- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Tail-MDP, a multi-dimensional long-tail learning framework with tail-aware decoding for trajectory prediction. The authors reformulate tail sample identification as an anomaly detection problem relative to head-dominant patterns, and use autoencoder reconstruction errors as a unified criterion to quantify tailness across three key dimensions affecting future motion. In addition, a lightweight prompt-guided decoding strategy is proposed to direct model attention toward tail cues during generation. Experiments are conducted on Argoverse2 and nuScenes.
Critical strengths
1.Long-tail identification is formulated as a unified multi-dimensional anomaly detection problem, with SAE head prototypes used to amplify reconstruction errors for tail samples.
2.Multi-dimensional tailness is explicitly incorporated into the decoding stage through lightweight prompt-guided tail-aware generation.
Critical weaknesses
1.Dataset coverage is somewhat limited. The empirical study only uses Argoverse2 and nuScenes, without including other widely used benchmarks such as Waymo Open Motion or INTERACTION.
- The novelty is mainly compositional, and the distinction from existing multi-dimensional long-tail work is not sharp enough. The framework combines AE/SAE-based anomaly detection, contrastive learning, prompt pools, and Prefix-Tuning, all of which have precedents. Multi-dimensional long-tail modeling has also been explored in recent work such as CDKFormer, AMD, and SAML. The paper would be stronger if it more explicitly clarified its unique contribution beyond these methods, especially the SAE head-prototype mechanism and the coupling between multi-dimensional tailness and prompt-guided decoding.
Questions for authors
1.Dataset generalization and evaluation fairness: Could the authors clarify why only Argoverse2 and nuScenes are used, and whether at least one additional widely used benchmark such as Waymo Open Motion could be added?
2.Novelty positioning relative to prior multi-dimensional long-tail work: How does Tail-MDP fundamentally differ from recent multi-dimensional long-tail methods such as CDKFormer, AMD, SAML, and SAIL? Is the main contribution the SAE head-prototype mechanism, the prompt-guided decoding, or their coupling, rather than multi-dimensional long-tail modeling itself?
Thank you for addressing my questions. Your responses resolved my concerns, and I appreciate your efforts to release the code. I will raise my score to 3.