- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes MemPilot, a framework for organizing and accessing latent memory through independently restorable states and learned sequential navigation. Each source page is encoded into a separate state and paired with a textual semantic key. A navigation policy selects states and decides when to stop, while acquired evidence guides subsequent read instructions. The authors adapt memory readers using page-local evidence supervision and train navigation with same-history counterfactual continuations. Experiments instantiate the framework with Metis and δ-Mem across five benchmarks, supplemented by controls examining memory organization, navigation, semantic keys, state payloads, and query-time efficiency.
Critical strengths
-
Independent state organization addresses a practical limitation of cumulative latent memory. Demonstrating the framework with two backends supports its applicability beyond one memory representation.
-
The experiments include useful controls, particularly matched-storage retention, fixed-route payload interventions, key-only access, and comparisons between static and learned navigation.
-
Training on HotpotQA and evaluating on four additional benchmarks provides meaningful transfer evidence. The measured query-time advantages on the longest histories are also practically relevant.
Critical weaknesses
-
The framework combines established ideas: independently stored latent memories, semantic-key retrieval, evidence-conditioned access, and actor–critic training. Related work already includes latent-memory banks with learned access, such as ElasticMem and M+, and iterative retrieval such as IRCoT. The paper explains implementation differences, but does not sufficiently establish a distinctive algorithmic advance. Comparisons against closer learned-memory systems and a textual navigator with the same keys, policy, and read budget would better demonstrate what specifically requires the proposed latent interface.
-
Semantic keys contain source-derived facts and account for substantial performance. Key-only retrieval reaches 35.50 average score, versus 39.99 for the full system; on HotpotQA, replacing latent payloads with zero states still achieves 60.09 F1 versus 65.77. These controls establish some payload contribution, but leave unclear whether latent storage provides sufficient benefit over compact textual summaries. The raw-source RAG baseline lacks the learned selection and query-conditioned evidence extraction used by MemPilot, so it does not resolve this question.
-
Counterfactual training improves the five-task average over GRPO by 2.11 points, but the comparison simultaneously introduces a learned critic, alternative continuations, and a paired difference loss. Without a standard PPO/critic baseline and separate ablations of these additions, the gain cannot be attributed specifically to counterfactual credit assignment. Multiple training seeds and confidence intervals are also needed, especially since HotpotQA and 2Wiki each use only 200 evaluation questions.
-
The efficiency advantage depends strongly on workload. Table 13 shows lower query latency on BEAM and LongMemEval-S, but higher latency on the other three benchmarks, while excluding offline state construction and key generation. Each Metis page additionally requires approximately 16.8 MB uncompressed or 2.1 MB at rank 64. Reporting construction costs, total persistent storage, and the query volume needed to amortize preprocessing would clarify when the added system complexity is worthwhile.
Questions for authors
How much does candidate coverage limit performance on long histories, and does learned sequential navigation retain its advantage over a matched textual navigator?
11 comments
Response 2/7 to Reviewer jf5p
R2. Keys, states, and raw-text access
W2 & W1: Keys, states, and raw-text access.
R2: The controls show that correct states contribute useful information beyond answer-side keys. Direct text reading provides a stronger quality reference in the current comparison. We first examine keys and state payloads, then give the text-reading configurations and results. The motivation for latent memory is addressed in R1.
The role of keys and key-free organization controls
Table R3.2(a) passes up to 16 BM25-retrieved keys directly to the answerer, without state restoration or sequential READ/STOP. The full system is higher on four tasks. Key-only is higher on LoCoMo. Keys describe pages at write time and can contain answer facts, while readouts respond to the current question. The next control removes semantic keys to test organization directly.
Storage-constrained Grouped remains higher than Cum. on all five tasks without semantic keys (Table R3.2(b)). Both retrieve top-16 candidates using source-page embeddings, share the adapted reader, trained answerer, and navigator, and allow eight accesses. Navigation, read instructions, and answering receive only neutral IDs and actual readouts. Cum. repeatedly reads one state for the full history. Grouped uses at most eight chronological groups and rank-63 compression, with state-plus-mapping storage no larger than Cum.
State contribution under fixed trajectories
Table R3.2(c) keeps questions, page order, read instructions, each variant’s readouts, and the answerer fixed, replacing semantic keys only in the final answer input with neutral IDs. Correct independent states lead on all three tasks, exceeding zero states by 5.04/5.55/8.20 points on LoCoMo/BEAM/LME. Useful state information remains beyond answer-side keys.
Text-reading controls: configuration and results
For the motivation for latent memory and its relation to text, see R1 above. Here, Table R3.2(d) addresses source-text replacement and text-navigation retraining.
Table R3.2(d) shares keys, navigator weights, answerer, and B=8 in original policy + text, substituting source pages and expanding the window from 4K to 32K. Text retraining matches initialization, data, four main trajectories plus one critic-only branch per question, and 900 actor updates. Frozen Qwen3-4B extracts up to 256 evidence tokens/page. RL and access budgets match. Total compute differs.
Retrained text navigation leads on all five tasks. Against original policy + text, it improves 2Wiki/LoCoMo, ties LME, and lowers HotpotQA/BEAM. Text preserves factual detail that latent encoding or readout may lose. Matched latent controls establish organization and access gains; text controls show the current quality tradeoff.
Table R3.2(a). MemPilot versus Key-only.
| Dataset | Metis + MemPilot | Key-only |
|---|---|---|
| HotpotQA | 65.77 | 59.62 |
| 2Wiki | 57.89 | 45.31 |
| LoCoMo | 26.32 | 27.99 |
| BEAM-128K | 23.16 | 21.40 |
| LongMemEval-S | 26.80 | 23.20 |
Table R3.2(b). Key-free organization under a storage cap.
2,840 questions and 5,680 answers. BEAM/LME use Flash evaluation. Some cumulative answers reuse same-configuration outputs.
| Dataset | Cum. | Grouped |
|---|---|---|
| HotpotQA | 25.77 | 45.19 |
| 2Wiki | 33.47 | 38.84 |
| LoCoMo | 8.72 | 10.26 |
| BEAM-128K | 14.17 | 17.53 |
| LongMemEval-S | 8.20 | 11.00 |
Table R3.2(c). Fixed routes/readouts with final-answer keys removed.
| Dataset | Ind. | Cum. | Zero | Foreign |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| LoCoMo | 18.85 | 10.38 | 13.81 | 9.40 |
| BEAM-128K | 16.62 | 8.58 | 11.07 | 9.89 |
| LongMemEval-S | 19.00 | 11.40 | 10.80 | 9.00 |
Ind.: independent states. Cum.: cumulative. Zero: zero states. Foreign: another history. LoCoMo/BEAM/LME: 1,540/400/500 questions.
Table R3.2(d). Latent reading and the two text controls.
| Dataset | MemPilot | Original policy + text reading | Retrained text navigator |
|---|---|---|---|
| HotpotQA | 65.77 | 66.67 | 66.18 |
| 2Wiki | 57.89 | 56.21 | 59.51 |
| LoCoMo | 26.32 | 41.59 | 43.37 |
| BEAM-128K | 23.16 | 25.68 | 23.21 |
| LongMemEval-S | 26.80 | 36.00 | 36.00 |
The MemPilot column uses the original paper’s Table 2 results. The text variants are additional experiments.
Related Revised Sections: §4.5; Appendices C.3, C.5–C.7 (Tables 15–16, 19).
Response 3/7 to Reviewer jf5p
R3. Training components, seeds, and behavior
W3: Training components, seeds, and behavior.
R3: The ablations distinguish the benefit of the paired loss from the overall comparison with PPO. We report those controls first, then the means and sample standard deviations across three training seeds, and finally evidence-gathering behavior from one seed.
Training design and component ablations
Table R3.3(a) compares seed-42 CSUPO with PPO + GAE and two ablations. Without Pair retains alternative branches but removes pairwise return-difference loss. Main-only removes both and trains its critic on main trajectories. PPO uses a standard state-value critic. Alternative branching changes rollout volume.
CSUPO averages 39.99: +1.50 over PPO and +1.07 over Without Pair. Differences precede mean rounding. It exceeds Main-only on all tasks and PPO on all four transfer tasks. PPO leads on HotpotQA. Without Pair retains alternative branches, testing the added return-difference loss.
At seed 42, removing Pair lowers 2Wiki/BEAM by 4.54/2.82, with slight gains elsewhere. CSUPO selects a higher proportion of evidence pages with fewer reads than PPO and both ablations. Per-question proportions are averaged over 200/200/1,527/470 questions (HotpotQA/2Wiki/LoCoMo/LME). LME labels identify supporting sessions. This single-seed diagnostic measures selected-page relevance, not complete coverage, which is not uniformly highest. Three-seed answer scores assess overall quality.
Table R3.3(a). Training methods and ablations (seed 42). The last four rows report evidence-page proportion (%) / mean reads.
| Dataset | CSUPO | w/o Pair | Main-only | PPO + GAE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HotpotQA | 65.77 | 66.27 | 65.31 | 66.89 |
| 2Wiki | 57.89 | 53.35 | 54.42 | 54.39 |
| LoCoMo | 26.32 | 27.41 | 25.00 | 24.96 |
| BEAM-128K | 23.16 | 20.34 | 20.07 | 20.78 |
| LongMemEval-S | 26.80 | 27.20 | 26.00 | 25.40 |
| Five-task average | 39.99 | 38.91 | 38.16 | 38.48 |
| HotpotQA (hit % / mean reads) | 83.83 / 1.75 | 79.41 / 2.38 | 77.48 / 2.31 | 75.21 / 2.08 |
| 2Wiki (hit % / mean reads) | 84.65 / 2.33 | 77.12 / 3.29 | 75.98 / 2.88 | 78.31 / 2.54 |
| LoCoMo (hit % / mean reads) | 43.08 / 1.99 | 40.29 / 2.82 | 35.16 / 2.71 | 35.55 / 2.37 |
| LME-S (hit % / mean reads) | 80.45 / 1.86 | 75.62 / 2.64 | 74.50 / 2.40 | 76.95 / 2.24 |
Related Revised Sections: §4.6 (Table 3); Appendices B.5, C.9 (Tables 23–25; Figures 9–10).
Response 1/7 to Reviewer jf5p
We thank the reviewer for the insightful and useful feedback. These comments have helped us improve the manuscript. We have addressed each weakness and question below and revised the main paper and appendix accordingly, with all changes marked in red.
R1. Contributions and related work
R1: MemPilot addresses how to preserve earlier latent information and obtain sufficient evidence from stored states as history grows. Below we explain why this problem matters, what prior methods leave unresolved, and the evidence for our contribution.
Why latent memory?
Latent memory stores history in learned internal states that LLMs can use, allowing the memory to be optimized for later tasks. Prior studies [10,11] show that these states can be trained to retain useful information, helping models answer questions and generate text from past information at a much lower inference cost. Motivated by these findings, we focus on two challenges in latent memory: cumulative updates can interfere with earlier information, and relevant evidence can be spread across multiple stored states. MemPilot preserves states independently and uses the evidence read from each selected state to decide what to read next and when enough information has been gathered to answer the question. Compared with full-context answering, peak GPU memory decreases from 37.94 to 9.57 GiB on BEAM and from 35.75 to 9.63 GiB on LME (paper Table 13).
A relevant state may provide only part of the answer. The access policy must use that partial evidence to decide what to read next and whether further reading is needed before answering.
What MemPilot adds to latent memory
M+ [3] retrieves and injects tokens from MemoryLLM’s layer-wise pools. MemDefrag [8] traces and reorganizes memory fragments through middle-layer attention. These methods organize access around their internal representations. MemPilot organizes access to independently saved states through the backend’s save, restore, and read operations. This lets the same organization and access design work with different state representations, as demonstrated with Metis [1] and δ-Mem [2]. Each backend still uses its own trained components.
ElasticMem [4] selects memories and latent capacity before generation. MemPilot makes further access decisions after reading evidence from a selected state: it can choose another state, revise the next read instruction, or stop. IRCoT [5] and Search-R1 [9] already use intermediate results for iterative text retrieval. MemPilot applies evidence-driven access to separately preserved neural states, where the system must restore a state and read out useful evidence before choosing its next action. Table R3.1 summarizes these differences.
Contribution and current evidence
CSUPO supervises return differences between legal access actions from the same observed history, including different READ choices and READ versus STOP. Comparing actions at the same starting history trains the action-value critic to estimate which next choice has greater expected return. This gives the navigator feedback on both where to read and whether another read is worthwhile, beyond the final score of a completed answer.
With adaptation and access components matched, independent-state organization improves the five-task average over cumulative memory by 5.29 points (paper Appendix C.5). Across three seeds, CSUPO improves the five-task mean over PPO + GAE by 1.95 points and over Without Pair by 1.57 points, with a higher macro-average in each seed (Table R3.3(b-1)). R2 details key-free organization controls and fixed-route state interventions. R3 details ablations of the training components, results across three seeds, and reading behavior.
Table R3.1. Related-work focus and specific distinctions of MemPilot.
Related Revised Sections: §§1–3, 5; Appendices C.7, C.11.