- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes MiLD, a training-free detector for AI-generated images based on low-bit morphological residuals. The method identifies channel-disagreement locations using Hamming states, applies a masked low-bit reversal, and uses the feature discrepancy between the original and reversed images from a frozen encoder as the detection score. However, the experimental comparison is not sufficiently up to date for an ICLR 2027 submission. Although the paper cites recent works from 2026, the main experiments do not provide a comprehensive comparison with the latest detectors. Moreover, MiLD does not achieve the best overall performance: its five-benchmark mean AUROC is 80.14%, which is 4.41 points lower than WaRPAD. In addition, the technical novelty appears incremental, and the theoretical analysis does not fully explain why the proposed perturbation should distinguish real and generated images.
Critical strengths
1.The paper presents a simple and efficient training-free detector. MiLD only requires two forward passes of a frozen encoder and does not train an additional detector on target-domain real/fake images.
2.The use of low-bit morphological residuals and Hamming states to locate channel-disagreement locations is interesting and provides a clear motivation for the masked low-bit reversal.
Critical weaknesses
1.The experiments do not sufficiently compare against the latest relevant methods. Most of the main baselines are from 2024–2025. Although the paper discusses more recent works such as RDD and RAID, these methods are not included in the main performance comparison.
2.The relationship to existing low-bit and bit-reversal methods is not sufficiently clarified. The paper discusses LOTA, LIDA, and RAID, but the fundamental differences between these methods and MiLD are not fully established.
3 The generalization results are mixed and do not fully support the broad claims.
4The theoretical analysis provides limited insight into the actual detection mechanism. The Taylor expansion shows that the feature discrepancy measures the sensitivity of the frozen representation along the masked low-bit reversal direction. However, it does not explain why generated images should consistently produce a larger response than real images.
Questions for authors
1.Why do the authors not compare their method with more recent baselines? 2.Recent works, such as Effort (ICML25) HSIC(ICLR26), adopt accuracy (ACC) as the evaluation metric. Relying solely on AUC is insufficient to fully reflect detector performance.