- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
Tri-Mem is an online few-shot method for industrial anomaly detection. It keeps the initial normal support features fixed and maintains two additional memories using low- and high-scoring patches from previous test images. Using frozen DINOv3 features, it combines distances to normal references with a bounded score from the anomaly memory. The authors evaluate the method on four industrial datasets and provide component ablations. On MVTec AD 2, the full method improves average pixel AUPRO by 4.6 percentage points and image AUROC by 3.2 points over the fixed-memory baseline across four support budgets.
Critical strengths
- Support-image augmentation helps reduce sensitivity to lighting changes when normal references are scarce. The three-memory design preserves the initial support features while adding normal and suspicious patterns from the test stream, allowing adaptation without replacing the original references.
- The method provides strong region-level localization results. It achieves the highest reported pixel AUPRO across all four few-shot budgets on MVTec AD 2 and at 2-, 4-, and 8-shot on BTAD. The memory and augmentation ablations provide evidence for the benefits of the main components.
Critical weaknesses
- The reliability of online updates is not sufficiently evaluated. The method selects normal and suspicious patches using its own scores, so selection errors can affect later predictions. However, evaluation uses only one fixed test-stream order, with no reported variation across repeated runs. Candidate purity and error accumulation are left for future work. The reported gains therefore need validation across different stream orders.
- Comparisons with closely related online methods are incomplete. The paper discusses few-shot online anomaly detection by Wei et al. but provides no quantitative comparison. Several online baselines are implemented by the authors, yet their selection and update rules are not sufficiently described. This limits the assessment of the gains over existing online approaches.
Questions for authors
- Do the gains remain consistent when the test images arrive in a different order? Please report the mean and standard deviation over several test orders, comparing the full method with the frozen core and the core plus normal memory.
- Can the authors add comparisons with other online anomaly detection methods under the same few-shot setting and briefly describe any changes made to the baseline methods?
- The joint-compression ablation allows the initial support features to be removed and also reduces the total normal-memory capacity. Can the authors keep the total capacity the same and compare keeping these features fixed versus allowing them to be removed? This would clarify the benefit of protecting the initial references.
- The augmentation ablation removes brightness changes and RGB shifts together. Since color changes can themselves be defects, can the authors test RGB shifts separately and report their effect on detecting color defects?