acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

: Stratified Scaling Search for Test-Time Scaling in Diffusion Language Models

Abstract

Test-time scaling asks how a fixed diffusion language model (DLM) can use additional inference compute to improve generation without retraining. Standard Best-of- sampling spends this compute on generating independent complete outputs and selects only after decoding, leaving the generation process itself unchanged. We introduce (Stratified Scaling Search), which instead allocates additional compute during denoising. At each denoising step, expands multiple partial trajectories, evaluates their one-step clean predictions with a black-box verifier, and resamples promising trajectories while preserving diversity. We derive this procedure from a KL-regularized reward-tilted target distribution and use incremental child-parent potentials whose product telescopes to the desired terminal reward tilt, making the ideal search objective invariant to the number of denoising steps. Our default verifier is training-free and requires neither a learned reward model nor ground-truth labels. Across six benchmarks, consistently improves over standard diffusion decoding at every tested inference budget. Its performance relative to other test-time scaling methods depends on the reliability of intermediate predictions: informative intermediate signals favor search during denoising, whereas costly or unreliable process-reward-model scoring can favor output-level selection.

Primary area:
generative models
Keywords:
diffusion language models, test-time scaling, inference-time compute, verifier-guided decoding, particle search, sequential Monte Carlo, denoising trajectories, mathematical reasoning, masked diffusion

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_EYwnOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper allocates inference compute during diffusion decoding through repeated trajectory expansion, look-ahead verification, and SSP resampling. Scheduled child–parent potentials telescope to a terminal reward tilt, and majority voting selects the final answer. Experiments cover six benchmarks with LLaDA and additional evaluations with Dream, showing gains over single-trajectory decoding and task-dependent advantages over output-level sampling.

Critical strengths
  • The method combines look-ahead scoring, scheduled weighting, and low-variance resampling into a practical inference procedure requiring no model training or external reward model by default. The fixed-schedule telescoping construction provides a coherent account of its intended target.

  • The empirical gains are useful, particularly on ARC-Challenge and TruthfulQA: at the default budget, S³ exceeds BoK by 3.07 and 4.68 percentage points, respectively. Code-generation and Dream results broaden the evidence. The analysis also reports limitations, including the small advantage on GSM8K and cases where PRM cost favors terminal selection.

Critical weaknesses
  • The central diversity diagnostics contradict their interpretation. Appendix E.2 states that SSP retains all eight founder lineages throughout 64 steps, but Figure 10 shows the SSP curves declining to approximately two and three surviving lineages. The numerical descriptions of Figure 9 also disagree with its bars. These discrepancies weaken the evidence supporting diversity preservation as a mechanism behind the gains. Moreover, the fixed-frontier resampling comparison does not establish its contribution to final accuracy, especially when systematic and stratified resampling also match SSP's reported offspring-count variance.

  • I could not reconstruct the evaluated procedure consistently from the stated configurations. Section 3.1 defines T=⌈L/K⌉T=\lceil L/\mathcal{K}\rceil, whereas Table 11 fixes L=128,T=64L=128,T=64 with default K=64\mathcal{K}=64. Algorithm 1 votes over NN survivors, but Table 19 describes Nb=8Nb=8 surviving particles despite the default N=4,b=2N=4,b=2. These may be notation or reporting errors, but they concern the decoding schedule and final candidate population and need resolution before the matched-compute comparisons can be assessed confidently.

Questions for authors
  • Please reconcile Figures 9–10 with Appendix E.2 and specify the logging, aggregation, and genealogy-tracking procedure. Were alternative resamplers evaluated by replaying fixed frontiers or within complete searches? How does SSP compare with systematic or stratified resampling in final accuracy under otherwise matched settings?

  • What exact decoding schedule and final voting population produced the reported results? Please resolve the configuration discrepancies above and explain the forward-pass counts and reuse of look-ahead logits.

  • How does Lemma 1 establish decreasing ESS with nonuniform parent offsets? For τt=1\tau_t=1, child scores (0.8,0.8,0.2,0.2)(0.8,0.8,0.2,0.2), and corresponding parent scores (1,1,0,0)(1,1,0,0), Eq. (9) gives ESS increasing from approximately 3.853.85 at Δ=0\Delta=0 to 44 at Δ=2/3\Delta=2/3. This appears to invalidate the stated monotonicity argument for Algorithm 2, although it does not affect the default fixed schedule.

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer EYwn

Thank you for the close reading of the appendices. The new runs and the accuracy results are in the response to Reviewer dCQ4 (W2). Here, S3S^3 means S3S^3 (505 NFE), unless we state another NFE.

W1 and Q1. Figures 9–10 and Appendix E.2. Figure 10 shows the behavior of SSP: the mean number of lineages falls from 8.0 at step 0 to 4.41 at step 32 and 2.14 at step 56. Appendix E.2 does not agree with this, and we will correct it with Figure 10 as the reference.

Table R5. Replay on identical logged weights (MATH-500, N=8N=8, b=2b=2).

ResamplerOffspring-count varianceFounder fractionAnswer entropy
SSP0.2490.5950.816
Systematic0.2490.5990.824
Stratified0.2690.5950.815
Multinomial0.4690.4440.662
Top-NN0.2320.3340.474

We apply each resampler to the same logged weights and track the founder of each particle. As you noted, this replay does not measure accuracy. In complete searches (Table R4, response to Reviewer AhDy), SSP does not differ significantly from systematic or stratified resampling [1]. Multinomial resampling is worse on ARC-C and TruthfulQA under majority vote. Thus, the evidence supports low-variance resampling as a group, but not SSP in particular.

W2 and Q2. Schedule and voting population. The schedule follows Algorithm 1 and Table 11: L=128L=128, K=64\mathcal{K}=64, T=64T=64, so 2 blocks of 32 steps, with 2 positions for each step. We will use this convention in Section 3.1.

The submitted tables mix votes over the NN survivors and over the NbNb frontier. The new results vote over the NbNb frontier for all methods. A vote over the survivors changes the majority accuracy of S3S^3 by at most 0.34 pp.

NFE and reuse of logits. S3S^3 (505 NFE) scores each child: 1+63×8=5051+63\times 8=505 passes, 1 for the root and 63×863\times 8 for the children. Survivors reuse cached logits at the next step.

The submitted S3S^3 runs used the stand-alone weight of Remark 2, not Eq. (6) of Algorithm 1. Two children of one parent received the same look-ahead score, so these runs used 256 distinct NFE, not 512. We call this setting S3S^3 (256 NFE), and we will report both counts. The telescoping argument (Proposition 2) does not apply to these runs. It applies only to S3S^3 (505 NFE).

Q3. Lemma 1. Your example is correct: in general, ESS is not monotone in Δ\Delta. We will replace Lemma 1 with this precise statement. Let ℓk(Δ)=ok+Δsk\ell_k(\Delta)=o_k+\Delta s_k with offset ok=τt(sk−skpar)o_k=\tau_t(s_k-s_k^{\mathrm{par}}), weights wk∝eℓkw_k\propto e^{\ell_k}, and w~k∝wk2\tilde w_k\propto w_k^2. Let sˉ=∑kwksk\bar s=\sum_k w_k s_k and s~=∑kw~ksk\tilde s=\sum_k \tilde w_k s_k.

  1. For any offset, dsˉdΔ=∑kwk(sk−sˉ)2≥0\frac{d\bar s}{d\Delta}=\sum_k w_k(s_k-\bar s)^2\ge 0.
  2. ddΔlog⁡ESS=−2(s~−sˉ)\frac{d}{d\Delta}\log\mathrm{ESS}=-2(\tilde s-\bar s).
  3. Fix Δ\Delta, and let (sk−sl)(ℓk−ℓl)≥0(s_k-s_l)(\ell_k-\ell_l)\ge 0 for all pairs. Then s~≥sˉ\tilde s\ge\bar s (Chebyshev sum inequality), so ESS does not increase at this Δ\Delta. This is a sufficient condition. ESS is monotone on [0,τ−τt][0,\tau-\tau_t] if the condition holds at every Δ\Delta in this interval. The condition holds for siblings of one parent, because ℓk−ℓl=(τt+Δ)(sk−sl)\ell_k-\ell_l=(\tau_t+\Delta)(s_k-s_l). It can fail across parents, so S3S^3 does not guarantee it in general.
  4. A constant offset (for example, τt=0\tau_t=0) satisfies item 3 for all Δ≥0\Delta\ge 0.

Algorithm 2 needs a feasible initial point, ESS(0)≥ηNb\mathrm{ESS}(0)\ge\eta Nb, and then keeps ESS(lo)≥ηNb\mathrm{ESS}(\mathrm{lo})\ge\eta Nb. Thus, it returns a feasible increment. It returns the largest feasible increment only if ESS is monotone over the full interval [0,τ−τt][0,\tau-\tau_t]. Item 3 at every Δ\Delta in this interval is one sufficient case. If ESS is not monotone, it can return a smaller feasible increment. The fixed schedule in our experiments does not use Algorithm 2 or this lemma.

Telescoping and performance. Proposition 2 is an algebraic identity for the target of Eq. (6). It does not cover the submitted S3S^3 (256 NFE) runs. It is not an accuracy guarantee for S3S^3 (see Reviewer AhDy, Minor 2).

BoK margins in your summary. These margins compare BoK under arg-max with S3S^3 under majority vote (see Reviewer dCQ4, W2). With the same rule, S3S^3 does not beat BoK.

[1] Srinivasan. FOCS 2001. https://doi.org/10.1109/SFCS.2001.959935

Thank you for the clarifications. They resolve my questions about the schedule and ESS. However, the submitted experiments used a different weighting rule from Eq. (6), and the reported advantage over BoK does not hold under matched selection. This weakens the empirical support for the paper, so I will maintain score. I have no further questions.

Reviewer_AhDyOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes S3S^3, which is a new training-free test-time scaling method for discrete diffusion models. At each step, S3S^3 maintains N particles and expands each into b children. The reward is estimated through a one-step endpoint predictor that jumps to the clean data, and is then scored as usual with the defined reward. S3S^3 uses a scheduled reward tilt, and resampled back to N particles with the Srinivasan Sampling Process. The final answer is chosen by majority vote over the surviving particles. On the theory side, the authors bound the cost of Best-of-K, and show that the per-step potentials telescope to the terminal tilt. S3S^3 is evaluated on LLaDA-8B and Dream-7B over multiple benchmarks, against single-trajectory decoding, BoK, and FK-Steering. The experiments mainly use a hand-crafted verified reward + a PRM model commonly used for AR.

Critical strengths
  • S3S^3 is a simple, efficient, training-free method that can be used with any discrete diffusion model, with wall time comparable to BoK.
  • Nice use of the one-step clean prediction as a look-ahead. It comes for free in discrete diffusion models, which is nicely illustrated here. The analysis of when the look-ahead is informative (Appendix E.1) is also useful beyond this work.
  • Consistent improvements over single-trajectory decoding across reasoning, multiple-choice, and code tasks.
  • Honest and thorough analysis, including where BoK+PRM is better.
Critical weaknesses

My main concerns are the unclear contribution over FK-Steering and the FK-Steering baseline. Upon resolving, I would consider increasing my score.

  • Contribution clarification: The method is close to FK-Steering, which already uses look-ahead scoring, and particle resampling. As far as I understand, the differences are the scheduled tilt, branching (N→Nb→N), and SSP resampling. However, these components are not ablated individually on accuracy. It is therefore unclear which of these drives the improvement gains over FK-Steering. An ablation for each of them would clarify the contribution and significantly strengthen the work. It could also lead to a better understanding of what is most important for S3S^3 performance.
  • FK-Steering baseline: On the LLaDA experiments, FK-Steering performs below single-trajectory decoding on three of four benchmarks. At λ=1, I would expect FK-Steering to behave roughly like BoK with majority voting, so I'm a bit confused about why there is such a big performance difference. Looking at Table 12, the hyperparameters seem to barely change the performance at all here. At the same time, FK-Steering is competitive with S3S^3 on code (Table 1). This makes me worry that something in the FK-Steering setup on LLaDA is off. I would expect a tuned FK-Steering baseline to at least be similar to BoK performance-wise.
  • (minor) The generation length of 128 tokens seems short for MATH-500, and the reported average effective output tokens (around 3–6, Table 16) are a bit confusing.
  • (minor) The theory mostly restates known results, while Corollary 1 holds for any distribution at the same KL distance (as noted in Appendix A.3). Also, BoK is compared to the exact tilt here, while S3S^3 is also only approximating the tilt so it doesn't really imply that S3S^3 imrprves this.
Questions for authors
  • How does S3S^3 perform with:
    • with b = 1 (no branching, more particles)
    • with FK’s constant-λ difference potential instead of the schedule
    • with systematic or multinomial resampling instead of SSP, measured on accuracy (Figure 9 does not show this, as far as I understand)
  • Is there any explanation or intuition for the bad performance of FK-Steering on LLaDA? What is the magnitude of the rewards? Could you measure the effective sample size (ESS) for FK-Steering and S3S^3 in your setup? This would clarify what the weights are doing here.
  • Could you clarify the low effective output tokens in Table 16? What is exactly being measured here?
  • Is S3S^3 applicable to uniform discrete diffusion models out of the box? How would the decoding schedule and the one-step prediction behave there?
3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer AhDy

Thank you for the precise questions. The new runs and the BoK results are in the response to Reviewer dCQ4 (W2). Here, S3S^3 means S3S^3 (505 NFE), which is Algorithm 1.

Novelty over FK-Steering. FK-Steering [1] already uses look-ahead scoring, resampling, and telescoping difference potentials (Section 5, Appendix G.1). The differences of S3S^3 are the scheduled tilt, N→Nb→NN\to Nb\to N branching, and SSP. Your requested ablations show that none of these gives a significant gain at our default point.

Table R4. Difference from S3S^3 in complete searches (pp), arg-max / majority vote.

VariantMATH-500GSM8KARC-CTruthfulQA
b=1b=1, N=8N=8−0.13-0.13 / +0.87+0.87+1.52+1.52 / +3.64+3.64−0.63-0.63 / +2.67+2.67−0.97-0.97 / +1.22+1.22
Constant tilt−1.27-1.27 / −0.53-0.530.00 / +0.03+0.03−0.28-0.28 / −0.34-0.34+0.19+0.19 / −2.10-2.10
Systematic+0.40+0.40 / +0.67+0.67+0.71+0.71 / +1.39+1.39−0.28-0.28 / +0.46+0.46+0.34+0.34 / −0.34-0.34
Stratified−0.47-0.47 / −0.67-0.67+0.53+0.53 / +0.88+0.88−0.31-0.31 / +0.09+0.09+0.63+0.63 / −1.02-1.02
Multinomial−1.80-1.80 / −1.53-1.53−0.91-0.91 / −1.09-1.09−1.02-1.02 / −4.55-4.55−1.51-1.51 / −3.75-3.75

We use the test and threshold of Reviewer dCQ4, W2. Under arg-max, no variant differs significantly from S3S^3. Under majority vote, b=1b=1 (no branching) is better than S3S^3 on GSM8K and ARC-C, so branching does not help at this point. Multinomial resampling is worse on ARC-C and TruthfulQA, while SSP, systematic, and stratified resampling give similar accuracy [2]. We will remove the claim that these components drive the gains.

Q2. ESS.

Table R3. Range over four benchmarks.

MethodESS fractionReward stdFounders at end
S3S^3 (/Nb/Nb)0.995–0.9970.049–0.0761.76–2.36 of 4
FK, λ=1\lambda=1 (/N/N)0.987–0.9940.064–0.0951.84–1.87 of 8
FK, λ=10\lambda=10 (/N/N)0.754–0.8340.056–0.0761.45–1.52 of 8

For S3S^3, the ESS fraction is 0.98 or more at every step. Thus, the weights are near uniform, and resampling is close to a random halving. Early resampling removes trajectories while the look-ahead is weak (AUROC 0.576 at t/T=0.9t/T=0.9, Figure 7). This can explain why b=1b=1 helps majority vote.

To test the effect of a stronger tilt, we started a sweep of the terminal tilt τ\tau at matched NFE. We will report these results in a follow-up message, whether or not they favor S3S^3.

FK-Steering on LLaDA. Your concern is correct. The submitted FK-Steering runs used block length K=128\mathcal{K}=128 and returned one arg-max particle, while the other methods used K=64\mathcal{K}=64. We will correct Table 4 and Section 4.2 with matched K=64\mathcal{K}=64 values (arg-max, λ=1\lambda=1):

FK-SteeringMATH-500GSM8KARC-CTruthfulQA
K=64\mathcal{K}=6427.4769.7577.1447.66
K=128\mathcal{K}=12822.2058.3375.7446.59

At K=64\mathcal{K}=64, FK-Steering exceeds Baseline on all four benchmarks and does not differ significantly from S3S^3. The largest gap is 1.52 pp (GSM8K, majority vote, FK-Steering higher, p=0.02p=0.02). At λ=1\lambda=1, it still differs from BoK, because each round removes particles by chance. With uniform weights (λ=0\lambda=0), it loses 6.24 pp on GSM8K and 5.60 on ARC-C against BoK-8 under majority vote.

Code tasks. At B=8B=8 (Table 1), FK-Steering is within 0.3 pp of S3S^3. The FK-Steering code runs used K=128\mathcal{K}=128, and we did not isolate the cause.

Minor 1. Table 16 counts the tokens of the extracted answer, not the full response. We will clarify this in Appendix I and list L=128L=128 as a limit for MATH-500.

Minor 2. We agree. Corollary 1 and Proposition 2 describe the target distribution, not the accuracy of S3S^3. The submitted runs, S3S^3 (256 NFE), use Remark 2, not Algorithm 1, so the telescoping argument (Proposition 2) does not apply to them. Their accuracy is within 1.00 pp of S3S^3 (505 NFE). We will state this separation in Section 3.

Q4. Uniform models. The method needs a stochastic reverse kernel and a one-step clean prediction, so it applies, but we did not test it.

[1] Singhal et al. ICML 2025. https://proceedings.mlr.press/v267/singhal25b.html

[2] Gerber et al. Annals of Statistics 2019. https://doi.org/10.1214/18-AOS1746

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Follow-up to Reviewer AhDy: sweep of the terminal tilt

In our response to Q2, we promised the results of a sweep of the terminal tilt τ\tau. The sweep is complete. The results do not favor a stronger tilt.

Setup. We used S3S^3 (505 NFE), Algorithm 1, at the default point of Table 11 with seeds 42–44. We changed only τ\tau, and the geometric schedule ends at the new τ\tau. The default is τ=3.57\tau=3.57. All runs use 505 NFE.

We use the question-level sign-flip test of Reviewer dCQ4, W2. The sweep gives 32 comparisons, and we did not correct for multiple testing. Thus, all pp values below are unadjusted, and we report them as exploratory.

Table R6. Accuracy (%), mean of three seeds, arg-max / majority vote.

τ\tauMATH-500GSM8KARC-CTruthfulQAESS fractionFounders at end (of 4)
1.027.60 / 29.3370.28 / 71.3776.71 / 82.6550.58 / 52.530.9995–0.99972.64–3.16
3.57 (default)28.27 / 28.1369.30 / 69.4778.38 / 81.9148.15 / 50.930.9946–0.99701.76–2.36
7.1427.67 / 27.8768.51 / 68.4477.73 / 80.9748.59 / 50.880.9836–0.99161.46–1.96
14.2827.53 / 28.0769.27 / 69.4277.79 / 80.3747.66 / 49.460.9625–0.98141.20–1.58
28.5627.67 / 27.6068.94 / 69.0777.93 / 80.0650.15 / 51.900.9393–0.96841.05–1.30

The ESS fraction is the mean over steps, and the ranges are over the four benchmarks. The default row is S3S^3 (505 NFE) in Table R1b.

Results. We compared each τ\tau with the default on each benchmark and rule, a total of 32 comparisons. For two differences, the unadjusted pp is less than 0.01:

  • τ=1.0\tau=1.0 (a weaker tilt) is better on GSM8K under majority vote: +1.90+1.90 pp, 95% CI [0.68,3.08][0.68, 3.08], unadjusted p=0.002p=0.002.
  • τ=28.56\tau=28.56 (a stronger tilt) is worse on ARC-C under majority vote: −1.85-1.85 pp, 95% CI [−3.16,−0.48][-3.16, -0.48], unadjusted p=0.006p=0.006.

No τ\tau above the default gives a gain over the default with unadjusted p<0.05p<0.05. The smallest such pp is 0.08 (TruthfulQA, arg-max, τ=28.56\tau=28.56). With 32 comparisons, one or two small pp values can occur by chance, so the two results with p<0.01p<0.01 are not confirmed effects.

Observations. At τ=28.56\tau=28.56, the mean ESS fraction is still 0.94 or more. But the final particles come from fewer founders (1.05–1.30 of 4, against 1.76–2.36 at the default). This is consistent with a loss of diversity. It does not show that this loss causes a change in accuracy, and we did not test this cause.

The τ=1.0\tau=1.0 runs keep the most founders and give the highest mean majority-vote accuracy on all four benchmarks. Only for the GSM8K gain is the unadjusted pp less than 0.01. For the other three gains, the unadjusted pp is from 0.12 to 0.25.

Thus, we find no evidence that a stronger tilt improves S3S^3 at this point. This is consistent with our answer to Q2.

At τ=1.0\tau=1.0, the mean majority-vote accuracy of BoK-8 (Table R1b) is still higher on MATH-500, GSM8K, and ARC-C. We did not test these differences. We will add Table R6 to the appendix, with the unadjusted pp values labeled as exploratory. We will state that we found no gain from a stronger tilt at our default point.

Thank you for the thorough rebuttal. I appreciate how openly you report the results, including the ones that do not favor the method. The new experiments answer all of my questions. However, they resolve my two main concerns in a direction that weakens the paper’s central claims.

Contribution over FK-Steering. The ablations in Table R4 show that none of the three components that set S³ apart from FK-Steering gives a significant gain at the default point. Those components are the scheduled tilt, N→Nb→N branching, and SSP. Under majority vote, removing branching (b = 1) is actually better on GSM8K and ARC-C. SSP performs on par with systematic and stratified resampling. The λ sweep in Table R6 points the same way: the weakest tilt (λ = 1) keeps the most founders and gives the highest mean majority-vote accuracy on all four benchmarks.

FK-Steering baseline. Thank you for tracking down the mismatch in block length and arg-max selection, this is very important for the soundness of the paper. Now with matched settings, FK-Steering beats single-trajectory decoding on all four benchmarks and does not seem to differ significantly from S³. Together with the ablations, this means that S³ does not rlly beat FK-Steering on accuracy.

Overall, the revised paper would need to change its claims on the competitiveness of S³ (as it now performs at best on par with FK-Steering and BoK). I think there are still interesting findings in the work, but they would need a different storyline from the one submitted. Two examples are the analysis of when the look-ahead becomes informative and the finding that verifier-tilted resampling collapses to near-uniform weights in this setting. As these changes go beyond what a rebuttal can address, I will maintain my score.

Reviewer_dCQ4OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The authors introduce a training-free approach to improve MDM’s accuracy. The approach allows the use of extra compute to improve accuracy over plain decoding. Like FK-steering, the closest paper, the approach initializes several (let’s say K) trajectories (“particles”), and as the trajectory progresses, computes for each step a potential function that scores the current trajectory, and uses the potential differences to resample the particles towards completions that a verifier is likely to reward. Unlike FK-steering, the authors add SSP sampling to preserve particle diversity; multinomial resampling is prone to collapsing the diversity. The authors also apply a schedule that tilts the resampling weights toward candidates the verifier rewards, with earlier steps tilting less.

Critical strengths
  1. Beats naive baseline: plain single trajectory diffusion LLM with a single schedule. It meaningfully and consistently beats plain diffusion.
  2. Usage of Srinivasan Sampling Process (SSP) preserves particle diversity. Novel application of a method to ensure particle diversity.
  3. Working steering approach for MDMs evaluated on reasoning benchmarks.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The authors note “PG-DLM (Dang et al., 2025) uses multi-pass refinement, and PRISM (Bai et al., 2026) changes the search hierarchy and verifier. “ However, if the main idea is to use test-time compute to improve performance, then it could be argued that in a compute matched setting, those are viable competing approaches, which are not measured.
  2. In applying their method to LLaDA, performance over BoK-8 is not consistent across all datasets, except for TruthfulQA. The same is true for their experiment in Dream. MATH-500: 32.20 vs 31.80; GSM8K: 62.93 vs. 61.71; ARC-C: 84.81 vs. 84.73; TruthfulQA: 57.16 vs. 54.83 (56.30 for FK-diff).
  3. In Table 12, the authors note that several rows show that varying the inverse temperature for FK-steering over a wide range yields the same accuracy values up to 2 decimal places. The paper does not explain why this is the case.
  4. Verifier Design: The verifier requires tuning based on the composition of questions in a dataset, and the paper doesn’t articulate the sensitivity to these values. For mathematical reasoning, GSM8K and MATH-500 get slightly different parameter values.
Questions for authors
  1. In the density mismatch graphs, could you share how the graphs were generated? Do all the points in the graph belong to a single question, or are they all generations for multiple different questions?
  2. “Figure 7 shows that the look-ahead signal becomes more informative as denoising progresses: AUROC rises from ≈ 0.50 at t/T=0.9 to ≈ 0.68 near termination”. However, Fig. 7 isn’t very clear. Would you be able to provide it as a table?
1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer dCQ4

Thank you for the careful review. We completed 168 new runs (LLaDA-8B-Instruct, four benchmarks, default point of Table 11, seeds 42–44, K=64\mathcal{K}=64). We name S3S^3 by its compute: S3S^3 (256 NFE) is the submitted setting, which uses Remark 2, not Algorithm 1. S3S^3 (505 NFE) is Algorithm 1 as written (see Reviewer EYwn, NFE).

W1. PG-DLM and PRISM. Both methods use test-time compute, but they spend it on different axes.

MethodSearch unitVerifierExtra cost
PG-DLM [1]Complete trajectories, refined over Gibbs iterationsTask rewardOne full pass for each iteration
PRISM [2]Partial trajectories, pruned on a scheduleYes/No self-verification by the DLMModel passes for each verification
S3S^3Partial trajectories, N→Nb→NN\to Nb\to N in one passRule-based score of x^0\hat{x}_0No model call

At B=8B=8, PG-DLM has one iteration, and its authors report that particles help more than iterations at low NFE. PRISM reports its LLaDA GSM8K result at 1,048 NFE, two times our largest budget. We did not run a matched comparison, and we will add this table to Section 5 with this limit.

W2. BoK. Your reading is correct, and our check found one more issue. The paper's BoK column used verifier arg-max, but Section 4.2 states majority vote.

We ran BoK again at equal NFE under both rules. BoK-4 is the first four samples of BoK-8. Values are accuracy (%), mean of three seeds, arg-max / majority vote. Each pp is from a question-level sign-flip test, and we call a gap significant when p<0.01p<0.01.

Table R1a. 256 NFE.

MethodMATH-500GSM8KARC-CTruthfulQA
BoK-427.07 / 28.6769.95 / 74.0077.16 / 84.5347.71 / 51.80
S3S^3 (256 NFE)28.47 / 29.0769.67 / 69.5777.39 / 80.2148.29 / 51.37
S3−BoKS^3-\mathrm{BoK}+1.40+1.40 / +0.40+0.40−0.28-0.28 / −4.43-4.43+0.23+0.23 / −4.32-4.32+0.58+0.58 / −0.43-0.43
pp0.18 / 0.720.69 / <0.001<0.0010.80 / <0.001<0.0010.64 / 0.71

Table R1b. About 512 NFE.

MethodMATH-500GSM8KARC-CTruthfulQA
BoK-827.40 / 30.5370.13 / 76.3278.07 / 86.5847.27 / 52.29
S3S^3 (505 NFE)28.27 / 28.1369.30 / 69.4778.38 / 81.9148.15 / 50.93
S3−BoKS^3-\mathrm{BoK}+0.87+0.87 / −2.40-2.40−0.83-0.83 / −6.85-6.85+0.31+0.31 / −4.67-4.67+0.88+0.88 / −1.36-1.36
pp0.42 / 0.0080.22 / <0.001<0.0010.70 / <0.001<0.0010.46 / 0.16

Baseline (single-trajectory decoding) gives 25.60, 68.16, 76.11, and 46.49. Both S3S^3 settings exceed Baseline on all four benchmarks under both rules.

At matched NFE, S3S^3 does not beat BoK. Under arg-max, no difference is significant. Under majority vote, BoK-8 leads on all four benchmarks, and the gaps on MATH-500, GSM8K, and ARC-C are significant. With Dream, Appendix G.2 already reports that the margins are not individually significant. We will remove the claim that S3S^3 outperforms BoK and report Tables R1a and R1b.

Also, the variant without branching (b=1b=1) is sometimes better than S3S^3 (see Reviewer AhDy, Table R4).

W3. Table 12. The stored seed-42 runs of FK-Steering+PRM at KFK=8K_{\mathrm{FK}}=8 change with λ\lambda (GSM8K 61.41 to 62.32 for λ∈{1,…,6}\lambda\in\{1,\dots,6\}). The updated Table 12 will report these values. The composite rows change little because the weights are near uniform (Table R3, response to Reviewer AhDy).

W4. Verifier sensitivity. We re-scored all stored S3S^3 (505 NFE) final frontiers under other weights with verifier arg-max.

BenchmarkDefaultEach weight ±50%\pm 50\% (30 draws)One component removedEqual weights
MATH-50028.2728.20–28.4027.87–28.4028.27
GSM8K69.2969.22–69.4069.02–69.4069.32
ARC-C78.3878.3877.79–78.3878.38
TruthfulQA48.1548.1548.05–48.2548.15

A ±50%\pm 50\% change moves accuracy by at most 0.13 pp. This test covers final selection only, not a complete search.

Q1. Figure 1. Each point is one generated response, which we embed and project to two dimensions. The points come from a subset of MATH-500 questions. They are not averages over the 500 problems. We will state this in the caption.

Q2. Figure 7 as a table. The source is one instrumented MATH-500 run (N=8N=8, b=2b=2).

t/Tt/T0.900.750.500.250.10
AUROC0.5760.6120.6200.7970.747
Spearman ρ\rho0.0940.1720.2490.4990.409

The look-ahead is weak early and informative late. We will report these values in Appendix E.1.

[1] Dang et al. PG-DLM. https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.08390

[2] Bai et al. PRISM. ICML 2026. https://proceedings.mlr.press/v306/bai26f.html

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.