- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces a two-stage method, Hash Guided Diffusion. Stage-1: Nuvo constructs a multi-chart YV parameterization of a coarse simulated garment. Stage-2: Diffusion model generates residual displacement fields using hash encoding. DDPM and deterministic ODE are both tested. The results are promising with 10 steps for stiff garments. Howver, this paper lacks clear novelty, enough ablations for claimed benefits, enough evidence for claimed results (rendered qualitative results and inference times). I believe it can be difficult to addrss all concerns within rebuttle period. I suggest rejection.
Critical strengths
The pratical problem for reducing the computational cost of high-frequency surface refinement is well-motivated.
The two-stage design is natrual.
Critical weaknesses
- The methodological novelty of this paper is unclear. The proposed pipeline mainly integrate existing methods.
- The evidence of design choice is not enough. The authors claimed that the efficient 10 step refinement is from geometry aligned residual representation and hash encoding. However, although the paper introduces baselines without Nuvo and without hash encoding, their numberical result are not included in the main comparision. So it is unclear whether the reduced sampling requirement results from the proposed representation or simply from applying a short-step diffusion solver.
Questions for authors
- Why Panel L2 changes when the sewing patterns are fixed?
- Could authors provide multi-gartment results, real rendering?
- Could authors provide ablation studies regarding w/o Nuvo, w/o hash, direct residual-fitting?
- Could authors provide inference times, function evaluations?
Answers to the Questions one by one
Thank you for the review feedback.
Q1. We will verify the metric implementation and clarify how the metric is computed in the revision.
Q2. We agree that evaluating refinement quality and generalization requires results across multiple garments, with reference renderings and close-up views of the refined surfaces.
Q3. We will verify the implementation and clarify the metric definition and evaluation protocol in the revision.
Q4. As reported in Appendix A.4, the full two-stage optimization takes approximately 2–3 hours per garment on a single NVIDIA H200 GPU.