acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Beyond Common Scenes: Long-Tailed Accident Anticipation with Scene Memory

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Traffic accident anticipation aims to issue early warnings of impending collisions from dashcam video, providing time for preventive action. Yet balanced accident and non-accident samples can conceal substantial imbalance among driving situations, leaving models with limited examples of the early warning cues in rare scenes. We formulate this scene-level long-tail problem and characterize it through complementary analyses of scene frequency, reference-model error, and expert curation, distinguishing statistical rarity, anticipation difficulty, and safety relevance. To support underrepresented scenes with related experience, we propose TailBank, a persistent scene-memory framework. TailBank retains central and peripheral representatives of training scene groups across batches and retrieves relevant knowledge to enhance current scene features. A distance-based fitness mechanism assesses how well the bank covers the current scene, modulates the fused representation, and separately flags insufficient support. This keeps scene familiarity distinct from accident likelihood. Our theoretical analysis establishes sufficient conditions for enhancement to reduce anticipation loss and for known and open scenes to be separated. Experiments on DAD, CCD, and A3D show state-of-the-art accuracy on DAD and A3D and competitive warning timeliness. Further evaluations support TailBank's effectiveness in rare and challenging scenes, generalization to unseen scenes, and identification of difficult cases.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
Autonomous Driving, Traffic Accident Anticipation, Long-Tailed Learning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_vsnzOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper argues that accident anticipation should account for scene-level long tails and proposes a scene-oriented memory bank with a fusion mechanism.

Critical strengths
  1. This paper introduces a worthwhile problem for accident anticipation, i.e., the long-tailed setting.
  2. Extensive experiments are conducted following previous accident anticipation works.
Critical weaknesses

The problem of accident anticipation is not new, and there are vast established works in this field. The DAD, CCD, and A3D datasets are widely selected and not good choices in this field, because the performance on these datasets is nearly saturated.

  1. The central long-tail definition is problematic. Several tail subsets are constructed by clustering the DAD test set, while other subsets are selected by model error or expert judgment. Low frequency in the test set does not show that a scene has little training support, and error-ranked or expert-selected examples measure difficulty or safety relevance rather than a statistical long tail. The paper should quantify support in the training set, define head, medium, and tail groups from training frequencies, and then evaluate those fixed groups on the test set.

  2. Only 11 of 270 test videos are reported as unseen, which is 4.07% of the set. And comparisons with standard open-set and out-of-distribution baselines are required, together with threshold selection on a separate validation set.

  3. The theoretical discussion does not substantiate the claimed mechanism. Proposition 1 is a standard smoothness-based descent statement that depends on an unobserved label gradient, while Proposition 2 assumes the feature separation the method is intended to produce. These results are better presented as conditional intuition unless the assumptions are checked empirically.

  4. The experimental evaluation is insufficient. The authors are encouraged to compare their method with recent approaches, such as RiskProp, and report established accident anticipation metrics to provide a more comprehensive evaluation. Reference (CVPR 2026):

Zou, Y., et al. “RiskProp: Collision-Anchored Self-Supervised Risk Propagation for Early Accident Anticipation.” Proceedings of the IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR), 2026, pp. 2768–2777.

  1. The optional vision-language-model feedback is shown through only two examples without a fidelity study. This aims to demonstrate how feature fusion changes under the reflection mechanisms and to explore the practical impact of these mechanisms on the accident risk prediction region.

Some minor issues:

  1. If this is intended as an ICLR 2027 submission, the running header still says ICLR 2026.

  2. Since Fig. 1 uses the DADA to describe the motivation, why not use it in the experiments?

  3. The main text points to Appendix E.2 for implementation details, but the relevant material appears to be in Appendix E.1.

  4. The description of Zhang et al. (2025) as a multi-criteria analysis of long-tailed driving behavior does not appear well matched to LATTE. The cited claim and reference should be checked.

  5. Standard references for VGG-16 and GRU are missing where these backbones are introduced.

  6. The state-of-the-art wording is too broad: the reported DAD mTTA is below DDM, the CCD AP is below ROAR, and the A3D AP is tied rather than strictly higher.

  7. Please add spaces and revise grammar in ‘observed scene.TailBank,’ ‘weight.Gradients,’ and ‘by following process.’

The motivation is worthwhile, but the present evaluation does not establish that the method solves training-data long-tail scarcity or reliably handles unseen scenes.

Questions for authors
  1. The long-tailed setting is problematic. Please provide more solid analysis or problem definition in this paper.
  2. Only 11 of 270 test videos are reported as unseen, which is 4.07% of the set. And comparisons with standard open-set and out-of-distribution baselines are required, together with threshold selection on a separate validation set.
  3. The theoretical discussion does not substantiate the claimed mechanism.
  4. More experiments on other popular datasets are preferred, such as DADA-2000 and DoTA.
Reviewer_ZHEgOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper claims that even when the numbers of accident and non-accident videos are balanced, more detailed scene characteristics, such as interactions between objects and road environments, can be imbalanced. In this regard, the authors distinguish three perspectives: rarity, difficulty, and safety relevance, and incorporate them into the evaluation. The authors introduce a memory-based method called TailBank, which preserves tail samples in a memory bank.

Critical strengths

None

Critical weaknesses
  1. The three evaluation perspectives are not sufficiently evaluated. Although the implications of each perspective are insightful, their evaluation is limited to the DAD dataset. These evaluations should be extended to other datasets (CCD and A3D). The compared baselines are also limited in number and somewhat outdated. The comparisons should include more recent methods.

  2. The relationships among the three perspectives need to be addressed. For example, rarity and difficulty may overlap. In addition, the expert curation protocol needs to be specified in more detail, including the experts' qualifications, annotation procedures, and inter-annotator agreement.

  3. Traffic accident anticipation needs to operate efficiently. Although efficiency is not the main focus of this paper, inference speed and computational cost should be reported so that readers can assess the strengths and weaknesses of each method. Comparisons with other efficient methods [1, 2] would strengthen this evaluation.

[1] Zhang, Jiaxun, et al. "LATTE: A real-time lightweight attention-based traffic accident anticipation engine." Information Fusion 122 (2025): 103173. [2] Song, Inpyo, and Jangwon Lee. "Real-time traffic accident anticipation with feature reuse." 2025 IEEE International Conference on Image Processing (ICIP). IEEE, 2025.

Questions for authors
  1. Can you expand the scope of three evaluation perspectives?
  2. Could you specify the relationships among the three perspectives?
  3. Could you report the efficiency of the method?
Reviewer_nR37OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper tackles the scene-level long-tail problem faced by traffic accident anticipation in driving environments, where however driving scenes are naturally long-tailed while balanced accident and non-accident samples. This paper first analyze the scene long-tail problem via scene frequency, prediction errors, and expert-curated safety-critical scenarios. Then, it proposes a TailBank scene memory to dynamically memorize local- and scene-level representative training scene groups, which should have seldom or never been visited during testing. At inference, relevant memory features can be retrieved to assist the current scene feature, which is guided by a distance-based fitness score for enhancement, and to identify potentially unseen scenes. Theoretical analyses of knowledge enhancement and scene separation are provided. Consequently, good anticipation performance on various metrics (at least 14.73% and 3.92% improvement over state-of-the-art on DAD and CCD, respectively) is achieved in comprehensive experiments on current large-scale driving video datasets (DAD, CCD, and A3D).

Critical strengths
  1. Firstly, the paper deals with a significant problem concerning the issue of anticipating accidents where balanced labels for accidents do not mean balanced representation of driving situations. The difference between scene rarity, predictability, and importance is reasonable enough to prompt an assessment.

  2. The suggested TailBank approach is quite straightforward and understandable. Keeping central and peripheral scene representations through training steps allows for a useful method of preserving data about rare scenes. The fitness procedure can also serve as a means of taking into consideration the importance of stored data when making predictions.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The relationship between the suggested long-tail problem and the true technique is not very convincing. (1) The tail subsets are based on the test-set frequence which is not necessarily rare during training (2) the long-tail evaluations mostly measure against UString and DSTA while the other baseline methods DDM perform better.

  2. The motivation for the fitness-guided fusion is unconvincing. It scales the retrieved knowledge as well as the original visual features (according to Eq. (6)) which could wash away some of the useful accident cues. The frozen-model comparisons do not show whether the design is preferable if the other choice of fusion were trained in isolation.

Questions for authors
  1. How are the training scene sets created, and are the rare test sets also rare in the training process?

  2. Why should both sources of features in Eq. (6) be scaled? Can other fusion techniques be independently trained and compared?

  3. Is there any possibility to test the stronger baselines like DDM on the long-tail subsets as well?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.