acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Choose Before You Decode: Latent Q-Guided Generation for Diffusion Language Models

Abstract

Continuous latent diffusion language models generate an entire response by iteratively refining a continuous latent representation, yet existing samplers typically assign the same denoising budget to every trajectory. Consequently, test-time methods such as Best-of- must fully denoise and often decode every candidate before selection. We introduce Latent Q-Guided Generation (LQG), a value-guided inference framework that evaluates latent trajectories before denoising is complete. LQG formulates the reverse process as a finite-horizon Markov decision process with terminal text utility and trains a Transformer critic through temporal-difference policy evaluation of the frozen denoiser. At inference time, multiple trajectories are advanced to an intermediate decision step, where the critic identifies promising candidates and prunes the remainder. Across unconditional and conditional generation tasks, LQG consistently improves expected terminal utility under independently specified scorers while substantially reducing denoising and decoding costs relative to terminal-scored Best-of-. Ablations further establish the importance of cross-trajectory selection and local margin regularization, while revealing an early-horizon limit on reliable trajectory ranking. These results demonstrate that latent value estimation provides a principled mechanism for efficient test-time generation in latent diffusion language models.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Reinforcement learning, latent representations, latent diffusion language models, test-time decoding

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 25%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.75 over 4 reviews, above 25% of the others.
Reviewer_Y4ANOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces Latent Q-Guided Generation (LQG), a value-guided test time framework that evaluates latent trajectories before denoising is complete for continuous latent DLMs. The idea is that to predict the terminal utility of partially denoised latent trajectories and allow candidate selection before completing the entire denoising and decoding process. The method is evaluated across unconditional and conditional generation tasks and shows improvements in several different metrics.

Critical strengths
  1. Predicting terminal utility directly from intermediate latent representation is a good idea. The finite-horizon MDP formulation provides a natural interpretation of the critic as an estimator of expected future utility.
  2. The overall empirical results is promising for improving MAUVE and BERTScore on both unconditional and conditional tasks.
Critical weaknesses
  1. So one claim the LQG makes is that it can identify promising trajectories early and prune the remaining candidate for better efficiency. But the main result still use the full denoiser calls, not after the pruning. So the experiments show the effectiveness of the latent-based reranking but not early pruning (with similar quality). So there misses a quality-efficiency trade-off.
  2. The paper emphasizes the TD policy, but the ablation show that TD learning alone is slightly lower than base denoiser. Most of the performance improvement comes from the cross-trajectory selection and margin losses. So it is hard to see whether the improvements come from TD learning, stronger critic capacity or the additional ranking supervision.
Questions for authors

Please check the weakness above.

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Y4AN

We thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback. We provide the point-by-point response as follows.

W1

So one claim the LQG makes is that it can identify promising trajectories early and prune the remaining candidate for better efficiency. But the main result still use the full denoiser calls, not after the pruning. So the experiments show the effectiveness of the latent-based reranking but not early pruning (with similar quality). So there misses a quality-efficiency trade-off.

The revised Table 4 now reports the quality–efficiency trade-off of early pruning: pruning at step 48 reaches MAUVE 0.933 versus 0.780 for the single sample, and is 1.31× / 2.10× faster than terminal best-of-4 (Table R6).

  • Setting: ROCStories, N = 4, pruning at decision step 48 (Section 5.3).
  • Quality: pruning reaches 0.933, versus 0.780 for the single sample and 0.901 for the hard-argmax utility best-of-4.
  • Cost: pruning adds 6% / 18% time over the single sample at batch 1 / 16, and is 1.31× / 2.10× faster than best-of-4.
  • Other budgets: Figure R1b varies the number of candidates and the pruning step, showing the trade-off between quality and wall-clock time (for denoiser evaluations on the horizontal axis, see our response to F54q W2).
OperatorMAUVEBatch 1 (s/output)Batch 16 (s/output)
Pruning at step 480.93341.00700.2089
Terminal density-ratio best-of-4 (hard argmax)0.90071.31950.4394
Single sample0.78010.94740.1765

(Table R6 = revised Table 4: a separately trained TD critic, with the reward fitted on 5,000 training texts; MAUVE uses test texts 2,500–3,500 as the reference; timed on one RTX PRO 6000. Because the critic and the reference differ, absolute MAUVE values are not comparable with the other tables and figures.)

Figure R1b: held-out MAUVE vs. seconds per output

(Figure R1b: ROCStories. The vertical axis is held-out MAUVE and the horizontal axis is seconds per output (batch 16, one H200). Each LQG prune curve goes from early to late pruning steps h from left to right (the rightmost point is the last step); the star is the history-based readout over completed trajectories; best-of-N decodes all N candidates and selects with the true utility. Times of hollow markers are estimated from H200 measurements; N = 8 and 16 are linear extrapolations.)

W2

The paper emphasizes the TD policy, but the ablation show that TD learning alone is slightly lower than base denoiser. Most of the performance improvement comes from the cross-trajectory selection and margin losses. So it is hard to see whether the improvements come from TD learning, stronger critic capacity or the additional ranking supervision.

TD alone already improves over the base denoiser, removing TD from the full objective lowers MAUVE, and a capacity-matched latent-SL critic does not outperform LQG, so critic capacity alone does not explain the gains.

  • TD alone: the TD-only row of Table 2 (0.721) uses the history-based readout. With the terminal argmax readout, the same TD-only critic reaches 0.839, against 0.731 for the single sample (Table 1), so TD alone can rank trajectories (Table R2).
  • TD and ranking supervision: we trained TD+selection+margin and selection+margin without TD from scratch. Removing TD lowers held-out MAUVE from 0.886 to 0.850 with the history-based readout and from 0.879 to 0.850 with the terminal readout (Table R1; see our response to F54q W1). The ranking losses alone give the largest gain, and TD adds to it.
  • Critic capacity: we retrained the latent-SL critic as a nonlinear MLP with the same depth and width as the LQG critic (8 layers × width 256, GELU). It does not outperform LQG on either ROCStories or AG News (best on ROCStories 0.886 vs. 0.896 for LQG; best on AG News 0.776, the same as LQG; Table R3, see our response to F54q W1.1).

I thank the authors for the response. However, my concern about the role of TD learning remains. Overall, the responses addresses some of my concerns, but I will keep my current score.

Reviewer_UG8eOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper aims to guide generation in continuous diffusion language models. It trains a Q function to estimate the expected utility of the final output from intermediate latent states. During generation, the trained Q-function scores trajectories and can be used to decide which partial sample to continue denoising and which to prune.

Critical strengths
  1. The idea of estimating the final output quality using intermediate latents is practical and relevant; the learned Q function is a simple object and can support efficient test-time scaling.
  2. The presentation is neat and clear, well written, and easy to follow.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The loss function in the main text is not fully justified. Equation 7 is standard TD learning, but I believe Equation (8) is not standard, and it appears to be heuristic. What are the assumptions behind Equation 8, and do they always hold? How each loss term affects the training signal is not fully verified. Although Tables 2 and 3 show ablation results, they do not fully explain the gain of each term. Why is L-selection useful in Table 2 but only has a marginal effect in Table 3? Besides, in Tables 2 and 3, can you also include a comparison with the base model to isolate the gain of TD learning itself?
  2. How do the authors compare this method with process reward model training, and how do the authors compare this method with existing value-guided diffusion sampling? How does the proposed training differ from these approaches, and what is new in the method?
  3. For the experiments, since the authors mention that this method provides better test-time scaling, it would be good to see a scaling curve comparison, with the x-axis as compute and the y-axis as a metric; how does this method compare with techniques like best-of-n sampling?
Questions for authors

See Weaknesses

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer UG8e [1/2]

We thank the reviewer for the thoughtful comments and the helpful suggestions. We provide the point-by-point response as follows.

W1

The loss function in the main text is not fully justified. Equation 7 is standard TD learning, but I believe Equation (8) is not standard, and it appears to be heuristic. What are the assumptions behind Equation 8, and do they always hold? How each loss term affects the training signal is not fully verified. Although Tables 2 and 3 show ablation results, they do not fully explain the gain of each term. Why is L-selection useful in Table 2 but only has a marginal effect in Table 3? Besides, in Tables 2 and 3, can you also include a comparison with the base model to isolate the gain of TD learning itself?

Equation 8 is an empirical regularizer rather than a consequence of the Bellman equation; Table R2 shows the effect of each term, L_selection carries less signal on XSum, where candidates of the same source differ little in utility, and both ablation tables now include the single sample.

  • Assumption behind Equation 8, and whether it holds: Equation 8 assumes that, in a given state, the final utility reached from the denoiser's own clean-latent proposal is no lower than that reached from nearby perturbations, so the critic should not rank unobserved perturbed actions above the observed action. This is not guaranteed in general, so we present Equation 8 as an empirical regularizer and report its effect below.
  • How each term affects the training signal: the revised Table 2 reports both history-based and terminal selection, and we add three controls without TD (Table R2). With terminal selection, the TD-only critic already reaches MAUVE 0.839: the TD loss learns to judge how good the final latent is. History-based selection has to compare, under the last state, the actions from the last part of each trajectory; with TD alone these scores differ too little, the softmax is close to uniform, and MAUVE is only 0.721. Adding selection and margin teaches the critic to compare these actions under the same state, and MAUVE rises to 0.894. In Table R2, adding the margin term raises history-based MAUVE together with TD (0.873 → 0.894) but not without TD (0.869 → 0.842).
  • Why L_selection helps in Table 2 but only marginally in Table 3: the grouped variance analysis finds within-source utility variance shares of 11.9% on XSum and 13.1% on QQP, corresponding to about 88% and 87% between-source variation under that calculation. L_selection uses differences among candidates of the same source, so the relative strength of this signal differs from unconditional ROCStories. This is consistent with the task-dependent increments in the cumulative loss ablations.
  • Base model in Tables 2 and 3: both tables now include a single-sample row. On ROCStories, the single sample is 0.731 (Table 1), and the TD-only critic with the terminal readout reaches 0.839, so TD alone already exceeds the base model. Removing TD from the full objective lowers both readouts (see our response to F54q W1 and Table R1).
Training losshistory-based MAUVEhistory-based diversityterminal MAUVEterminal diversity
TD only0.72140.34970.83900.3240
TD + selection0.87300.35180.86360.3519
TD + selection + margin0.89350.35670.88500.3504
selection only0.86900.35020.86610.3503
margin only0.83180.32390.83760.3226
selection + margin0.84210.35490.83750.3551

(Table R2: ROCStories, Table 2 training configuration; the single sample in Table 1 is 0.731. The first three rows are the revised Table 2; the last three are the new controls without TD, reported in the bottom rows of Table 2 of the revision.)

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer UG8e [2/2]

W2

How do the authors compare this method with process reward model training, and how do the authors compare this method with existing value-guided diffusion sampling? How does the proposed training differ from these approaches, and what is new in the method?

Unlike process reward models, the critic is supervised only by the final outcome and operates on continuous latents; unlike value-guided diffusion sampling such as SVDD, LQG selects among independent trajectories with selection-oriented training and decodes no candidate before selection.

  • Process reward models: the critic is supervised by the final outcome. It regresses the expected utility of the final decoded text from intermediate latent states and needs no step-level annotation; it also operates on continuous latent states, so no intermediate text has to be decoded. A process reward model is instead trained to judge the correctness of intermediate reasoning steps in text.
  • Value-guided diffusion sampling: the most closely related prior work we found is SVDD (Li et al., 2024). SVDD branches several successors from the same parent at every denoising step and keeps one according to the value; LQG fixes N independent trajectories from N initial noises, and either prunes once at a chosen step and completes the surviving trajectory with the original sampler, or selects among completed trajectories by their late clean-latent proposals; no candidate is decoded before selection. For training, LQG's critic regresses the utility of the final decoded text with TD and adds the cross-candidate selection loss and the margin term, while SVDD-MC regresses the Monte Carlo return of a single trajectory. Our latent-SL baseline is a setting close to SVDD and, for a fair comparison, uses the same sampler as LQG (N = 4, T = 250).
  • What is new: the selection-oriented training and inference design for compressed language latents: cross-trajectory relative supervision and local proposal regularization, history aggregation of late proposals, and one-time pruning among independently initialized trajectories. This combines relative candidate supervision, proposal-history scoring and independent-trajectory pruning in a single latent-space selection method (see our response to F54q W1 and Q4).

If the reviewer is aware of other related work, please let us know and we will discuss it in the revision.

W3

For the experiments, since the authors mention that this method provides better test-time scaling, it would be good to see a scaling curve comparison, with the x-axis as compute and the y-axis as a metric; how does this method compare with techniques like best-of-n sampling?

Figure R1a gives the requested compute–quality curve and compares LQG with best-of-N at the same N; Tables R4 and R7 summarize the numbers.

  • Scaling curve: Figure R1a plots held-out MAUVE against denoiser evaluations per output on ROCStories. It varies the pruning step (h = 16 to the last step) and the number of candidates (N = 1–16), and compares against best-of-N that decodes every candidate and selects with the true utility at the same N. The version with wall-clock time on the horizontal axis is in our response to F54q W2 (Figure R1b).
  • Number of candidates: the history-based readout improves over the single sample and maintains MAUVE around 0.885–0.886 across N = 4, 8 and 16 (Table R7). We use N = 4 for its lower denoising cost at this quality level.
  • Comparison with best-of-N: Table R4 reports 0.896 vs. 0.894 for hard utility best-of-4, at 0.285 vs. 0.415 s per output. Figure R1a and Table R7 use a separately trained critic and show quality and compute across candidate budgets and pruning steps.

Figure R1a: held-out MAUVE vs. denoiser evaluations per output

(Figure R1a: ROCStories. The vertical axis is held-out MAUVE and the horizontal axis is denoiser evaluations per output. Each LQG prune curve goes from early to late pruning steps h from left to right (the rightmost point is the last step); the star is the history-based readout over completed trajectories; best-of-N decodes all N candidates and selects with the true utility.)

NDenoiser evaluations per outputheld-out MAUVEDiversitybatch 16 s/output
12500.7210.3520.16
41,0000.8850.3520.29
82,0000.8860.3530.45
164,0000.8860.3480.78

(Table R7: ROCStories, LQG history-based readout, same runs as Figure R1a. This curve uses a separately trained critic; Table R4 uses the critic of Tables R3–R5. Times for N = 8 and 16 are extrapolated from points measured on an H200.)

Thank the authors for additional experiments and a detailed response. Though many of my questions are answered, my major concern is that the main objective is heuristic/empirical, and it still remains. Therefore, I prefer to keep my current score.

Reviewer_Car3OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces LQG, a method that trains a critic to predict final text quality from latent diffusion states while keeping the generator frozen. The critic selects candidates before decoding and can prune trajectories during denoising to reduce computation. The paper evaluates their method on two unconditional and two conditional text generation tasks.

Critical strengths

The results on AG News and XSum show that the latent critic can improve candidate selection without changing the generator. The comparisons with other selection methods and the loss ablations also help explain the gains.

Critical weaknesses
  1. My main concern is whether early pruning keeps the quality gains shown in the main results. Appendix A.7 says that the main evaluation completes all four trajectories, while Remark 4 reports a 1.88× end-to-end speedup with early pruning. I could not find the quality results for that pruning setting. This makes it hard to tell whether the method achieves both benefits together, which is a main claim of the paper.

  2. The contribution over earlier value-learning methods is also unclear. SVDD already learns intermediate values with a frozen diffusion model and discusses Bellman-based training. LQG uses a critic for latent text generation, selection and margin losses, and a different pruning scheme.

Questions for authors
  1. Which task was used for the speedup in Remark 4? Could you give the quality and end-to-end time for that same pruning setting, alongside terminal Best-of-N?

  2. How do LQG’s critic training and pruning scheme differ from SVDD’s learned-value methods?

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Car3 [1/2]

We thank the reviewer for the careful reading and the helpful questions. We provide the point-by-point response as follows.

W1

My main concern is whether early pruning keeps the quality gains shown in the main results. Appendix A.7 says that the main evaluation completes all four trajectories, while Remark 4 reports a 1.88× end-to-end speedup with early pruning. I could not find the quality results for that pruning setting. This makes it hard to tell whether the method achieves both benefits together, which is a main claim of the paper.

Early pruning keeps the quality gain: in the revised Table 4, pruning at step 48 reaches MAUVE 0.933 versus 0.780 for the single sample, and is 1.31× / 2.10× faster than terminal best-of-4 (Table R6).

  • Setting: ROCStories, N = 4, pruning at decision step 48 (Section 5.3), which is the operator described in Appendix A.4.
  • Quality: pruning reaches 0.933, versus 0.780 for the single sample and 0.901 for the hard-argmax utility best-of-4.
  • Cost: pruning adds 6% / 18% time over the single sample at batch 1 / 16, and is 1.31× / 2.10× faster than best-of-4.
  • Other budgets: Figure R1b varies the number of candidates and the pruning step and shows quality against wall-clock time per output (for denoiser evaluations on the horizontal axis, see our response to F54q W2).
OperatorMAUVEBatch 1 (s/output)Batch 16 (s/output)
Pruning at step 480.93341.00700.2089
Terminal density-ratio best-of-4 (hard argmax)0.90071.31950.4394
Single sample0.78010.94740.1765

(Table R6 = revised Table 4: a separately trained TD critic, with the reward fitted on 5,000 training texts; MAUVE uses test texts 2,500–3,500 as the reference; timed on one RTX PRO 6000. Because the critic and the reference differ, absolute MAUVE values are not comparable with the other tables and figures.)

Figure R1b: held-out MAUVE vs. seconds per output

(Figure R1b: ROCStories. The vertical axis is held-out MAUVE and the horizontal axis is seconds per output (batch 16, one H200). Each LQG prune curve goes from early to late pruning steps h from left to right (the rightmost point is the last step); the star is the history-based readout over completed trajectories; best-of-N decodes all N candidates and selects with the true utility. Times of hollow markers are estimated from H200 measurements; N = 8 and 16 are linear extrapolations.)

W2

The contribution over earlier value-learning methods is also unclear. SVDD already learns intermediate values with a frozen diffusion model and discusses Bellman-based training. LQG uses a critic for latent text generation, selection and margin losses, and a different pruning scheme.

LQG differs from SVDD in how candidates are formed and pruned and in its selection-oriented critic training; our latent-SL baseline is an SVDD-like setting under the same sampler settings.

  • Candidates and pruning: SVDD (Li et al., 2024) branches several successors from the same parent at every denoising step and keeps one according to the value. LQG fixes N independent trajectories from N initial noises, and either prunes once at a chosen step and completes the surviving trajectory with the original sampler, or selects among completed trajectories by aggregating their late clean-latent proposal scores.
  • Training: the selection-oriented training combines terminal-utility regression, cross-trajectory relative supervision, and local proposal-margin regularization (details in Q2).
  • Contribution: these training, history-readout and pruning choices define the method's contribution in compressed language latents. Both LQG readouts select before decoding and decode only one output.
  • SVDD-like baseline: our latent-SL baseline is a setting close to SVDD: its value is trained by Monte Carlo regression on the terminal utility, as in SVDD-MC. For a fair comparison, latent-SL and LQG use the same sampler settings (the same frozen DDPM sampler, N = 4 candidates, T = 250 denoising steps). The revision also cites SVDD.

Q1

Which task was used for the speedup in Remark 4? Could you give the quality and end-to-end time for that same pruning setting, alongside terminal Best-of-N?

The task is ROCStories, and the revised Table 4 reports the quality and end-to-end time of that pruning setting alongside terminal best-of-4 (Table R6). In the revision, Remark 2 (Remark 4 in the submission) reports the number of denoiser evaluations (397 vs. 1,000), and Table 4 shows that pruning at step 48 reaches MAUVE 0.933, versus 0.901 for terminal best-of-4 scored on the decoded text, while being 1.31× faster at batch 1 and 2.10× faster at batch 16 (see W1).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Car3 [2/2]

Q2

How do LQG’s critic training and pruning scheme differ from SVDD’s learned-value methods?

LQG trains a state–action critic with TD plus cross-candidate selection and margin terms, and prunes once among independent trajectories; SVDD-MC regresses single-trajectory returns from the state, and SVDD selects among successors at every step.

  • Critic training: LQG's critic is trained offline on trajectories generated by the frozen sampler, and its inputs are the noisy state and the denoiser's clean-latent proposal (state–action). Its target is the utility of the final decoded text, propagated along the trajectory with TD. Two further terms are added: the selection loss compares several candidate trajectories generated from the same input, so that the critic's scores can rank the candidates, and the margin term makes the critic score the denoiser's actual proposals above their perturbations. SVDD-MC instead regresses the Monte Carlo return of a single trajectory, with only the state as input and no cross-candidate loss.
  • Pruning: SVDD selects among several successors of the same parent at every step; LQG keeps N independent trajectories, scores them once at a chosen step, and completes the best one with the original sampler; no candidate is decoded before selection.

Thank you for the additional experiments and the detailed response. They addressed some of my concerns. Learning intermediate values to guide a frozen diffusion model is already part of SVDD. LQG’s latent scoring, ranking losses and pruning rule are useful, but I still feel that this is a limited advance over this idea. Therefore, I maintain my initial score.

Reviewer_F54qOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes Latent Q-Guided Generation (LQG), a test-time selection method for continuous latent diffusion language models (LDLMs). In these models, text is encoded by the encoder of a frozen pretrained encoder–decoder model and compressed by a learned autoencoder into a fixed set of continuous vectors. A diffusion model then learns to generate such vectors. LQG treats the denoising chain of such a frozen diffusion model as a finite-horizon Markov decision process (MDP): the state is the current noisy latent, the action is the denoiser's clean-latent prediction, and the reward is a utility estimated on the final decoded text. A transformer critic is trained on a fixed buffer of rollouts with a temporal-difference (TD) loss that evaluates the denoiser's own actions. Two further loss terms are added: a regularizing "margin loss" that favors the denoiser's prediction over nearby perturbations, and a xent-style "ranking loss" to incentivize selection of the best trajectory among a given group of trajectories. At inference, the critic ranks four trajectories and only the winner is decoded, with optional pruning partway through denoising.

They test the method on unconditional generation (ROCStories and AG News datasets) via a reward based on clustered GPT-2 features, and on conditional generation (XSum and QQP datasets) via a ROUGE-based reward. The evidence is a comparison against two families of baselines:

  • an MLP critic trained by Monte Carlo regression and used to pick the best finished trajectory, to prune trajectories during denoising, or to resample them periodically;
  • trajectory selection methods from autoregressive LLM literature.
Critical strengths
  1. The method and evaluation protocol are clear and controlled. All methods share the denoiser, autoencoder and decoder (and, on the unconditional tasks, the same candidate pools), results are averaged over three seeds, and the ports of external baselines are well documented.
  2. The loss ablation is useful. On ROCStories, the TD loss alone is no better than random selection, whereas the ranking loss brings clear gains, showing that latent-based trajectory selection algorithms can improve quality in LDLMs.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The evidence is insufficient to identify what the TD loss and RL formulation are contributing; what remains from the method, namely, ranking latent trajectories with a learned critic, is well established in the literature:

    • According to Tables 2 and 3, a TD-only critic performs no better than random, and instead the gains over the baseline come from the ranking and margin losses. Furthermore, only two tasks are ablated. Finally, LQG does not clearly beat the other latent-based trajectory selection baselines (like latent-SL, despite using a much smaller MLP critic).
    • Missing basic baselines: Best-of-N with the true utility, and LD4LG's own selection rule; additionally, TrajSelector sits at a different quality–diversity point.
    • The training reward is built directly from the evaluation metrics, and it seems that the ROCStories reference samples used during training are also used to compute MAUVE in the final evaluation tables.
  2. Despite the emphasis on efficiency and pruning, the experiments do not use pruning, and quality is never studied as a function of compute.

    • Every reported LQG result denoises all four trajectories to the end, making no use of pruning.
    • No test-time setting (number of trajectories, steps, pruning step, temperature) is ablated, so quality is never compared across test-time compute budgets or quality-diversity frontiers.
    • Sections contradict each other on what was run, e.g., App. A.4 says deployment prunes, while App. A.7 says LQG completes every trajectory.
Questions for authors
  1. What is the hierarchical selection rule, what are W, M and β, and what role do they play?
  2. Which configuration produced Table 1: the pruned deployment of App. A.4 or the full trajectories of App. A.7? Could you also reconcile App. A.7 with Table 5, and Table 2's final row with Table 1's LQG row?
  3. Why is pruning absent from the main results, and why is it not ablated together with the other test-time compute settings (number of trajectories, denoising steps, pruning step)? More generally, sampling ablations (e.g., temperature or guidance) that control for compute and diversity would be needed to support the efficiency claims.
  4. How does LQG differ from SVDD's value-based selection combined with Controlled Decoding's TD-trained values?
  5. Are the 500 texts behind the ROCStories reward part of the MAUVE references? Which references does the AG News reward use, and why are the test splits not used?

Experiments that could change my assessment:

  • Best-of-N scored with the true utility, LD4LG's selection rule, and the same transformer trained by Monte Carlo regression with the same auxiliary losses, compared at matched compute and diversity.

Suggestions for future work (do not affect my assessment):

  • A task with a verifiable reward, scaling in the number of trajectories, and a quality judgment independent of the reward.
8 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer F54q [1/7]

We thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback and the insightful suggestions. We provide the point-by-point response as follows.

W1

The evidence is insufficient to identify what the TD loss and RL formulation are contributing; what remains from the method, namely, ranking latent trajectories with a learned critic, is well established in the literature.

TD contributes beyond the ranking losses: removing it from the full objective lowers held-out MAUVE under both readouts (Table R1). Beyond ranking with a critic, the method contributes a selection-oriented critic and readout design for compressed language latents.

Contribution of TD: To isolate TD's contribution within the full objective, we trained (1) TD+selection+margin and (2) selection+margin without TD from scratch. We report two readouts below: the history-based readout (defined in Q1) and the terminal argmax readout, which keeps the candidate whose final latent the critic scores highest.

ReadoutReferenceTD+selection+marginselection+marginDifference
history-basedheld-out0.8860.850+0.036
terminal argmaxheld-out0.8790.850+0.029

(Table R1: ROCStories; both critics retrained from scratch. The held-out reference does not overlap with the reward texts (see W1.3).)

Removing TD lowers held-out MAUVE from 0.886 to 0.850 with the history-based readout and from 0.879 to 0.850 with the terminal argmax readout. This supports a contribution of TD in this ablation; the comparison with Monte Carlo regression is reported in S1.

Contribution of the method:

  • Training: the cross-trajectory selection loss supplies relative supervision among competing candidates, and the margin term regularizes local proposal scores.
  • Readouts: the history-based readout aggregates the scores of late clean-latent proposals. Both readouts select in latent space and decode only the selected output.
  • Pruning: the early-pruning operator scores N independently initialized trajectories once, keeps one, and completes it with the frozen sampler. This differs from SVDD's repeated selection among successors of the same parent at every step (Q4).

Together, these training and inference choices enable selection and pruning in compressed language latents before decoding (Q4, S1).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer F54q [2/7]

W1.1

According to Tables 2 and 3, a TD-only critic performs no better than random, and instead the gains over the baseline come from the ranking and margin losses. Furthermore, only two tasks are ablated. Finally, LQG does not clearly beat the other latent-based trajectory selection baselines (like latent-SL, despite using a much smaller MLP critic).

TD and the ranking losses are complementary (Table R2), and a latent-SL critic with the same depth and width as LQG's does not outperform LQG (Table R3).

  • TD alone already ranks well: with the terminal readout, the TD-only critic reaches 0.839 MAUVE (single sample 0.731): the TD loss learns to judge how good the final latent is. The history-based readout instead compares, under the last state, the actions from the last part of each trajectory; with TD alone these scores differ too little, the softmax is close to uniform, and MAUVE is only 0.721. Adding selection and margin teaches the critic to compare these actions under the same state, and MAUVE rises to 0.894. Removing TD lowers both readouts (W1).
  • Latent-SL: the latent-SL critic in the original Table 1 is a four-layer linear network; the revision states this. We also retrained it as a nonlinear MLP with the same depth and width as the LQG critic (8 layers × width 256, GELU). On AG News, LQG outperforms the original latent-SL under all three operators (0.776 vs. 0.662 / 0.761 / 0.762 for BoN / PSP / FK), and the nonlinear control reaches 0.739 / 0.750 / 0.776, matching LQG at its best operator. On ROCStories its best result is 0.886, versus 0.896 for LQG.
  • Coverage of the ablations: the loss ablations cover ROCStories and XSum, representing unconditional and conditional generation. Table R2 adds selection-only, margin-only and selection+margin controls alongside the TD-based objectives.
Training losshistory-based MAUVEhistory-based diversityterminal MAUVEterminal diversity
TD only0.72140.34970.83900.3240
TD + selection0.87300.35180.86360.3519
TD + selection + margin0.89350.35670.88500.3504
selection only0.86900.35020.86610.3503
margin only0.83180.32390.83760.3226
selection + margin0.84210.35490.83750.3551

(Table R2: ROCStories; the single sample in Table 1 is 0.731. The first three rows are the revised Table 2; the last three are the new controls without TD, reported in the bottom rows of Table 2 of the revision.)

TaskMethodheld-out MAUVEDiversity
ROCStoriessingle sample0.7210.352
ROCStoriesLQG (history-based)0.8960.348
ROCStorieslatent-SL linear: BoN / PSP / FK0.885 / 0.871 / 0.8690.336 / 0.344 / 0.335
ROCStorieslatent-SL same depth and width, GELU: BoN / PSP / FK0.886 / 0.850 / 0.8530.343 / 0.345 / 0.345
AG Newssingle sample0.7550.522
AG NewsLQG (history-based)0.7760.527
AG Newslatent-SL linear: BoN / PSP / FK0.662 / 0.761 / 0.7620.554 / 0.523 / 0.536
AG Newslatent-SL same depth and width, GELU: BoN / PSP / FK0.739 / 0.750 / 0.7760.564 / 0.527 / 0.546

(Table R3: the held-out references are the first 1,000 texts of the ROCStories and AG News test splits. LQG uses the same critic in Tables R3–R5.)

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer F54q [3/7]

W1.2

Missing basic baselines: Best-of-N with the true utility, and LD4LG's own selection rule; additionally, TrajSelector sits at a different quality–diversity point.

We add both baselines: LQG matches best-of-4 with the true utility without decoding the candidates, and it is faster than both best-of-4 and LD4LG's MBR selection (Tables R4 and R4b).

  • Best-of-N with the true utility: on the same candidate pools, best-of-4 decodes four candidates, scores each with the true utility and keeps the highest, whereas LQG selects before decoding. LQG matches it on ROCStories (0.896 vs. 0.894) and exceeds it on AG News (0.776 vs. 0.548), and is faster at batch 16 (0.285 vs. 0.415 and 0.283 vs. 0.399 s per output; Table R4).
TaskMethodheld-out MAUVEbatch 16 (s/output)batch 1 (s/output)
ROCStoriessingle sample0.7210.1631.674
ROCStoriesLQG (history-based)0.8960.2851.726
ROCStoriesbest-of-4 with true utility0.8940.4151.858
AG Newssingle sample0.7550.1611.581
AG NewsLQG (history-based)0.7760.2831.644
AG Newsbest-of-4 with true utility0.5480.3991.763

(Table R4: LQG uses the same critic in Tables R3–R5; MAUVE uses the non-overlapping held-out reference; times are seconds per output on one H200.)

  • LD4LG's selection rule (MBR): we add LD4LG-style MBR-4 on XSum and QQP, using ROUGE-2 consensus among the same four decoded candidates, without a gold reference. LQG selects in latent space and decodes one output, which reduces decoding and selection cost: at batch 16 it takes 0.796 vs. 0.891 s per output on XSum and 0.636 vs. 0.659 on QQP (Table R4b). Best-of-4 scored with the training utility is also included; for these conditional tasks it uses the evaluation gold reference and is labeled as an oracle diagnostic.
TaskMethodROUGE-1 / ROUGE-2 / ROUGE-L / BERTScorebatch 16 (s/output)batch 1 (s/output)
XSumsingle sample37.91 / 15.41 / 30.46 / 42.160.3714.191
XSumLQG (history-based)37.94 / 15.28 / 30.50 / 42.100.7964.381
XSumMBR-438.46 / 15.88 / 31.02 / 42.960.8914.431
XSumutility best-of-4 (gold-reference oracle)42.79 / 19.13 / 34.73 / 44.800.8944.434
QQPsingle sample63.96 / 40.31 / 61.30 / 68.850.3104.196
QQPLQG (history-based)64.00 / 40.52 / 61.38 / 69.000.6364.369
QQPMBR-464.45 / 40.96 / 61.78 / 69.250.6594.384
QQPutility best-of-4 (gold-reference oracle)68.13 / 46.06 / 65.49 / 71.720.6614.403

(Table R4b: all text-quality scores multiplied by 100. Times average three timing runs, each using the median of three warmed repetitions. End-to-end time includes source encoding, denoising, critic scoring where applicable, decoding, and MBR or utility selection; one H200. Model loading and offline evaluation are excluded. MBR and oracle best-of-4 decode four candidates; LQG decodes one.)

  • TrajSelector: unconditional generation aims to match the data distribution, which is what MAUVE measures; diversity helps only while the outputs still match that distribution. In Table 1, TrajSelector increases diversity, but its MAUVE falls below the single sample (ROCStories 0.634 vs. 0.731; AG News 0.768 vs. 0.892), which indicates that its outputs move away from the data distribution. LQG keeps the single-sample diversity (ROCStories 0.348 vs. 0.352) while raising MAUVE.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response

Dear Reviewers,

We thank all reviewers for their careful reading and constructive feedback. The reviewers' main concerns were whether early pruning preserves the quality gains, what TD learning contributes beyond the ranking losses, missing baselines, and the overlap between the reward and the evaluation references. We summarize the key additions in the revision below; changes in the revised paper are marked in blue, and detailed answers are in the individual responses.

1. Early pruning and quality–compute trade-offs are now evaluated (Car3 W1, Y4AN W1, F54q W2/Q3, UG8e W3).

  • Table 4 (new): on ROCStories with N = 4, pruning at decision step 48 reaches MAUVE 0.933, versus 0.780 for the single sample and 0.901 for terminal best-of-4 with the true utility, while being 1.31× / 2.10× faster than best-of-4 at batch 1 / 16.
  • Figure 3 (new, Appendix A.13): quality against denoiser evaluations and wall-clock time, and diversity, for N = 1–16 candidates and pruning steps from h = 16 to the last step, with best-of-N as reference.

2. The contribution of TD is isolated (F54q W1/W1.1/S1, UG8e W1, Y4AN W2).

  • Controls without TD (Table 2): removing TD from the full objective lowers MAUVE under both readouts (0.894 / 0.885 → 0.842 / 0.838), and TD alone already ranks well with the terminal readout (0.839 vs. 0.731 for the single sample).
  • Monte Carlo regression (Table 9): the same transformer, data, auxiliary losses and number of updates, with only the regression target changed from TD to Monte Carlo.
  • Critic capacity: a nonlinear latent-SL critic with the same depth and width as LQG's does not outperform LQG (ROCStories 0.886 vs. 0.896).

3. New baselines and held-out evaluation (F54q W1.2/W1.3/Q5/S1).

  • Best-of-4 with the true utility: LQG matches it on ROCStories (0.896 vs. 0.894) and exceeds it on AG News (0.776 vs. 0.548) without decoding the candidates, and is faster (0.285 vs. 0.415 s per output at batch 16).
  • LD4LG's MBR selection: LQG selects before decoding and decodes one output, with lower end-to-end time on XSum and QQP.
  • Held-out references (Appendix A.11): MAUVE against the first 1,000 texts of the ROCStories and AG News test splits, which contain none of the 500 reward-fitting texts; LQG improves over the single sample on both tasks (ROCStories 0.721 → 0.896, AG News 0.755 → 0.776).

4. Clarifications of the method and its positioning (F54q Q1/Q2/W2.3/Q4, Car3 W2/Q2, UG8e W1/W2).

  • Operators: Table 1 uses history-based selection over completed trajectories without pruning; Appendix A.4 now describes the pruning variant evaluated in Table 4; the selection rule and its parameters W, M and β_hist are specified in Equation (12).
  • Objective: Equation 8 is presented as an empirical regularizer with its assumption stated.
  • Related work: the revision discusses and cites SVDD and states the latent-SL architecture; the individual responses also contrast LQG with Controlled Decoding and process reward models.

In summary, the revision adds the missing pruning and compute–quality evidence, isolates the role of TD, adds the requested baselines and held-out evaluation, and clarifies the operators and their relation to prior work.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.