- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper presents Hy3D for hierarchical 3D point-cloud segmentation. It maps point features from different semantic levels into a shared Poincaré ball and uses class prototypes, a parent-affinity loss, and a depth-aware radial loss to align the features with the taxonomy. Experiments cover Campus3D and a custom five-level hierarchical segmentation protocol on PartNeXt. The authors use PointNet++ on both datasets and additionally evaluate a PointNeXt encoder on PartNeXt, with Euclidean controls and component ablations.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
- The advance over existing Poincaré embeddings, prototype-margin constraints, and the Campus3D decoder is limited. The theoretical results are mainly hinge identities and a radial budget. The paper evaluates PartNeXt [3] using a custom five-level protocol rather than the dataset’s original class-agnostic part-segmentation benchmark, which includes PartField [4], SAMPart3D [5], and SAMesh [6]. The paper lacks comparisons with related methods such as DHL [1] and HyCoRe-seg [2], and does not compare with PartField [4], SAMPart3D [5], or SAMesh [6] under a common class-agnostic evaluation protocol. With PointNeXt, HE mean mIoU improves by only about 0.10 percentage points, compared with seed standard deviations of approximately 0.66–0.69 points.
The presentation is excessively defensive and repetitive. Statements that the theory does not establish "a special advantage of hyperbolic space," three-seed results "do not establish statistical significance," and qualitative examples represent local predictions "rather than test-set averages" repeatedly interrupt the argument and obscure the contribution. The figures are poorly explained: Figure 3 uses unnamed "leaf" labels, Figure 4 lacks a semantic legend, and neither identifies the errors being corrected.
- On Campus3D, M0 without the geometric losses already performs close to the full model. With the classification heads held fixed, adding the losses improves OA/mIoU by only 1.65/2.30 percentage points; on PartNeXt, the gains are about 0.6/1.0 points. PartNeXt path consistency barely changes, and prototype–taxonomy Spearman correlations are mostly only 0.1–0.3. The paper also does not report parent-retrieval and radial-constraint diagnostic results. The existing results do not show whether the parent-prototype constraint reduces cross-parent-branch errors in the classification heads before HE decoding.
[1] Chongshou Li et al. Deep Hierarchical Learning for 3D Semantic Segmentation. IJCV, 2025. Paper.
[2] Antonio Montanaro, Diego Valsesia, and Enrico Magli. Towards Hyperbolic Regularizers for Point Cloud Part Segmentation. ICASSP, 2023.
[3] Penghao Wang et al. PartNeXt: A Next-Generation Dataset for Fine-Grained and Hierarchical 3D Part Understanding. NeurIPS, 2025. Paper.
[4] Minghua Liu et al. PartField: Learning 3D Feature Fields for Part Segmentation and Beyond. 2025. Paper.
[5] Yunhan Yang et al. SAMPart3D: Segment Any Part in 3D Objects. arXiv:2411.07184, 2024. Paper.
[6] George Tang et al. Segment Any Mesh. arXiv:2408.13679, 2024. Paper.
Questions for authors
-
What specific limitations of the original protocol do the five-level mapping and the 8:1:1 split on PartNeXt respectively address? The original benchmark evaluates PartField, SAMPart3D, and SAMesh on class-agnostic part segmentation. Could you provide comparisons with these methods under a common class-agnostic protocol, and with DHL or HyCoRe-seg under your custom hierarchical protocol? Merely stating that "we study a given taxonomy" is insufficient to explain the absence of competitive baselines.
-
The parent-margin loss only constrains distances between child-level features and parent prototypes. The prototype bank is discarded at inference, and the classification weights are not tied to the prototypes. Please identify which result shows that this constraint reduces cross-parent-branch errors before HE decoding, rather than merely improving overall segmentation accuracy. Do the existing ablations distinguish improvements in classification within the same parent branch from reductions in errors across parent branches? If not, the paper has not demonstrated that the prototype-based geometric constraint improves the parent–child classification relationships it targets.