- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes AGTRL for recovering coarse hidden-screen content from a single RGB observation of its diffuse light on a wall. The method uses an encoder–decoder with two bottleneck components: AGRL forms a normalized convolutional feature update, and TraceTrust weights this update using local continuity, local deviations, and a learned gate. The network is trained with paired screen targets using an L1 reconstruction loss. Evaluation covers four screen-content datasets, comparisons with image-restoration methods, component ablations, and robustness experiments.
Critical strengths
The paper reports consistent improvements across four datasets, with a substantial gain on Screen2000. Compared with the strongest baseline in Table 1, PSNR improves from 23.44 to 24.71 dB, SSIM from 0.7990 to 0.8371, and LPIPS from 0.3261 to 0.2587. These results provide useful evidence that the proposed design can improve reconstruction in the evaluated setting.
The component evaluation is reasonably extensive. Table 2 removes or replaces the main components, while the supplementary experiments examine finer design choices and compare the combined module with standard attention mechanisms and a parameter-matched convolutional alternative in a shared U-Net. These controls provide support for the architectural contribution beyond the headline comparison.
Critical weaknesses
-
The baseline selection does not adequately establish the claimed advance over existing passive reconstruction methods. Section 2 explicitly discusses closely related approaches, including NLOS-OT, NLOS-LTM, and IR⁴Net, yet none is included in Table 1, and their exclusion is not explained. Comparing against a large collection of general restoration architectures leaves the most relevant task-specific comparison unresolved. The authors should evaluate an appropriate existing passive reconstruction method on the same paired data, or explain the concrete acquisition, supervision, or implementation constraints preventing such a comparison. Without this, the claim of state-of-the-art performance rests on an incomplete comparison set.
-
The baseline adaptation and training protocol is insufficiently documented to assess the fairness of Table 1. Section 4.1 specifies paired splits and states that a separate model is trained for each dataset, but does not explain how the 20 baseline methods were initialized, adapted, and trained for wall-to-screen reconstruction. The reported MAE/AdamW settings appear in the AGTRL description and are not explicitly stated to apply to the baselines. Since many compared methods were originally developed for different restoration tasks, their task-specific training and model selection are essential to interpreting the results. Without the training schedules, tuning procedure, and checkpoint-selection criteria, it is difficult to determine whether the reported advantages reflect the proposed design or differences in how the methods were adapted and optimized.
Questions for authors
-
Why are the closely related passive reconstruction methods discussed in Section 2 absent from Table 1? Please provide a comparison with an appropriate method on the same paired data, or explain the specific constraints preventing it.
-
Were all 20 baselines trained or fine-tuned on the stated wall–screen training splits? Please clarify their initialization, task-specific modifications, training schedules, tuning procedure, and checkpoint selection.