- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces ForesightBench, a benchmark evaluating whether long-horizon agents proactively acquire information before task-required transitions make it inaccessible. It contains 90 executable tasks across eight domains, including 40 Frontier tasks paired with persistent-observability controls. Experiments on six agent systems reveal substantial performance drops under irreversible observability loss, supplemented by trajectory-level analyses.
Critical strengths
- Meaningful problem formulation. The paper identifies an underexplored limitation of long-horizon agents: acquiring future-critical information before it becomes inaccessible.
- Controlled evaluation design. The matched Challenge–Control pairs and executable outcome verification provide useful evidence of agents' sensitivity to persistent observability.
Critical weaknesses
- Insufficient evidence for the predictability of observability loss. While the benchmark provides agents with task instructions and access to documented interfaces, it remains unclear whether agents can reasonably anticipate which information will become inaccessible after specific transitions. The current validation establishes pre- and post-transition accessibility, but does not explicitly assess whether the loss is predictable from agent-visible information. This raises concerns about whether some failures reflect insufficient prospective planning or unclear environment semantics.
- Limited strategy-level diagnostic baselines. Although the paper includes Oracle/NOP validation and matched persistent-observability controls, it does not evaluate simple proactive strategies, such as inspecting or preserving relevant state before irreversible operations, or explicitly prompting agents to consider future information needs. Such comparisons would help clarify whether the observed failures require stronger prospective reasoning or can be substantially mitigated by straightforward information-preservation policies.
Questions for authors
- What agent-visible documentation or environmental signals allow agents to anticipate observability loss before the closing transitions? Has the predictability of these transitions been independently validated?
- How would simple proactive information-preservation strategies or foresight-aware prompting perform on the benchmark?
4 comments
Response to Reviewer sKow (2/2): simple strategies and foresight prompting
Short answer. They help, but only a little. Generic prompts and blanket snapshots close only 8–12% of the gap, while naming only the category of needed state closes 56%.
Setup. We use Frontier-40 with three systems and three runs each, for 120 runs per cell. Every condition uses the same model, scaffold, budget, tools, and verifier, with a fresh environment for each run, and all conditions were run in the same period. The prompts are the same for every task and match those in our response to RE5d.
- C1 Preservation prompt: "Before taking an action that changes the environment, consider which information may become unavailable and whether it could be needed to satisfy the task later. Use the available documentation and interfaces to inspect and preserve such information when appropriate, then complete the task."
- C2 Foresight planning: C1 plus "First list what later steps will need and whether it will remain accessible."
- C3 Snapshot policy: the scaffold snapshots all queryable state before every state-changing command.
- C4 Category hint, a diagnostic reference rather than a baseline: it names only the category of needed state. A second author and an independent reviewer checked each of the 40 hints for leaked entities, values, commands, or timing (App. N).
| System | C0 | C1 | C2 | C3 | C4 | Control |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| DeepSeek-V4-Flash-0731 | 22 | 35 | 41 | 33 | 84 | 119 |
| Qwen3.8-Flash-Next | 17 | 27 | 30 | 26 | 74 | 118 |
| GLM-5.3-Flash | 9 | 15 | 14 | 14 | 62 | 120 |
| Pooled (%) | 13.3 | 21.4 | 23.6 | 20.3 | 61.1 | 99.2 |
| Gap closed | – | 9.4% | 12.0% | 8.1% | 55.7% | – |
C1 improves over C0 by 8.1 percentage points (pp), with a 95% CI of [4.7, 11.5] and adjusted p = 3×10⁻⁵, whereas C2 does not improve further, with adjusted p = 0.41. Two paraphrases of C1 give similar results, and adding C1 to the Control leaves success at 355 of 360, versus 357 without it.
Process evidence.
| C0 | C1 | C2 | C4 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Preservation actions before closure / run | 1.2 | 4.8 | 5.6 | 3.1 |
| Windows satisfied in time | 17% | 27% | 29% | 66% |
Rates are per information window. App. D.2 reports the stricter per-trajectory rate, which requires all windows to be satisfied.
Agents preserve four times as often under C1, but the right state is preserved in time in only 10 pp more windows. Of C1 failures, 38% save raw instead of derived state, 27% miss windows that open later, and 21% save the wrong entity. Snapshots use 2.4× the tokens and fail for the same reasons: derived state is not dumpable, and later windows are not yet open. C1 helps more on Standard-50, by 15.3 pp, because one explicit window usually dominates there.
Interpretation. Your two concerns separate cleanly.
- Unclear semantics explain little. The loss is documented, as Part 1 shows, and a category hint recovers 56% of the gap, more than half.
- Simple policies do not close the gap. They make agents save more, but not the right state.
The remaining bottleneck is identifying future-critical state before access closes. We report C1 as a useful but limited mitigation.
Revisions. Sec. 5.4 and App. N add the ladder, prompts, per-system results, and process metrics.
Both of your concerns now have direct evidence: an independent predictability audit, which finds 67/74 windows explicit or inferable, and a baseline ladder, in which generic strategies close at most 12% of the gap. We hope these results address your concerns, and we would appreciate it if you would take them into account in your evaluation. We are glad to clarify anything further.
The rebuttal resolved my concerns, I will raise my score to 3.
Thank you
Thank you for reviewing our rebuttal and for your updated assessment. We are glad we were able to address the points you raised, and we are happy to clarify any further questions you may have.
Response to Reviewer sKow (1/2): is observability loss predictable?
Thank you for the review. This part addresses W1/Q1, whether agents can anticipate the loss, and Part 2 addresses W2/Q2, whether simple strategies suffice. Both include new evidence.
Short answer. Yes, for 67 of 74 windows (90%), where an independent audit finds the closing event explicit in, or inferable from, documents in the agent workspace. Most failing agents do seek the needed state, but only after access has closed.
1. Agent-visible cues. Task documents describe what a transition does to information without revealing hidden values. Dockerfiles copy them into the agent workspace. Task IDs refer to the task manifest in the supplementary material.
2. Independent predictability audit, added in App. O. Three engineers with 6–12 years of infrastructure-operations experience, none involved in task construction, assessed all 74 information windows in Frontier-40. They saw only what an agent sees before closure: instructions, change requests, runbooks, interface help, and pre-closure responses. They saw no causal cards, hidden values, verifier internals, or Oracle solutions. For each window, they identified which operation closes access and which later step needs the state.
Agreement is Fleiss κ = 0.63. Disagreements concentrate on derived-state windows, where the closing event is clear but the needed aggregate is less obvious. Reviewers named the needed state for 61/74 windows from pre-closure materials alone.
The 7 unclear windows fall in 5 tasks. Excluding them barely changes the gap: on Frontier-35, Challenge 22/175 vs. Control 159/175, +78.3 percentage points, compared with +79.0 on all 40 tasks. We clarified their documentation, but all reported results use the frozen versions.
3. Behavioral evidence. The submission already reports this pattern: in 58 of the 63 process-determinable failures in App. D.2, the agent first tried to acquire the required state only after closure. Across all five systems, this holds for 108 of 138 failures. Agents recognize the need too late: the failure is in anticipating, before the transition, which state will be needed.
4. Semantics are usable once the target is known. Naming only the category of needed state, with no entity, value, or command, raises success from 13.3% to 61.1% under C4, as Part 2 shows. This indicates that the environment semantics are usable once the agent knows what to look for.
Revisions. App. O adds the audit protocol, the results, and the cases where reviewers disagreed. Sec. 3.3 now states the types of agent-visible cues that describe closing events.