- Rating
- 4(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
In general, this paper introduces a splat eak, which can identify whether one image is used to construct the 3DGS. The author also discusses how to reduce this potential private release problem. Overall, I think the introduced idea is interesting and could be useful in some scenarios when one image owner wants to verify whether his/her image is used by others to reconstruct 3D assets.
Critical strengths
(-) The idea itself is interesting, and I think this is the first study of such a membership inference problem in image-3DGS. I think some readers could find this paper useful and have some following works.
(-) Basically, it designs a method to find a candidate image's camera position. A naive solution to find the position could directly inverse render and continue to optimize the camera position to find the best similar scores, but it fails as it is hard to optimize. The introduced methods seem useful: 2D-3D matching and PnP estimation. Calculating photometric log-ratio just passed the estimation errors.
(+) Also studied how to avoid such a private release problem.
Critical weaknesses
(-) The proposed auditing framework relies on training multiple same-scene background reference models (default ), while the defense pipeline similarly requires pre-training 4 teacher models and generating synthetic supervision renders. In large-scale scenes or compute-constrained environments, this cumulative training overhead may pose a practical bottleneck. Under severe computational or time constraints, if the reference budget is compressed to fewer models (e.g., or ), what is the degradation trajectory regarding detection recall and false positive rate (FPR)? Furthermore, is there a lower-cost single-model calibration alternative viable for lightweight 3DGS deployments?
(-) When candidate poses are unknown, the localization pipeline relies on a registered set of public background photographs to construct a sparse 3D point cloud map via feature matching and PnP. If an adversary severely crops the background regions or if the auditor cannot obtain overlapping background imagery from the same scene, this feature-matching-based relocalization may fail. In cases with extremely sparse texture (where extracting sufficient inlier matches is challenging) or when registered background images are unavailable, is there a feasible strategy to directly invert the camera pose against the 3DGS radiance field without relying on explicit geometric mapping?
(-) The gray hline in Figure 1 could be darker, as the current version does not clearly divide into different parts enough.
Overall I think the idea is novel, and the experiment is compressive generally. I would keep my positive rating unless I see other serious weaknesses from other reviewers.
Questions for authors
Please see above.