- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
TrajectoryOp learns a solution operator with an explicit shock interface. An FNO encodes the initial field, two KAN decoders predict regional primitive states, and an initial-field-conditioned trajectory network locates the interface separating them. Training combines initial and sparse state labels with regional conservation-law residuals and a Rankine-Hugoniot interface loss. The physical constraints cover the entire prescribed time interval, including times without state labels. A graph interface x = xi(y,t) extends the formulation to two dimensions.
The paper tests Burgers, shallow water, one-dimensional Euler rarefaction-contact-shock solutions, and a two-dimensional Euler shock-entropy interaction. With 3.125% of the specified dense nonzero-time state-label tuple budget, TrajectoryOp reduces error against the strongest matched sparse baseline by approximately 77%, 48%, 41%, and 45%. Loss and joint interface/constraint ablations support the design. Dense FNO nevertheless remains more accurate on three of four main benchmarks. The contribution is a useful integration of established interface physics into operator learning, supported primarily by experiments rather than new theoretical guarantees.
Critical strengths
-
An interpretable mechanism for reducing state supervision. The interface is an explicit output whose motion is coupled to predicted traces through RH, while regional PDE losses constrain unlabeled states. This avoids forcing the tracked jump into a single continuous output representation and amortizes interface learning across initial conditions. It is a consequential, physically motivated design even though its individual ingredients are established.
-
Consistent sparse-budget improvements with useful controls. All four tests improve over the matched sparse external baselines. The paper includes loss ablations and a clearly labeled joint interface/RH ablation. Its label accounting and validation-time restrictions are transparent, and the FNO comparator is larger than TrajectoryOp in the reported one-dimensional Euler configuration. These features make the reported empirical signal more credible than an architecture comparison alone.
Critical weaknesses
-
The central smooth-region assumption is not reconciled with the tested wave structures. The Euler RCS family contains an untracked contact discontinuity. More directly, the stated shallow-water ranges admit two shocks: with g = 1, h_L = 1.2, h_R = 0.8, u_L = 0.6, u_R = -0.3, and x_0 = 0, the exact middle state is h_* = 1.47397, u_* = 0.36180. Both waves are compressive shocks, with speeds -0.68150 and 1.14736; both remain inside the domain through T = 0.5. No shallow-water pattern filter is stated. One hard interface leaves another discontinuity inside a branch treated as smooth, undermining the explanation for the regional strong residual. This does not prove that finite-resolution predictions are impossible, especially with diffuse targets, but it requires an explicit treatment and validation. Conservation/RH alone also does not ensure entropy admissibility, and the stated reference boundary conditions are not included in the described network constraints.
-
The evidence does not yet isolate the physical and label-efficiency advantage over suitable alternatives. The external baselines are data-only; the internal single-decoder control uses a global strong residual across shocks. An appropriate weak/conservative physics-informed learner is missing. References use spatially first-order Rusanov discretization without convergence or exact Riemann checks, and no quantitative shock-location, conservation, or admissibility metrics are reported. All runs use one seed. The 3.125% ratio is correct for nonzero-time state tuples, but not total information, independent simulations, or computational cost. Sparse TrajectoryOp has approximately 1.57, 2.30, and 1.72 times dense FNO's error on shallow water and the two Euler tasks, so broad comparable-performance language needs qualification.
Questions for authors
-
Does the actual shallow-water dataset exclude two-shock states? Please provide any filter and wave-pattern counts, identify the tracked front, and explain how the other shock is handled when such states are retained. Likewise, how is the Euler contact treated within the regional strong-residual rationale? The explicit within-range example above would be a useful diagnostic.
-
How are the extrapolation and reflecting boundary conditions imposed on the learned operator, or justified as inactive over the test horizon? What evidence supports admissibility of the predicted fronts on the current benchmarks? I am asking about the existing experiments, not requiring a general entropy theorem or arbitrary new boundary families.
-
Do the accuracy conclusions persist against exact one-dimensional Riemann solutions and a refined or higher-order two-dimensional reference? Please report interface-location and shock-local errors, conservation/jump diagnostics, and errors specifically after the last labeled time, rather than only global averages including t_0.
-
How does the contribution differ from LeFloch and Xiang's RH-guided FNO/explicit-shock construction (arXiv:2607.23143), and does the sparse-label advantage persist against an appropriate weak-form or conservative physics-informed learner, such as an adapted UNFV? The joint ablation already supplied is helpful, but does not answer this comparison. Relevant primary sources: https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.23143 and https://arxiv.org/abs/2505.23702.
-
How robust are the main and ablation differences across training seeds and label selections? Please also provide sufficient implementation detail to reproduce the exact two-dimensional perturbation and physical-coordinate differentiation through moving collocation points. If computational savings are intended beyond fewer state tuples, what are the numerical data-generation, training, and inference costs?
5 comments
Q2: Boundary Conditions and Post-Hoc Entropy Admissibility Diagnostics
Diagnostics on the test sets confirm that the predicted solutions respect both properties (Appendix A.2 & B.7):
- Boundary conditions: In 1D, all wave fronts over remain strictly inside the interior of (for 1D Euler on , extreme wave positions lie in ), and boundary-cell state variations across all three benchmarks are at most , so the extrapolation boundaries remain inactive. In 2D Euler, over , the mean wall normal velocity violation (exact reflecting condition: ) is for sparse TrajectoryOp, compared with for Dense FNO.
- Entropy admissibility: Across all 1024 test cases and all nonzero times (), the predicted shocks of Burgers, shallow water, and 1D Euler satisfy the Lax characteristic compression inequalities in 100% of cases. For 1D Euler, the thermodynamic entropy increases across the predicted shock in 84.3% of all case-time pairs.
Q3 & Weakness 2: Exact 1D Riemann Evaluation, -Refined 2D Convergence Check, and Late-Time/Conservation Metrics
Global exact-Riemann errors, extrapolation errors, shock-position errors, and local shock-band ( cells) errors are reported in General Response Tables 1–2 (Section 4.3, Table 2 & Appendix B.1, Table 10). Table 7 below provides the shock-position errors (comparing the maximum-gradient jump location across all models and the explicit trajectory of TrajectoryOp) together with the conservation drift over (Appendix B.1, Table 11).
For the 2D benchmark, we recomputed 8 uniformly spaced test cases at () and () grid resolutions using the same Rusanov solver (observing an convergence order of between and , consistent with a first-order scheme on discontinuous flows) and conservatively averaged the solution onto the base grid (Table 8; Appendix B.1, Table 12 & Figure 8). The original training labels themselves have an error of at relative to the reference. Evaluated against the -refined reference, sparse TrajectoryOp achieves lower error than Dense FNO at all stored times, showing that Dense FNO's lower error on the grid comes from fitting the numerical dissipation of the first-order training labels. The revised manuscript reports both the numerical-grid metrics (Table 1) and the exact and refined-reference evaluations (Section 4.3, Table 2).
Table 7: Late-time shock position error (grid cells at ) and conservation drift ()
| Diagnostic Metric & Model | Burgers | Shallow Water | 1D Euler | 2D Euler |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Flow-Jump Pos. Error (): TrajectoryOp (Sparse) | 0.61 / 1.21 | 0.67 / 1.29 | 4.76 / 8.66 | 0.91 / 2.64 |
| Flow-Jump Pos. Error (): FNO (Sparse) | 7.53 / 43.71 | 9.22 / 134.81 | 13.16 / 62.16 | 89.63 / 102.49 |
| Flow-Jump Pos. Error (): FNO (Dense) | 0.55 / 1.53 | 0.87 / 1.70 | 4.01 / 10.35 | 1.00 / 0.80 |
| Explicit Error (): TrajectoryOp (Sparse) | 0.58 / 1.19 | 0.61 / 1.26 | 4.75 / 8.65 | 0.96 / 2.64 |
| Conservation Drift (): TrajectoryOp (Sparse) | 0.0052 | 0.0074 | 0.0106 | -- |
| Conservation Drift (): FNO (Sparse) | 0.0417 | 0.0389 | 0.0395 | -- |
Table 8: 2D Euler evaluation against -refined reference solutions (relative error across 8 test cases)
| Reference / Model | Full Space-Time | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Original Numerical Labels | 0.0049 | 0.0040 | 0.0069 | 0.0079 |
| TrajectoryOp (Sparse) | 0.0050 | 0.0041 | 0.0069 | 0.0081 |
| FNO (Dense) | 0.0061 | 0.0054 | 0.0079 | 0.0087 |
| FNO (Sparse) | 0.0089 | 0.0052 | 0.0143 | 0.0233 |
Q4: Comparison with LeFloch & Xiang (arXiv:2607.23143) and Weak-Form / Conservative Learners (arXiv:2505.23702)
Comparison with PITT (LeFloch & Xiang, 2026): We have added a citation and discussion in Section 2.2. While PITT also uses the Rankine-Hugoniot relation to advance shocks, it is formulated and demonstrated for one-dimensional scalar balance laws (the Schwarzschild–Burgers model): it builds the explicit steady-state and generalized Riemann solutions of this model into the network and advances shocks by an analytical RH law at each rollout step, and its extension to systems is left to a follow-up work. In contrast, TrajectoryOp learns the shock trajectory as a continuous space-time operator output, applies to coupled conservation systems (shallow water, 1D Euler), and extends to 2D curved interfaces (2D Euler shock–entropy interaction).
Comparison with weak-form and conservative finite-volume learners: Under the same 3.125% sparse budget, we added a single-decoder Weak-Form Residual baseline (integrating against smooth compactly supported test functions) and a Conservative Finite-Volume (FV) Residual baseline (penalizing one-step Rusanov flux residuals across cells, following UNFV; Section 4.4, Table 3 & Appendix B.3). As shown in General Response Table 2 (and the ablation table in Reviewer aDub Q2), TrajectoryOp achieves lower extrapolation error than both the single-decoder Weak-Form and Conservative FV baselines across all four benchmarks; moreover, pairing the same weak-form residual with our two-branch representation outperforms the single-decoder weak-form model on every benchmark, confirming the benefit of explicit interface separation beyond the choice of weak or conservative loss.
Q5: Multi-Seed Robustness, Implementation Details, and Computational Cost
We repeated the main experiments, including the single-decoder strong-form model, across 3 seeds (1234, 2345, and 3456), where each seed sets both the network initialization and the selection of sparse labeled cases and spatial points (Table 9; Appendix B.2, Table 13). Across all four benchmarks, sparse TrajectoryOp achieves lower extrapolation error than the single-decoder strong-form model, sparse FNO, sparse DeepONet, and sparse Shift-DeepONet in every seed (3/3), and dense TrajectoryOp outperforms dense FNO in every seed on Burgers, shallow water, and 2D Euler. In addition, while the shock-position error of sparse FNO fluctuates widely across seeds ( cells), sparse TrajectoryOp stays near 1 cell on Burgers and shallow water with small variance.
Q1 & Weakness 1: Shallow-Water Wave Analysis and Euler Contact Discontinuity
Wave-type statistics and dominant-shock tracking in shallow water: The shallow-water dataset in Table 1 was sampled directly from the stated parameter ranges without filtering out two-shock states (Appendix A.1 & B.6). We verified the reviewer's calculation for the diagnostic example (h∗=1.47397,u∗=0.36180, wave speeds −0.68150 and 1.14736). Across the 1024 test cases of this unfiltered dataset, 515 cases (50.3%) satisfy h∗≤hL and consist of a left-going smooth rarefaction wave and a right-going shock, while the remaining 509 cases (49.7%; training: 516/1024, validation: 65/128) satisfy h∗>hL and contain two shocks. Because uL>0>uR and hL>hR, the h∗>hL cases are strongly asymmetric: the right-going wave is the dominant shock (median depth ratio h∗/hR≈2.0), whereas the left-going shock has a small jump amplitude (median depth ratio h∗/hL≈1.12). Initialized at the largest initial jump ξ0(a), TrajectoryOp tracks the right-going shock across the dataset (t8 position error of 1.45 cells), while the weak left-going wave stays inside the left region x<ξψ(t) and is approximated smoothly by the left decoder V^−.
Subgroup breakdown and single-shock (h∗≤hL) benchmark: Table 5 separates the unfiltered test set into these two subsets. Sparse TrajectoryOp is more accurate than Dense FNO on the h∗≤hL rarefaction-shock subset (0.0118 vs. 0.0122), whereas smoothing the weak left shock accounts for the higher error on the h∗>hL subset (0.0171 vs. 0.0133). When we restrict the initial-state sampling to h∗≤hL so that every case contains a single shock and retrain all models (Table 6), sparse TrajectoryOp (3.125% label budget) closely matches Dense FNO in both L1 error and shock position, while dense TrajectoryOp achieves the lowest error (0.0072 vs. 0.0110). We report this single-shock benchmark in the main text (Section 4.3, Table 2), and the unfiltered dataset remains in Table 1 with its subset analysis in Appendix B.6.
1D Euler contact discontinuity: As detailed in our reply to Reviewer nFCc (Q4), the contact discontinuity moves slower than the primary shock (u∗<sshock) and lies inside the left region x<ξψ(t) in 99.9% of test cases at t8. Because velocity and pressure are continuous across a contact wave ([u]=[p]=0), the left decoder V^− represents the density transition smoothly, contributing only 0.0036 (∼8%) to the relative L1 error without disturbing the regional PDE residual (Appendix B.7).
Table 5: Subgroup breakdown on the original shallow-water test set (full space-time relative L1 error against exact Riemann solutions)
Table 6: Shallow-water evaluation with h∗≤hL (left-going smooth rarefaction and right-going shock, evaluated against exact Riemann solutions)