 57.0 | 56.0 | −1.0 | |
| 16 | 58.0 | 58.0 | 0.0 |
As shown in Table R3, support-gated selection does not outperform minimum-energy selection at any evaluated candidate budget, nor does it mitigate the performance decline on Adjust Bottle as the candidate count increases. One possible explanation is that feature-space proximity to the reference distribution does not necessarily reflect action quality under the current execution context. These results suggest that additional support-based filtering, under the evaluated configuration, provides no improvement over history-conditioned energy verification, supporting our use of minimum-energy selection.
Dear Reviewer TxWC,
Thank you again for your time and thoughtful feedback on our paper! As the author–reviewer discussion period draws to a close, we wanted to follow up and express our hope that the additional evidence and revisions have addressed your concerns. Your suggestions have helped us to strengthen the paper, and we would be happy to discuss any further questions.
Best regards,
The Authors
Rebuttal by Authors (1)
Thank you for your thoughtful and constructive feedback! In response, we have conducted additional experiments and analyses, expanded our baseline comparisons, and clarified our methodology and contributions in the revised manuscript. We hope these additions address your concerns and welcome any further discussion.
Thank you for this suggestion. To address this concern, we additionally evaluated RTC on the real-world Water Filling task, where stable and temporally consistent execution is particularly important, using the same policy backbone and evaluation protocol as our other baselines. RTC achieves a mean task-completion score of 48.8, compared with 40.5 for the base policy, 51.3 for BID, and 68.0 for TeV, representing a 19.2-point improvement over RTC.
While RTC employs training-free inpainting to maintain consistency with previously committed actions, TeV learns a history-conditioned energy verifier to evaluate and select candidate actions based on recent observation–action history. This additional comparison demonstrates TeV's stronger performance in the evaluated real-world setting, providing further evidence for the effectiveness of temporally aware action verification.
Thank you for this valuable suggestion. To evaluate robustness beyond deterministic execution, we conducted additional experiments on RoboTwin 2.0 by injecting stochastic disturbances into executed actions, following the disturbance-testing approach in BID. Specifically, we apply temporally correlated Gaussian noise (ρ=0.8) to arm-joint targets at each control step, with three disturbance levels: no noise, moderate noise (σ=0.025 radians), and strong noise (σ=0.075 radians). Perturbed commands are clipped to valid joint limits, while gripper commands remain unchanged. These disturbances introduce stochastic variations into subsequent robot states, allowing us to evaluate performance under deviations from nominal execution. We compare Base, BID, and TeV under identical disturbance settings, with 100 trials per task, method, and noise level across all seven tasks.
Table R1. Performance under stochastic execution disturbances on RoboTwin 2.0 (average success rate, %).
As shown in Table R1, TeV consistently achieves the highest average success rate across all disturbance levels. Under moderate noise, TeV achieves 49.6%, outperforming Base (43.7%) and BID (45.6%). Under strong noise, all methods experience substantial degradation, with TeV achieving 20.3% compared with 18.6% and 17.0% for Base and BID. Although the performance margin narrows as disturbances intensify, these results indicate that TeV's benefits extend beyond deterministic execution. We have incorporated these additional experiments into Appendix D.