- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
SonarLLM adapts a multimodal language model to underwater sonar and optical inputs using a dedicated sonar encoder, modality-specific feature enhancement, and reliability-supervised fusion. Its staged training combines sonar representation learning, semantic alignment, and instruction tuning. The paper evaluates sonar and fusion tasks and uses controlled optical degradation to analyze the fusion gate.
Critical strengths
- The dedicated acoustic pathway addresses sonar-specific processing rather than treating sonar as an ordinary RGB image. The staged adaptation and modality-specific processing form a coherent approach to an important underwater perception problem.
- The paired degradation evaluation keeps the scene and sonar input fixed while changing the optical input. Together with gate and feature ablations, this is useful evidence about the intended fusion behavior.
Critical weaknesses
- The interaction between range compensation and the following normalization remains unclear. Equation (4) applies a positive scalar gain to each token and then channel-wise LayerNorm; the supplied acoustic implementation follows that order. Apart from the normalization epsilon, LayerNorm cancels such scaling, so the claimed attenuation compensation needs a different mechanism or direct evidence that it survives this operation.
- Reliability supervision and the main turbidity stress test use the same synthetic degradation generator. As the paper acknowledges, these results establish adaptation within that controlled family. This limits the demonstrated scope of the fusion benefit; broader reliability under natural turbidity or unmodeled sensor failures remains open.
Questions for authors
- What range-dependent information remains after LayerNorm, and what happens when only the range-gain component is removed?
- Can the gate retain its advantage on naturally degraded observations or a degradation generator excluded from training?
3 comments
Response to Reviewer kcTM(Q2)
Thank you for your question. The gate maintains its advantage under naturally degraded observations or when the degradation generator is excluded from training.
Specifically, the test set used in our paper is constructed from held-out real sonar-optical acquisition sequences from RGBS50 and UMOD:
Sec. 4.1: "Evaluation samples come from held-out RGBS50 and UMOD sequences (25 subsets, 150 QA instances each; zero training overlap confirmed by a sequence–frame audit, Appendix C)"
From the perspective of the entire test set, different samples preserve the diverse targets, backgrounds, and sonar-optical discrepancies from various real collected scenes. Therefore, it enables a valid evaluation of the model's degradation adaptation capability on "naturally degraded observations".
Finally, we sincerely thank you for this question, and we will further refine the description in the revised manuscript to make this point clearer.
Dear Reviewer kcTM,
Thank you again for your valuable comments on our submission. We would like to kindly confirm whether we have sufficiently addressed all of your concerns (or at least part of them).
Should there be any remaining questions or areas requiring further clarification, please do not hesitate to let us know.
If you are satisfied with our responses, we would greatly appreciate your consideration in adjusting the evaluation scores accordingly.
We sincerely look forward to your feedback.
Response to Reviewer kcTM(Q1)
Thank you for this valuable question. After layer normalization, the distance-dependent information retained includes the relative contrast of echoes, speckle statistics, echo waveform morphology, multipath and sidelobe structures, as well as range-varying noise distributions. These are relative structural features that do not rely on the absolute amplitude of the signal.
If we remove the range-gain component only, only the constant-scale contribution from this saturated gain term is discarded, while all distance-related structural features remain intact. We sincerely appreciate this comment, which helps us refine our presentation. We will clarify this mechanism in the revised manuscript.