- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The key idea for superresolving the image has been to do a basic VAE type of reconstruction, and then try to add a super-resolved residue by learning it from the data. There have been experiments for quantitative and qualitative evaluation of the proposed technique.
Critical strengths
It "may" be a good idea to split the SR process into two steps as done, but there has not been any theoretical explanation as to why it should be done that way. Else there is very little novelty.
Critical weaknesses
There is very little novelty in this work. It is not that residue based SR has not been attempted before. There are many papers 2-3 decades ago that uses concepts like Wavelet, curvelet, ridgelet, etc for superresolving an image. The authors have not gone back to those methods for a lesson on how they tried to do it. Experimental results (both quantitative and qualitative) show marginal improvements, if at all any.
Questions for authors
The paper is titled prior preserving residue.... where is the prior? What was the model? Is that fixed or learned? It is not at all clear.
The paper title also uses a term like 'efficient' -- efficiency of what.? computation, parameterization, ease of learning, ....?
I have a very fundamental question -- AE is like a vector quantizer and a good VQ should have the property that the residual error must be white in spectrum. Else a better VQ can always be designed (use the orthogonality of the constructed signal and the residual signal). It is called the best unbiased estimator. If so, what is the technique that allows you to predict the residue? There's none! Then how do you justify your method?