- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper argues that accident anticipation should account for scene-level long tails and proposes a scene-oriented memory bank with a fusion mechanism.
Critical strengths
- This paper introduces a worthwhile problem for accident anticipation, i.e., the long-tailed setting.
- Extensive experiments are conducted following previous accident anticipation works.
Critical weaknesses
The problem of accident anticipation is not new, and there are vast established works in this field. The DAD, CCD, and A3D datasets are widely selected and not good choices in this field, because the performance on these datasets is nearly saturated.
-
The central long-tail definition is problematic. Several tail subsets are constructed by clustering the DAD test set, while other subsets are selected by model error or expert judgment. Low frequency in the test set does not show that a scene has little training support, and error-ranked or expert-selected examples measure difficulty or safety relevance rather than a statistical long tail. The paper should quantify support in the training set, define head, medium, and tail groups from training frequencies, and then evaluate those fixed groups on the test set.
-
Only 11 of 270 test videos are reported as unseen, which is 4.07% of the set. And comparisons with standard open-set and out-of-distribution baselines are required, together with threshold selection on a separate validation set.
-
The theoretical discussion does not substantiate the claimed mechanism. Proposition 1 is a standard smoothness-based descent statement that depends on an unobserved label gradient, while Proposition 2 assumes the feature separation the method is intended to produce. These results are better presented as conditional intuition unless the assumptions are checked empirically.
-
The experimental evaluation is insufficient. The authors are encouraged to compare their method with recent approaches, such as RiskProp, and report established accident anticipation metrics to provide a more comprehensive evaluation. Reference (CVPR 2026):
Zou, Y., et al. “RiskProp: Collision-Anchored Self-Supervised Risk Propagation for Early Accident Anticipation.” Proceedings of the IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR), 2026, pp. 2768–2777.
- The optional vision-language-model feedback is shown through only two examples without a fidelity study. This aims to demonstrate how feature fusion changes under the reflection mechanisms and to explore the practical impact of these mechanisms on the accident risk prediction region.
Some minor issues:
-
If this is intended as an ICLR 2027 submission, the running header still says ICLR 2026.
-
Since Fig. 1 uses the DADA to describe the motivation, why not use it in the experiments?
-
The main text points to Appendix E.2 for implementation details, but the relevant material appears to be in Appendix E.1.
-
The description of Zhang et al. (2025) as a multi-criteria analysis of long-tailed driving behavior does not appear well matched to LATTE. The cited claim and reference should be checked.
-
Standard references for VGG-16 and GRU are missing where these backbones are introduced.
-
The state-of-the-art wording is too broad: the reported DAD mTTA is below DDM, the CCD AP is below ROAR, and the A3D AP is tied rather than strictly higher.
-
Please add spaces and revise grammar in ‘observed scene.TailBank,’ ‘weight.Gradients,’ and ‘by following process.’
The motivation is worthwhile, but the present evaluation does not establish that the method solves training-data long-tail scarcity or reliably handles unseen scenes.
Questions for authors
- The long-tailed setting is problematic. Please provide more solid analysis or problem definition in this paper.
- Only 11 of 270 test videos are reported as unseen, which is 4.07% of the set. And comparisons with standard open-set and out-of-distribution baselines are required, together with threshold selection on a separate validation set.
- The theoretical discussion does not substantiate the claimed mechanism.
- More experiments on other popular datasets are preferred, such as DADA-2000 and DoTA.