- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies the representation efficiency of compressed pluggable memory in large language models, with a focus on the rank of the memory matrix. It asks how the available representation space can be used more effectively under a given memory budget. The authors analyze the redundancy among memory vectors from the perspective of memory-matrix rank. They argue that, compared with only looking at the size of the memory matrix, rank can further reflect the effective dimension of the memory representation space, and it bounds the independent feature directions that the later attention layer can read. The paper then proposes MemTower, which improves downstream task performance through variable-rate continuation pretraining, explicit budget announcement, and rank regularization. In my view, the problem studied here is important and meaningful, and using matrix rank to analyze the capacity of compressed memory is an intuitive and inspiring idea. The experiments show that the proposed method achieves some performance gains on several QA and reasoning tasks.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses an important and practical problem in LLMs about how to make good use of a limited pluggable memory capacity. The authors propose to analyze representation redundancy from the memory-matrix rank perspective. Although analyzing redundancy with rank is a common idea in traditional machine learning, applying it to the memory matrix of an LLM is still intuitive and insightful. MemTower has a reasonable technical motivation, the experiments are fairly comprehensive, and the method achieves meaningful performance improvements on several downstream tasks. In addition to standard benchmarks, the authors also analyze the memory representations through rank interventions and spectral analysis.
Critical weaknesses
The technical contribution of this paper is relatively limited. The theoretical analysis mainly relies on standard properties of linear algebra and does not develop substantially deeper theoretical results. The proposed method mainly combines existing training strategies and representation regularization techniques within the pluggable memory framework, resulting in limited technical novelty. Although the authors provide fairly complete performance comparisons and representation analysis, the relationship among rank, memory budget, and actual task performance is not studied in depth. In particular, a systematic comparison with other representation-diversity regularization methods is missing, and the actual computation cost is not analyzed. The theoretical analysis mainly targets the local linear attention operation, while its effectiveness in a real nonlinear Transformer is supported mostly by experiments. On top of this, the paper does not release implementation code, which to some extent limits the reproducibility of the results. For these reasons, I think the authors need to answer the Questions For Authors properly before the paper can reach the acceptance level.
Questions for authors
- The main theoretical result of the paper shows that the rank of the memory matrix gives an upper bound on both the independent feature directions readable by attention and the dimension of the pre-softmax score patterns. This conclusion is reasonable and meaningful, but the proof mainly relies on standard matrix-rank properties of linear algebra, so the mathematical derivation is fairly direct. Representation redundancy, low-rank structure, and effective representation dimension have also been studied for a long time in machine learning and pattern recognition. Could the authors further explain what new theoretical insight this analysis provides compared with existing work on rank and representation redundancy?
- Compared with covariance regularization, orthogonality constraints, or other spectral regularization methods, what is the advantage of the log-determinant regularization used here? Why are these common representation-diversity regularization methods not used as baselines under the same experimental setup?
- Table 3 shows that, after removing rank regularization, the average accuracy drops by 1.6% at the 4× compression rate and by 7.6% at 16×. This result is interesting because it suggests that efficient use of representation dimensions may matter more at higher compression rates. Could the authors further analyze how rank regularization works under different memory budgets?
- MemTower requires training and running a Memory Tower with up to 8B parameters, and this cost has an important effect on the practical value of the method. In particular, a larger Memory Tower may improve memory representation quality, but its encoding cost can also be higher. Could the authors report the actual encoding and inference cost?
4 comments
Author Response to Reviewer YUpR (part ii)
Q4. Encoding and inference cost.
- We additionally perform detailed analysis regarding MemTower's costs and savings, as in our response to Reviewer eo5Q's Q2. Overall, the savings come from two complementary sources: reusing a memory amortizes its encoding cost, and decoupling representation from generation permits a smaller encoder. For 1k source tokens at x4, a 64-token query, a 128-token answer, and an 8B decoder, we estimate model-weight computation using FLOPs per token.
| Accuracy | Encoding | First use, total | 10 uses, total | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full context, 8B | 85% | - | 19.46 (100%) | 194.56 (100%) |
| MemTower, 8B→8B | 79% | 20.48 | 27.65 (142.1%) | 92.16 (47.4%) |
| MemTower, 1.7B→8B | 76% | 4.35 | 11.52 (59.2%) | 76.03 (39.1%) |
| MemTower, 0.6B→8B | 76% | 1.54 | 8.70 (44.7%) | 73.22 (37.6%) |
-
Reuse recovers the cost of even an 8B encoder on the second use. Each query costs 7.17 versus 19.46 TFLOPs for full context, amortizing the initial encoding cost.
-
Smaller encoders make savings possible from the first use. Our additional 0.6B→8B model achieves 76% accuracy while reducing first-use computation by 55.3% relative to full context under this approximation.
Lastly, regarding contribution and reproducibility:
- Our central contribution is a rank-based perspective on how effectively pluggable memory uses its limited capacity. Adding memory embeddings increases the allocated budget, but redundancy can prevent that increase from exposing more independent directions to attention. We make this distinction concrete through the rank bound, then connect it to prediction through usable rank, measuring the accuracy sustained by retained memory directions. This perspective motivates our design of MemTower, which trains the encoder and decoder to allocate predictive content across the available directions as the memory budget changes. Its improvements in both task accuracy and performance under rank truncation demonstrate the value of connecting memory geometry, decoder utilization, and training design.
Our scripts for model, training and evaluation will be released along with the camera-ready version to ensure reproducibility. Our trained models will be released in multiple settings, including 8B→8B, 1.7B→8B, and 0.6B→8B.
We sincerely thank for the reviewer's suggestions again for clarifying the paper's contribution and its practical value. We will incorporate these additional insights into the final version, and please let us know if there are any remaining questions or concerns.
[1] Garrido et al., RankMe: Assessing the Downstream Performance of Pretrained Self-Supervised Representations by Their Rank, ICML 2023.
[2] Arefin et al., Seq-VCR: Preventing Collapse in Intermediate Transformer Representations for Enhanced Reasoning, ICLR 2025.
[3] Bardes et al., VICReg: Variance-Invariance-Covariance Regularization for Self-Supervised Learning, ICLR 2022.
[4] Yu et al., Learning Diverse and Discriminative Representations via the Principle of Maximal Coding Rate Reduction, NeurIPS 2020.
Thank you for your response. It has addressed most of my concerns. My main remaining concern is still whether the constraint imposed by the rank of the memory matrix remains meaningful in the presence of the complex nonlinear operations in Transformers. Although the authors' current discussion does not fully resolve this question, it provides some theoretical justification and empirical evidence supporting the rank-based analysis. Overall, I recognize the value and completeness of this work, and I will raise my score.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the engagement and positive assessment of our work!
Mathematical-wise, it is indeed difficult to perform theoretical analysis on full nonlinear operations. Rather, in this work we establish a rank-based perspective for understanding how effectively pluggable memory utilizes its limited representational capacity, supported by both tractable theoretical analysis in the linear setting and empirical validation on real-world LLMs. We greatly appreciate the reviewer’s recognition of the value of this perspective and the constructive feedback throughout the discussion, which we believe will make a better version of the final paper.
Author Response to Reviewer YUpR (part i)
We sincerely appreciate the reviewer's thoughtful feedback and for recognizing the practical importance of pluggable memory. We first address the reviewer's specific questions as below.
Q1. New theoretical insight, and applicability to a nonlinear Transformer.
Our analysis gives representation redundancy an operational meaning at the memory interface. Proposition 1 identifies that adding linearly dependent embeddings can increase storage and processing cost without expanding these independent dimensions. This establishes a distinction between the number of memory slots and the capacity they expose to the decoder, motivating us to examine how effectively a given memory budget is used.
This distinction motivates usable rank, which relates retained memory directions to the task accuracy they sustain. RankMe assesses representation quality through a spectral statistic, while Seq-VCR regularizes internal Transformer representations [1,2]. Our intervention instead measures the utilization of each context's compressed memory by a separate decoder. Such paradigm connects the capacity constraint to task utility, which the spectrum alone does not establish.
The paper's "linear interface" analyzes the projections and weighted sums used to read memory. The value bound also holds when softmax determines the weights: the output remains a combination of the fixed value vectors and cannot leave their span. These are local constraints that we model theoretically on memory access; their relevance to the general Transformers is empirically tested by removing memory directions and measuring accuracy with the full nonlinear Transformer unchanged.
Q2. Choice of log-determinant and comparison with diversity regularizers.
We choose the normalized log-determinant because it acts on the spectrum of each context's memory matrix: it is invariant to rotations of the embedding coordinates and does not reward larger embedding magnitudes. Its diminishing returns favor distributing variation across directions, while we also adopt normalization to make the value comparable across memory budgets. These properties suit our variable-budget memory training, where we build on established covariance and coding-rate objectives [3,4].
We agree with the reviewer that covariance regularization and orthogonality constraints offer related ways to encourage representation diversity. However, penalizing off-diagonal covariance alone can still leave variation concentrated in a few dimensions; our normalized log-determinant additionally rewards spreading that variation across directions. Together with its scale and budget normalization, this makes it a natural surrogate for our memory-capacity analysis. Our ablations therefore focus on whether this spectral objective improves memory utilization within the complete training recipe.
Q3. Rank regularization under different memory budgets.
For a 1024-token source context, x4 provides 256 memory slots, whereas x16 provides 64. Redundant directions therefore consume a larger fraction of the smaller budget. Consistent with this, removing regularization causes a 1.6% accuracy drop at x4, increasing to 7.6% at x16.
To compare geometry across budgets, we apply the same spectral diagnostic to the existing x4 runs, obtaining 0.88 without / 0.93 with regularization, compared with the reported 0.80 / 0.95 at x16. Normalization accounts for the different numbers of available directions, which shows a larger increase in spectral spread at x16 (+0.15 vs. +0.05), consistent with the larger accuracy drop when regularization is removed at that rate. Such a pattern supports regularization's role in using a tighter memory budget more effectively.