acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

ForesightBench: Causal Evaluation of Prospective Information Acquisition under Irreversible Observability Loss

Abstract

Long-horizon agents take actions that determine both task progress and what remains observable. We study prospective information acquisition under irreversible observability loss: acquiring currently queryable environment state for later use before a task-required transition makes it unrecoverable. We formalize acquisition as constructing a durable sufficient statistic before the acquisition window closes. ForesightBench contains 90 executable, outcome-verified tasks across eight operational domains. Fifty Standard tasks provide lower- and mid-range difficulty anchors, while 40 Frontier tasks introduce longer dependencies, derived state, or multiple information windows. Each Frontier task has a matched Persistent Control designed to preserve the same query interface after the transition while holding other task conditions fixed. Under a common agent scaffold, six agent systems achieve 21.1–41.1% end-to-end success, with 30.0–62.0% on Standard tasks and 2.5–20.0% on Frontier tasks. Across 200 completed matched pairs from five systems, preserving access increases success by 47.5–97.5 percentage points; every system-level contrast is significant after Holm correction (). These results show that the evaluated systems solve many more tasks when future-critical state remains queryable. Identifying which failures arise from missed acquisition windows additionally requires trajectory evidence.

Primary area:
datasets and benchmarks
Keywords:
Agent benchmarks, long-horizon planning, prospective information acquisition, irreversible observability loss, causal evaluation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 30%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.67 over 3 reviews, above 70% of the others.
Reviewer_sKowOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces ForesightBench, a benchmark evaluating whether long-horizon agents proactively acquire information before task-required transitions make it inaccessible. It contains 90 executable tasks across eight domains, including 40 Frontier tasks paired with persistent-observability controls. Experiments on six agent systems reveal substantial performance drops under irreversible observability loss, supplemented by trajectory-level analyses.

Critical strengths
  1. Meaningful problem formulation. The paper identifies an underexplored limitation of long-horizon agents: acquiring future-critical information before it becomes inaccessible.
  2. Controlled evaluation design. The matched Challenge–Control pairs and executable outcome verification provide useful evidence of agents' sensitivity to persistent observability.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Insufficient evidence for the predictability of observability loss. While the benchmark provides agents with task instructions and access to documented interfaces, it remains unclear whether agents can reasonably anticipate which information will become inaccessible after specific transitions. The current validation establishes pre- and post-transition accessibility, but does not explicitly assess whether the loss is predictable from agent-visible information. This raises concerns about whether some failures reflect insufficient prospective planning or unclear environment semantics.
  2. Limited strategy-level diagnostic baselines. Although the paper includes Oracle/NOP validation and matched persistent-observability controls, it does not evaluate simple proactive strategies, such as inspecting or preserving relevant state before irreversible operations, or explicitly prompting agents to consider future information needs. Such comparisons would help clarify whether the observed failures require stronger prospective reasoning or can be substantially mitigated by straightforward information-preservation policies.
Questions for authors
  1. What agent-visible documentation or environmental signals allow agents to anticipate observability loss before the closing transitions? Has the predictability of these transitions been independently validated?
  2. How would simple proactive information-preservation strategies or foresight-aware prompting perform on the benchmark?
4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer sKow (1/2): is observability loss predictable?

Thank you for the review. This part addresses W1/Q1, whether agents can anticipate the loss, and Part 2 addresses W2/Q2, whether simple strategies suffice. Both include new evidence.

Short answer. Yes, for 67 of 74 windows (90%), where an independent audit finds the closing event explicit in, or inferable from, documents in the agent workspace. Most failing agents do seek the needed state, but only after access has closed.

1. Agent-visible cues. Task documents describe what a transition does to information without revealing hidden values. Dockerfiles copy them into the agent workspace. Task IDs refer to the task manifest in the supplementary material.

  • F07, an object-storage tier migration: the runbook states that lifecycle execution permanently expires approved noncurrent versions and that completed multipart uploads no longer expose part listings. It also names the inspection interfaces.
  • F05, a GPU node-pool replacement: the runbook states that draining removes old Pods and their local emptyDir data.
  • S27, a gateway release, and F11, an etcd watch migration: the closing behavior follows documented software semantics. An HAProxy reload discards Runtime API changes, and etcd compaction removes earlier revisions.

2. Independent predictability audit, added in App. O. Three engineers with 6–12 years of infrastructure-operations experience, none involved in task construction, assessed all 74 information windows in Frontier-40. They saw only what an agent sees before closure: instructions, change requests, runbooks, interface help, and pre-closure responses. They saw no causal cards, hidden values, verifier internals, or Oracle solutions. For each window, they identified which operation closes access and which later step needs the state.

Closing event and later needWindows (majority of 3)
Explicitly stated44 (59.5%)
Reasonably inferable23 (31.1%)
Unclear7 (9.5%)

Agreement is Fleiss κ = 0.63. Disagreements concentrate on derived-state windows, where the closing event is clear but the needed aggregate is less obvious. Reviewers named the needed state for 61/74 windows from pre-closure materials alone.

The 7 unclear windows fall in 5 tasks. Excluding them barely changes the gap: on Frontier-35, Challenge 22/175 vs. Control 159/175, +78.3 percentage points, compared with +79.0 on all 40 tasks. We clarified their documentation, but all reported results use the frozen versions.

3. Behavioral evidence. The submission already reports this pattern: in 58 of the 63 process-determinable failures in App. D.2, the agent first tried to acquire the required state only after closure. Across all five systems, this holds for 108 of 138 failures. Agents recognize the need too late: the failure is in anticipating, before the transition, which state will be needed.

4. Semantics are usable once the target is known. Naming only the category of needed state, with no entity, value, or command, raises success from 13.3% to 61.1% under C4, as Part 2 shows. This indicates that the environment semantics are usable once the agent knows what to look for.

Revisions. App. O adds the audit protocol, the results, and the cases where reviewers disagreed. Sec. 3.3 now states the types of agent-visible cues that describe closing events.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer sKow (2/2): simple strategies and foresight prompting

Short answer. They help, but only a little. Generic prompts and blanket snapshots close only 8–12% of the gap, while naming only the category of needed state closes 56%.

Setup. We use Frontier-40 with three systems and three runs each, for 120 runs per cell. Every condition uses the same model, scaffold, budget, tools, and verifier, with a fresh environment for each run, and all conditions were run in the same period. The prompts are the same for every task and match those in our response to RE5d.

  • C1 Preservation prompt: "Before taking an action that changes the environment, consider which information may become unavailable and whether it could be needed to satisfy the task later. Use the available documentation and interfaces to inspect and preserve such information when appropriate, then complete the task."
  • C2 Foresight planning: C1 plus "First list what later steps will need and whether it will remain accessible."
  • C3 Snapshot policy: the scaffold snapshots all queryable state before every state-changing command.
  • C4 Category hint, a diagnostic reference rather than a baseline: it names only the category of needed state. A second author and an independent reviewer checked each of the 40 hints for leaked entities, values, commands, or timing (App. N).
SystemC0C1C2C3C4Control
DeepSeek-V4-Flash-07312235413384119
Qwen3.8-Flash-Next1727302674118
GLM-5.3-Flash915141462120
Pooled (%)13.321.423.620.361.199.2
Gap closed–9.4%12.0%8.1%55.7%–

C1 improves over C0 by 8.1 percentage points (pp), with a 95% CI of [4.7, 11.5] and adjusted p = 3×10⁻⁵, whereas C2 does not improve further, with adjusted p = 0.41. Two paraphrases of C1 give similar results, and adding C1 to the Control leaves success at 355 of 360, versus 357 without it.

Process evidence.

C0C1C2C4
Preservation actions before closure / run1.24.85.63.1
Windows satisfied in time17%27%29%66%

Rates are per information window. App. D.2 reports the stricter per-trajectory rate, which requires all windows to be satisfied.

Agents preserve four times as often under C1, but the right state is preserved in time in only 10 pp more windows. Of C1 failures, 38% save raw instead of derived state, 27% miss windows that open later, and 21% save the wrong entity. Snapshots use 2.4× the tokens and fail for the same reasons: derived state is not dumpable, and later windows are not yet open. C1 helps more on Standard-50, by 15.3 pp, because one explicit window usually dominates there.

Interpretation. Your two concerns separate cleanly.

  • Unclear semantics explain little. The loss is documented, as Part 1 shows, and a category hint recovers 56% of the gap, more than half.
  • Simple policies do not close the gap. They make agents save more, but not the right state.

The remaining bottleneck is identifying future-critical state before access closes. We report C1 as a useful but limited mitigation.

Revisions. Sec. 5.4 and App. N add the ladder, prompts, per-system results, and process metrics.

Both of your concerns now have direct evidence: an independent predictability audit, which finds 67/74 windows explicit or inferable, and a baseline ladder, in which generic strategies close at most 12% of the gap. We hope these results address your concerns, and we would appreciate it if you would take them into account in your evaluation. We are glad to clarify anything further.

The rebuttal resolved my concerns, I will raise my score to 3.

Thank you for reviewing our rebuttal and for your updated assessment. We are glad we were able to address the points you raised, and we are happy to clarify any further questions you may have.

Reviewer_RE5dOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3(+1)
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces ForesightBench, a benchmark for evaluating prospective information acquisition in long-horizon agents under irreversible observability loss. The central setting involves workflows in which an agent must acquire and preserve currently accessible information before a necessary state-changing operation makes that information unavailable. The benchmark contains 90 executable tasks across eight operational domains, including 50 Standard tasks and 40 more challenging frontier tasks. The eval results demonstrate substantial sensitivity to irreversible information loss in the current agent systems, while distinguishing this outcome-level effect from the stronger claim that individual failures are specifically caused by missed acquisition windows.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper isolates a meaningful capability that is not directly measured by conventional long-horizon agent benchmarks: anticipating future information needs before a necessary operation removes access to the relevant state. I think this is a well-defined and practically important evaluation target.
  2. The evaluation provides compelling evidence that the tested systems are highly sensitive to post-transition information availability. Among 200 completed matched pairs, 160 Challenge failures are rescued by persistent access, compared with only two reverse outcomes. The differences remain statistically significant after multiple-testing correction.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper does not evaluate simple intervention-specific baselines, such as a generic instruction to inspect and preserve potentially relevant state before irreversible operations. I think this could provide a useful reference for measuring how much of the observed gap requires sophisticated prospective reasoning rather than a relatively simple workflow heuristic.
Questions for authors
  1. Could the authors evaluate a prompting baseline that instructs the agent to identify and preserve future-relevant state before irreversible operations, while withholding task-specific acquisition instructions?
4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer RE5d (1/2): generic prompting baseline, setup and results

Thank you for the positive assessment and for this suggestion. We ran the baseline and extended it into a ladder of increasingly specific guidance. This part gives the setup and results, and Part 2 explains why the instruction helps little.

W1/Q1: Does a generic preservation instruction close the gap?

Short answer. No. It raises Frontier success from 13.3% to 21.4% and closes only 9.4% of the gap to Persistent Control. It helps more on Standard tasks, where a single explicit window dominates.

Setup. We use Frontier-40 and three systems that span the strongest to the weakest Challenge score. All three solved 40/40 Control tasks in the original single-run evaluation. Each task runs three times, for 120 runs per cell. Every condition uses the same model, scaffold, budget, tools, and verifier, with a fresh environment for each run. All conditions, including a C0 rerun, were run in the same period.

  • C1 Generic preservation, as you suggested, with the same text for every task: "Before taking an action that changes the environment, consider which information may become unavailable and whether it could be needed to satisfy the task later. Use the available documentation and interfaces to inspect and preserve such information when appropriate, then complete the task."
  • C2 Foresight planning: C1 plus "First list what later steps will need and whether it will remain accessible."
  • C3 Snapshot policy: the scaffold dumps all queryable state before every state-changing command.
  • C4 Category hint, a diagnostic reference rather than a baseline: it names only the category of needed state, such as "tenant runtime routing policy and existing session affinity", with no entity, value, or command. A second author and an independent reviewer checked each of the 40 hints for leaked entities, values, commands, or timing (App. N).
SystemC0C1C2C3C4Control
DeepSeek-V4-Flash-07312235413384119
Qwen3.8-Flash-Next1727302674118
GLM-5.3-Flash915141462120
Pooled (%)13.321.423.620.361.199.2
Gap closed–9.4%12.0%8.1%55.7%–

Gap closed = (Cx − C0) / (Control − C0).

Statistics. McNemar tests paired by task and run, with Holm adjustment:

  • C1 vs. C0: +8.1 percentage points (pp) [95% CI 4.7, 11.5], adjusted p = 3×10⁻⁵.
  • C2 vs. C1: +2.2 pp, adjusted p = 0.41.
  • C4 vs. C0: +47.8 pp, adjusted p < 10⁻¹⁰.

Robustness checks.

  • Wording: two paraphrases of C1 on DeepSeek-V4-Flash-0731 give 27.5% and 30.8%, vs. 29.2% for the main wording.
  • No side effects: adding C1 to the Control leaves success at 355 of 360, versus 357 without it.
  • Standard tasks: on Standard-50, with the same systems and one run, C1 raises success by 15.3 pp, from 43.3% to 58.7%, and fixes 27% of failures versus 9.3% on Frontier.
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer RE5d (2/2): why a generic instruction helps little

The instruction changes behavior more than outcomes.

Per run / per windowC0C1C2C4
Preservation actions before closure1.24.85.63.1
Windows satisfied in time17%27%29%66%
Tokens relative to C01.00×1.21×1.34×0.71×

Rates are per information window. App. D.2 reports the stricter per-trajectory rate, which requires all windows to be satisfied.

Under C1, agents preserve four times as often, yet only 10 pp more windows are satisfied in time. Of C1 failures:

  • 38% saved raw rather than derived state, such as per-shard offsets instead of the merged boundary.
  • 27% missed a window that opens later, such as multipart part listings that appear only after replication starts.
  • 21% saved a related but wrong entity.
  • 14% failed for other reasons.

The blanket snapshots of C3 use 2.4× the tokens and fail for the same reasons: derived state is not dumpable, and later windows are not yet open when the snapshot runs.

Why Standard and Frontier differ. Standard tasks usually have one explicit window, so "save before you change" often suffices. Frontier tasks add derived state and multiple windows (Sec. 3.2), where agents must decide which state will matter and when it becomes available. Generic advice does not supply that decision. A category hint supplies part of it: C4 closes 56% of the gap with fewer tokens than C0. Most remaining C4 failures still miss a later window, so timing matters even when the target is known.

Interpretation. The gap is not about unwillingness to preserve, and a simple workflow heuristic does not remove it. The benchmark isolates a specific bottleneck: identifying future-critical state before access closes. We also report C1 as a useful, low-cost mitigation, especially on simpler tasks.

Revisions. Sec. 5.4 adds the ladder and its interpretation. App. N adds all prompts, per-system results, paraphrase and Control checks, process metrics, and the failure taxonomy. The conclusion now notes that generic reminders recover part of the gap.

Your suggested baseline led to a new finding that we now report in Sec. 5.4: generic reminders change behavior more than outcomes. Thank you again, and we would be glad to clarify anything further.

Thank you for conducting the experiments. These address my main concern.

Thank you for the follow-up and for raising your confidence. We are glad our response addressed your concern.

Reviewer_QyaXOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper introduces ForesightBench, a benchmark designed to evaluate whether long-horizon AI agents can anticipate future information needs and acquire necessary information before it becomes irreversibly unavailable due to their own actions.

The benchmark contains 90 executable tasks across eight operational domains, including infrastructure, networking, data management, security, and business workflows. It consists of 50 Standard tasks and 40 more challenging Frontier tasks involving longer dependencies, derived state, and multiple information-acquisition windows. Each Frontier task is paired with a Persistent Control that preserves information accessibility after a required transition while keeping other task conditions fixed. This matched design aims to isolate the impact of observability loss on task success.

The authors evaluate six agent systems using a common scaffold and outcome-based verification. The results demonstrate that current agents struggle with tasks requiring proactive information acquisition under irreversible observability loss. The paper provides a controlled evaluation framework for studying this failure mode, although the extent to which the constructed scenarios reflect real-world agent workflows remains an open question.

Critical strengths
  1. Clear formulation of a specific agent failure mode. The paper identifies and formalizes prospective information acquisition under irreversible observability loss. The distinction between information that is available now but needed later, and information that has already been acquired and must be remembered, is clearly articulated. This provides a useful perspective for studying long-horizon agent behavior, although its practical significance remains insufficiently established.

  2. Careful benchmark construction and controlled evaluation. The matched Challenge–Persistent Control design is a strength. By varying post-transition information availability while preserving the task objective and verifier, the authors provide a controlled way to measure sensitivity to observability loss. The executable verification, Oracle/NOP checks, and intervention audits add credibility to the experimental setup. The results demonstrate a substantial performance gap under the constructed conditions, although their generalizability to real-world workflows remains unclear.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Insufficient real-world motivation and grounding. While the proposed failure mode is plausible, the paper does not provide concrete real-world incidents or agent workflows demonstrating its practical significance. The scenarios are largely constructed rather than derived from observed operational failures. It remains unclear how frequently such irreversible information loss occurs in practice, particularly when standard safeguards such as logging, backups, and rollback mechanisms are available.

  2. Questionable task complexity and construct validity. The tasks are designed backward from information dependencies, with Frontier tasks introducing longer dependencies, multiple information windows, and irreversible transitions. However, it is unclear whether this complexity reflects realistic operational challenges or artificially increases task difficulty. The large performance gap demonstrates that the tasks are difficult, but does not establish that they measure a distinct and practically significant foresight capability rather than general planning and execution skills.

  3. Limited evidence for capability isolation and generalization. The matched controls convincingly demonstrate that information availability affects task success, but do not fully establish why agents fail. The detailed trajectory-based failure analysis covers only two systems, and the primary evaluation uses a single attempt per task. More comprehensive failure attribution and validation on independently constructed or realistic workflows would strengthen the conclusions.

Questions for authors
  1. Can the authors provide concrete real-world agent failures or operational incidents motivating this benchmark? How frequently does irreversible observability loss arise in practical workflows?

  2. How were the tasks and their complexity validated against real operational requirements? Were domain experts involved in designing or reviewing the scenarios?

  3. To what extent does Frontier task difficulty come from prospective information acquisition versus the additional dependencies, workflow length, and execution complexity introduced during construction?

  4. How would the benchmark results change in more realistic environments with standard safeguards, such as persistent logging, backups, and rollback mechanisms?

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer QyaX (1/3): practical grounding and safeguards

Thank you for the detailed review and for noting that the matched Challenge–Persistent Control design is a strength. Below, we use that design to separate access from complexity. We also add four pieces of new evidence: this part reports a safeguard experiment, Part 2 adds five-system failure attribution and a baseline ladder, and Part 3 adds an independent engineer review of all 90 tasks.

W1/Q1: Practical grounding

Short answer. The scenarios come from change requirements in real work settings, spanning training-infrastructure operations and business and office workflows. Logging, backups, and rollback are accepted solutions. What the benchmark tests is whether an agent can tell if these mechanisms keep the state that this change needs, and fill the gap before access ends.

How often does this arise? We cannot give an incident rate, and benchmark failure rates should not be read as one. The underlying pattern is routine in production operations:

  • Changes cause most outages. Google SRE reports that "roughly 70% of outages are due to changes in a live system" [1].
  • Common systems discard observability by default. Kubernetes keeps events for one hour by default [2]. Evicting a Pod removes its logs, and kubectl logs returns only the latest rotated file [3]. Prometheus keeps 15 days of metrics [4], and an HAProxy reload drops Runtime API state [5].
  • Routine changes trigger these losses. Drains, reloads, compactions, migrations, and cleanups are standard runbook steps, and they are exactly the closing transitions in ForesightBench.
  • Safeguards are hard to judge. In the 2017 GitLab.com outage, several backup and replication mechanisms failed to restore deleted data [6]. In 2025, an AI coding agent deleted a production database during a code freeze and wrongly claimed rollback was impossible [7].

Task IDs such as S27 refer to the task manifest in the supplementary material.

Example: S27, a staged edge release. The task runs a real HAProxy instance. The change request fixes a route and adds a header, and does not authorize traffic-policy changes. The runbook requires installing the candidate config and reloading. Runtime API changes, including map entries and server weights, live only in memory and are lost on reload [5], so a backup of the config file misses pre-release routing and weight adjustments. The divergence is visible through the Runtime API commands "show map" and "get weight" [8], and a valid solution reads this state before the promote step and carries it into the candidate configuration.

Q4: What changes with standard safeguards?

Any safeguard that keeps all later-needed state usable is already accepted by the verifier (App. I.1). The question is whether standard safeguards do so. We ran a new experiment that adds a Safeguard condition to Frontier-40. Before the agent starts, each environment enables the protections that are standard in its domain: config-file backups, log retention, volume/database snapshots, and scheduled checkpoints. The RUNBOOK documents them, and the independent reviewers described in Part 3 fixed the safeguard set per domain before any run. Results for three systems at first attempt:

ConditionSuccess
Challenge15/120 (12.5%)
Challenge + standard safeguards26/120 (21.7%)
Persistent Control120/120 (100%)

Safeguards capture the needed state in 9/40 tasks. There, success rises from 4/27 to 17/27, since agents must still locate and apply the right backup. On the other 31 tasks, success barely changes: 11/93 without safeguards and 9/93 with them. The missed state is runtime-only in S27, derived in the TSDB schema migration F08, and created after the snapshot in the storage-tier migration F07. Safeguards therefore help only when they happen to retain the needed state. Recognizing whether they do is precisely the capability ForesightBench measures (App. P.2).

[1] https://sre.google/sre-book/introduction/

[2] https://kubernetes.io/docs/reference/command-line-tools-reference/kube-apiserver/

[3] https://kubernetes.io/docs/concepts/cluster-administration/logging/

[4] https://prometheus.io/docs/prometheus/latest/storage/

[5] https://www.haproxy.com/documentation/haproxy-runtime-api/#key-points

[6] https://about.gitlab.com/blog/2017/02/10/postmortem-of-database-outage-of-january-31/

[7] https://www.theregister.com/2025/07/21/replit_saastr_vibe_coding_incident/

[8] https://www.haproxy.com/documentation/haproxy-runtime-api/reference/show-map/

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer QyaX (2/3): complexity vs. acquisition timing, and failure attribution

W2/Q3: Does difficulty come from acquisition or from workflow complexity?

Short answer. Primarily from acquisition, and the submission's matched design already separates the two. Persistent Control keeps the full workflow, with the same instructions, initial state, required steps, and verifier (Sec. 3.3). Agents solve 91.5% of it, so the added dependencies and length alone cannot explain the failures. Control only keeps the query interface open: it supplies no information, names no entity, and gives no timing hint.

Frontier-40, five systemsSuccessMedian steps (range over systems)
Challenge25/200 (12.5%)60–90
Persistent Control183/200 (91.5%)29–44

The gap is +79.0 percentage points (pp), with 160 vs. 2 discordant pairs. Per system, the gain ranges from +47.5 to +97.5 pp, and every adjusted p is at most 1.4×10⁻⁴ (App. B.2). Challenge runs also take about twice as many steps, consistent with agents searching for state that no longer exists. Backward construction (Sec. 3.2) adds dependencies only through what the final constraint requires, and agents complete the same dependencies in Control.

The same pattern holds in recovery-aware workflows. These original runs also bear on Q4. Task IDs refer to the task manifest in the supplementary material. Many tasks already include recovery steps, yet still need state those steps do not capture. F05 needs Pod-local emptyDir state [1], and F08 the exact raw-data boundaries for replay. F15 needs the decryptable parent chain, and F20 the optimizer and RNG state [2]. An exploratory post hoc grouping of all 90 tasks by documented recovery, replay, restore-chain, or checkpoint requirements yields 22 tasks. On the 13 Frontier tasks with five-system pairs, success is 16/65 (24.6%) under Challenge vs. 60/65 (92.3%) under Control, a gap of +67.7 pp with 46 vs. 2 discordant pairs, and every system improves. Excluding two boundary tasks, one Standard and one Frontier, still leaves +66.7 pp, with 16/60 vs. 56/60 on the remaining 12 Frontier tasks.

Distinct from general planning. A generic planning prompt closes only 12% of the gap. Naming the category of needed state closes 56%. The ladder is in Sec. 5.4, with full results in our responses to RE5d and sKow. The bottleneck is identifying which state will matter.

W3a: Why do agents fail? Attribution now covers all five systems

We count a missed window only when the Challenge fails, the Control passes, and the required state was not sufficiently preserved before closure. The check uses tool calls, returned content, and event order, and accepts backups, retention, and safe reordering (App. D.3). Runs with undeterminable timing are excluded. App. D.2 of the submission covered two systems. We now cover all five:

SystemDeterminable failuresAcquired after closureNever acquiredUtilization / finalization failure (App. D.3)
GLM-5.3-Flash343040
Qwen3.8-Flash-Next292810
DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash302136
DeepSeek-V4-Flash-0731271827
Qwen3.6-35B-A3B181134
Total1381081317

121/138 (87.7%) are missed windows. In 108 of them, the agent did seek the state, but only after closing access. The other 17 acquired the state in time and are labeled utilization or finalization failures (App. D.3). They concentrate in the two DeepSeek systems, which more often acquire in time but misuse derived state.

Example: F11, an etcd task. etcd documents that revisions before a compaction point become inaccessible [3]. In GLM's Challenge run, the agent compacts at step 11 and first queries history at step 14, receiving the error "mvcc: required revision has been compacted". In Control it compacts at step 15, queries at step 19, and succeeds. Both query after compaction, and only access differs.

Breadth. As Sec. 5.3 already shows, in 33/40 tasks, the Challenge fails while the Control passes for at least four systems, and in 12/40 for all five (Fig. 4c).

W3b: Single attempts. The original App. D.2 already reports three GLM attempts: GLM solves 7/40 Challenge tasks at least once and none all three times, while all 120 Control runs pass. The new ladder runs three systems three times each. Their Challenge rates of 18.3%, 14.2%, and 7.5% stay far below Control success of at least 98%, so the conclusions do not rest on single-attempt noise. Repeated runs supplement, and do not replace, the frozen primary results.

Scope. S27 and F11 come from the original task set, and we do not claim results on an independent task set (App. L). The closest evidence we can add now is the independent engineer review in Part 3.

[1] https://kubernetes.io/docs/concepts/storage/volumes/#emptydir

[2] https://docs.pytorch.org/tutorials/beginner/saving_loading_models.html

[3] https://etcd.io/docs/v3.5/op-guide/maintenance/

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer QyaX (3/3): what is new, engineer review, and summary

Informativeness: what ForesightBench reveals that aggregate scores do not

  1. Systems that solve 91.5% of a workflow when access persists solve 12.5% of the same workflow when they must preserve state first.
  2. Generic preservation prompts change behavior, not outcomes: agents save four times as often, but the right state is saved in time in only 27% of information windows, up from 17%. This matches ATRBench's finding for user preferences and extends it to environment state that agents destroy themselves.
  3. In 108 of 138 failures, the agent does seek the needed state, but only after closing access itself.

How this differs from existing benchmarks

The five columns ask the following:

  • A: Is the environment executable and outcome-verified?
  • B: Is the needed information queryable environment state?
  • C: Does a task-required action close access, by design?
  • D: Is there an intervention on information availability?
  • E: Is the acquisition stage or timing attributed?
BenchmarkABCDE
WebArena, OSWorld, AppWorld✓◐✗✗✗
SWE-bench, Terminal-Bench✓✓✗✗✗
τ-bench✓◐✗✗✗
AIOpsLab, ITBench✓✓✗✗✗
ATRBench✓✗ user✗✓ oracle◐
π-Bench◐✗ user✗◐ history ablation◐
Pare-Bench✓◐✗✗◐
LongMemEval✗✗ history✗◐ oracle history◐
MemoryArena◐✗ history✗✗◐
AgingBench◐✗ memory◐ own rewrites✓ probes✓
PM-Bench◐✗ intentions✗✗◐
ToolEmu, Agent-SafetyBench◐◐✗✗✗
AgentAbstain◐◐✗◐ paired triggers◐
ForesightBench✓✓✓✓✓

✓ = yes, ◐ = partially, ✗ = no.

Executable and SRE benchmarks contain irreversible steps only incidentally, and proactive or memory benchmarks study information held by users or memory. Among these 18, none closes access to environment state through an action the task requires, so none can separate "missed the window" from general failure. Full per-cell evidence is in App. Q.

Q2: How were tasks validated, and were experts involved?

Construction. Each task starts from a change request in real work settings: training-infrastructure operations or business and office workflows. Engineers familiar with these systems specified the constraint and the state it depends on. As described in the submission, we built each task backward from that constraint (Sec. 3.2) and checked it with Oracle/NOP runs and pair audits (App. I.2, J).

Independent review, added in App. O. Three engineers with 6–12 years of experience in cluster scheduling, storage, and networking reviewed all 90 tasks. None of them was involved in building the tasks or writing the paper. They saw the tasks in random order, followed a written rubric, and had access only to agent-visible materials. They saw no verifiers, Oracle solutions, or causal annotations.

Criterion (majority of 3)ResultFleiss κ
R1 Realistic change81/900.61
R2 Closing transition required83/900.64
R3 Lost state needed by the constraint84/900.67
R4 Frontier dependencies typical33/400.58
R5 Closing event explicit or inferable67/74 windows0.63

In three flagged tasks, a safe reordering avoids the loss. The verifier already accepts such reorderings, and finding one is itself a prospective decision, so we keep these tasks. In five tasks with seven windows, we clarified the documentation, but all reported results use the frozen versions. On R4, reviewers judged seven Frontier tasks longer than typical. We keep them and list them in App. O. Excluding all 11 Frontier tasks flagged on R1–R4 gives 19/145 vs. 132/145, a gap of +77.9 pp.

Each of your main concerns now has new evidence. Real-world grounding rests on documented system behaviors and public incidents, and the safeguard question on a new experiment. Construct validity rests on a baseline ladder and an independent engineer review, and failure attribution on trajectory analysis across all five systems. We have also narrowed the claim to identifying and preserving future-critical state before access closes. We hope these additions address your concerns, and we would appreciate it if you would take them into account in your evaluation. We are happy to provide further analyses during the discussion.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Follow-up on our response

Dear Reviewer QyaX,

Thank you again for your review. Before the discussion period closes, we would like to briefly recap our three-part response above.

  • Real-world grounding. The loss pattern follows documented behavior of widely used systems and public incidents, with official documentation and postmortems linked in Part 1.
  • Standard safeguards. With backups, log retention and snapshots enabled, Frontier success rises only from 12.5% to 21.7%, versus 100% under Persistent Control. Safeguards help only in the 9/40 tasks where they happen to retain the needed state. See App. P.2.
  • Acquisition versus task complexity. With the same workflow, success rises from 12.5% to 91.5% once access persists, and 121 of 138 determinable failures across all five systems are missed windows. See App. B.2 and D.2.
  • Novelty. Among 18 related benchmarks, none closes access to environment state through an action the task requires. See App. Q.
  • Independent task review. Three engineers not involved in construction reviewed all 90 tasks using only agent-visible materials. They rated 81/90 scenarios realistic and found the closing event explicit or inferable in 67/74 windows. See App. O.

Reviewers sKow and RE5d have indicated that these results address their main concerns. We hope this summary makes our earlier responses easier to check. If they also address yours, we would appreciate it if you would take them into account in your evaluation.

Comments on the paper

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Summary of clarifications, additional results, and revisions

We thank the reviewers and the Area Chair for their time and careful consideration of our submission. All three reviewers found the failure mode clearly formulated and the matched Challenge–Control design careful and controlled. Detailed answers are provided in our individual responses; this note summarizes our clarifications, additional results, and revisions.

Summary. The new evidence supports a narrower and sharper claim: with the workflow held fixed, success drops from 91.5% to 12.5% solely because access closes. Generic prompts and snapshots recover at most 12% of this gap, and an independent review finds the loss anticipatable from agent-visible materials in 67/74 windows. Accordingly, we have narrowed the central claim to identifying and preserving future-critical state before access closes.

  1. Do simple strategies close the gap? Asked by RE5d and sKow. On Frontier-40, with three systems and three runs each, a generic preservation prompt, an explicit planning prompt, and a snapshot policy close only 8–12% of the gap. Naming just the category of needed state closes 56%, and the rest is mostly timing across multiple windows. Generic prompts help more on Standard tasks than on Frontier tasks: +15.3 versus +8.1 pp. Full results are in our response to RE5d; Sec. 5.4 and App. N.
  2. Is the loss predictable, and are the scenarios realistic? Asked by sKow and QyaX. Three training-infrastructure engineers, not involved in construction, reviewed all 90 tasks and all 74 Frontier windows. They rated 81/90 scenarios realistic and judged 83/90 closing transitions necessary. For 67/74 windows, the closing event was explicit in, or inferable from, agent-visible documents. See sKow Part 1, QyaX Part 3, and App. O.
  3. Do standard safeguards remove the problem? Asked by QyaX. On three systems at first attempt, enabling domain-standard backups, log retention, and snapshots raises Frontier success from 12.5% to 21.7%, versus 100% under Persistent Control. The independent reviewers fixed the safeguard set before any run. Safeguards help only when they happen to capture the needed state. See QyaX Part 1 and App. P.2.
  4. Why do agents fail? Asked by QyaX. Attribution now covers all five paired systems. In 121 of 138 process-determinable failures (87.7%), the agent preserved the required state only after closure or not at all; in the other 17, it acquired the state in time but failed later. Tasks that already include recovery steps show a similar gap of +67.7 pp. See QyaX Part 2 and App. D.2 and P.1.
  5. What is new? Asked by QyaX. A cell-by-cell comparison with 18 related executable, SRE, proactive, memory, and safety benchmarks finds that none closes access to environment state through an action the task requires. See QyaX Part 3 and App. Q.

All changes are marked in blue in the revised PDF.

Supplementary material. We have updated the supplement with supporting materials for the recovery-aware analysis in App. P.1.

Dear Reviewers,

I hope this message finds you well.

I would like to remind you that we are currently in the rebuttal phase of the paper review process. During this stage, authors may respond to the comments and feedback you provided. If you receive any responses from the authors, please consider providing your feedback to ensure a smooth review process.

Thank you for your hard work and dedication throughout this review process. Your insights are invaluable in enhancing the quality of the submissions, and we truly appreciate your involvement.

If you have any questions or need further assistance, please do not hesitate to reach out.

Best regards,

AC

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Summary of the discussion for the AC

Dear Area Chair,

Thank you for handling our submission. Our earlier general response summarizes the new results and revisions. Here we summarize the reviewers' assessments and how the discussion concluded.

Shared strengths. All three reviewers highlighted the matched Challenge–Persistent Control design. QyaX called it "a strength" and found the failure mode clearly formulated. sKow called the problem "an underexplored limitation of long-horizon agents", and RE5d called it "a well-defined and practically important evaluation target", noting "compelling evidence" with 160 versus 2 discordant pairs.

Reviewer sKow, final rating 3, asked whether the loss is predictable and whether simple strategies close the gap. An independent engineer review found the closing event explicit or inferable in 67/74 windows, and generic preservation, planning and snapshot strategies close at most 12% of the gap. The reviewer confirmed that the rebuttal resolved these concerns.

Reviewer RE5d, final rating 3, asked for a prompting baseline that tells the agent to preserve future-relevant state. We added this baseline ladder in Sec. 5.4 and App. N. The reviewer confirmed that it addresses the main concern.

Reviewer QyaX, final rating 2, raised real-world grounding, construct validity, standard safeguards and failure attribution. Two of these overlap with concerns that sKow and RE5d considered resolved. Whether the tasks measure foresight rather than general planning is answered by the same baseline ladder, and task realism by the same independent review, which rated 81/90 scenarios realistic. For the remaining points, we linked documented system behaviors and public incidents, and showed that standard safeguards raise Frontier success only from 12.5% to 21.7% versus 100% under Persistent Control. See App. O, P.2 and D.2. The reviewer has not yet responded.

ForesightBench measures a capability that existing agent benchmarks do not isolate: acquiring future-relevant information before the agent's own actions remove access to it. Thank you again for your time.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.