- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies recovery of the current front-view RGB screen content from a camera observation of a wall or door illuminated by the hidden display. It focuses on two core challenges: useful screen evidence is compressed and mixed with nuisance appearance. To recover screen content from this mixed glow, the paper proposes Reflection-Evidence Routed Representation Learning (RERL), a recovery path designed to promote evidence alignment and degradation-aware feature. Across four screen-content groups verifies the effectiveness of the proposed RERL.
Critical strengths
1.The writing is good 2.The research task is intriguing, but the methodology is relatively conventional.
Critical weaknesses
-
Figure 2 exhibits obvious AI-generated artifacts and needs to be redesigned to provide a complete and proper pipeline overview of the proposed method.
-
The literature review in the related work section is outdated, with references extending only up to 2023. The authors should include recent literature, such as [1–10], and incorporate them into the comparative analysis in Table 1.
-
The paper lacks the required AI USE STATEMENT.
[1] Tang N, Nie S, Luo X, et al. Degradation-Consistent Test-Time Adaptation for All-in-One Image Restoration[C]//Proceedings of the IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition. 2026: 15476-15485.
[2] Jo S, Ko D, Kang J, et al. Flow Straight to Reality: Perceptually Consistent Flow Matching for Efficient Image Restoration[C]//European Conference on Computer Vision. Cham: Springer Nature Switzerland, 2026: 223-239.
[3] Zhou S, Zhang J, Huang W, et al. QuReC: All-in-One Image Restoration with Query-Specific Guidance and Local-Global Response Calibration[J]. arXiv preprint arXiv:2607.15097, 2026.
[4] Lee H, Kang S, Yu J, et al. Tasktok: Delving into task tokens for task-driven image restoration[C]//European Conference on Computer Vision. Cham: Springer Nature Switzerland, 2026: 447-464.
[5] Lee H, Son M, Yu J, et al. LogicIR: Logic Gate Networks for Image Restoration[C]//European Conference on Computer Vision. Cham: Springer Nature Switzerland, 2026: 394-411.
[6] Zheng Y, Li W, Liu Z. Image Restoration via Diffusion Models with Dynamic Resolution[J]. arXiv preprint arXiv:2605.14267, 2026.
[7] Xiao F, Hu P, Xu L, et al. Beyond ground-truth: Leveraging image quality priors for real-world image restoration[J]. arXiv preprint arXiv:2603.29773, 2026.
[8] Chen I, Hadji I, Sanchez E, et al. Restore, Assess, Repeat: A Unified Framework for Iterative Image Restoration[J]. arXiv preprint arXiv:2603.26385, 2026.
[9] Dong G, Li C, Ren C, et al. Learning domain-aware task prompt representations for multi-domain all-in-one image restoration[C]//International Conference on Learning Representations. 2026, 2026: 133754-133777.
[10 ] Zeng X, Yu Y, Xiong S, et al. ShiftLUT: Spatial Shift Enhanced Look-Up Tables for Efficient Image Restoration[J]. arXiv preprint arXiv:2603.00906, 2026.
- In the ablation study (Table 3), the authors should provide experimental results where both CDERL and DAR are simultaneously removed.
Questions for authors
Q1: What is the core novelty of the proposed method?
Q2: Compared to the latest literature [1–10], does the proposed method still achieve superior/state-of-the-art performance across Lock, Game, Screen, and Figure?
Q3: What are the experimental results when CDERL and DAR are simultaneously removed?
Please refer to the "Critical Weaknesses" section for further details.
Response to Reviewer p4ZT
Thank you for recognizing the task. The revised paper has been uploaded, and we answer each point.
Q1. Core novelty.
Restoration networks, including the ten 2026 methods in your list, start from an input that is registered to its target and condition on a degradation type, an image domain, or a quality prior. In a wall reflection, the screen content reaches the wall through an unknown transport that mixes it spatially, and the strength of that mixing changes across the image and from capture to capture. CDERL keeps the feature content on which encoder and decoder agree, and DAR estimates the mixing per image and per region and routes and spatially guides the experts on that estimate.
Controls replace the modules at the same locations with gated cross-attention, a VQ bridge, and a four-expert global mixture. Parameters and FLOPs differ by at most 1.6% from RERL, and all use RGB L1 only, with mean±SD over three seeds.
On the same test content at two mixing strengths, the margin over a concatenation bridge grows with the mixing.
Q2. Recent literature and comparative performance.
Table 1 compares with AdaIR (ICLR 2025), DarkIR and HVI-CIDNet (CVPR 2025), DeepSN-Net and DExNet (TPAMI 2025), and DEA-Net (TIP 2024), and Table 3 uses UniRes (ICCV 2025).
We adapted all ten methods to paired reconstruction and trained them on our reflection-target pairs with the training schedule, splits, and full test sets used for Table 1. The three all-in-one methods, [1], [3], and [9], reach the level of the Table 1 baselines.
The other seven build on generative priors, quality priors, tokenizers, or lookup operators learned on natural images, and their PSNR on this task is lower.
RERL leads all ten on every group in PSNR, SSIM, and LPIPS. [1] and [9] are the closest to our setting and are now cited in the revised related work.
Q3. Simultaneously removing CDERL and DAR.
With both modules removed, PSNR falls below the full model by 1.321/0.819/1.447/8.715 dB on Lock/Figure/Game/Screen, and the backbone is below the full model on every group in all three metrics. The row is now the first row of the revised Table 3.
Figure 2 and AI use statement. Figure 2 has been redrawn as a complete pipeline overview in three panels, in which each block carries its equation, Eqs.(2)–(5), or its section of Appendix C. The original Figure 2 was rendered from SVG to PNG directly using Python's CairoSVG, which caused artifacts. This time as well, but we identified and resolved the issue with this conversion. The required AI use statement has been added to the revised paper.
We ask that the rating be reconsidered in light of these additions.