- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SpikeEEG-3D, an SNN framework for reconstructing colored 3D point clouds from EEG signals. The model uses LD-LIF neurons to learn adaptive neuronal dynamics, Event-Enhanced Cross-Attention (EECA) to fuse static and dynamic EEG representations, and SpikeBit neurons to reduce quantization errors during 3D reconstruction.
Experiments on EEG-3D show improvements in classification accuracy, several reconstruction metrics, and estimated energy efficiency compared with existing methods.
Critical strengths
1.The paper explores EEG-based 3D reconstruction, a challenging and relatively underexplored application for spiking neural networks. The proposed framework covers both EEG representation learning and point-cloud generation, making it a meaningful attempt to extend SNNs to this task.
2.LD-LIF, EECA, and SpikeBit address different challenges in EEG representation learning and reconstruction. The ablation studies support their effectiveness, particularly the improvement brought by SpikeBit over conventional LIF neurons.
Critical weaknesses
1.The decoder also uses predicted object categories, and the encoder is trained with CLIP-based visual supervision. While these choices are reasonable, the paper does not clearly establish how much of the reconstruction quality comes from EEG-specific information rather than category priors or the generative decoder. A shuffled-EEG or category-only baseline would help clarify this important point.
- In Table 2, SpikeEEG-3D improves semantic accuracy and SSIM over Neuro-3D, but its Chamfer Distance and F1 scores are worse, indicating weaker geometric fidelity. Furthermore, the energy savings are based on analytical operation-level estimates rather than actual hardware measurements. These limitations weaken the claims of superior reconstruction quality and practical efficiency.
Questions for authors
1.Can the authors clarify how much of the 3D reconstruction performance comes from EEG-specific information rather than category priors? Are shuffled-EEG or category-only results available?
2.How do the authors explain the worse Chamfer Distance and F1 scores compared with Neuro-3D? How well do the estimated energy savings reflect practical hardware performance?
4 comments
Response to Reviewer CCTd Part (2/2)
W2: The reconstruction and efficiency improvements are not fully convincing. In Table 2, SpikeEEG-3D improves semantic accuracy and SSIM over Neuro-3D, but its Chamfer Distance and F1 scores are worse, indicating weaker geometric fidelity. Furthermore, the energy savings are based on analytical operation-level estimates rather than actual hardware measurements. These limitations weaken the claims of superior reconstruction quality and practical efficiency.
Q2: How do the authors explain the worse Chamfer Distance and F1 scores compared with Neuro-3D? How well do the estimated energy savings reflect practical hardware performance?
Response to W2 & Q2: Thank you for this valuable question. We acknowledge that our CD and F1 are slightly worse than those of Neuro-3D. Nevertheless, SpikeEEG-3D achieves comparable geometric reconstruction quality, while obtaining higher semantic reconstruction accuracy and SSIM with substantially lower estimated energy consumption. Our primary objective is to achieve competitive reconstruction quality with higher energy efficiency.
Regarding energy efficiency, we provide a more comprehensive analysis that better accounts for practical implementation costs. Following SpikedAttention [1], we incorporate memory access, neuronal state updates, and output write-back costs to estimate System-Level Energy. The results are presented below.
Energy comparison for EEG classification.
| Method | Computation-Level Energy (mJ) | System-Level Energy (mJ) |
|---|---|---|
| DeepNet | 0.241 | 0.768 |
| EEGNetv4 | 0.133 | 0.425 |
| TSConv | 0.306 | 0.982 |
| EEG Conformer | 0.643 | 2.052 |
| ShallowFBCSPNet | 0.236 | 0.752 |
| Neuro-3D | 2.304 | 7.327 |
| BrainAlign | 1.472 | 4.672 |
| SpikeEEG-3D | 0.111 | 0.490 |
Energy comparison for 3D reconstruction.
| Method | Computation-Level Energy (J) | System-Level Energy (J) |
|---|---|---|
| Neuro-3D | 327.798 | 1040.640 |
| SpikeEEG-3D w/ LIF-T4 | 110.415 | 497.490 |
| SpikeEEG-3D w/ LIF-T8 | 173.406 | 705.170 |
| SpikeEEG-3D w/ SpikeBit-B4 | 102.098 | 481.529 |
| SpikeEEG-3D w/ SpikeBit-B8 | 105.609 | 512.720 |
Under the System-Level Energy evaluation, SpikeEEG-3D retains 14.95× and 2.03× higher estimated energy efficiency than Neuro-3D in EEG classification and 3D reconstruction, respectively. These findings further confirm that our method preserves considerable energy-efficiency advantages even under a more comprehensive energy evaluation. We include both energy estimates in Tables 1 and 2 of the revised manuscript and further clarify these energy comparisons.
We sincerely look forward to further discussion to clarify any other concerns. If you have additional suggestions, we are committed to addressing them and continuously improving our work based on your feedback.
[1] Hwang S, Lee S, Park D, et al. Spikedattention: Training-free and fully spike-driven transformer-to-snn conversion with winner-oriented spike shift for softmax operation[J]. Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, 2024, 37: 67422-67445.
Dear reviewer, I'm sorry to bother you.We hope the above clarifications and the additional experiments in the revised draft sufficiently addressed your concerns. We remain committed to addressing any remaining points you may have during the discussion phase.
I appreciate the authors' thoughtful response and additional clarifications, which have resolved some of my concerns. As I acknowledge these improvements, I will keep my original rating unchanged.
Response to Reviewer CCTd Part (1/2)
Dear Reviewer CCTd:
We sincerely thank you for your positive feedback and valuable suggestions on our work! We appreciate your recognition of the interesting application of SNNs to EEG-based 3D reconstruction and the effectiveness of our architectural designs. We are pleased to clarify and answer the questions and provide some additional experimental results.
Response to W1 & Q1: Thank you for your constructive comment. To assess whether 3D reconstruction genuinely benefits from EEG-specific information beyond category priors and the generative decoder, we conduct two additional control experiments: EEG Shuffling, where EEG features are randomly shuffled across test samples while keeping the predicted categories unchanged, and Category-only, where the decoder relies solely on predicted categories without EEG features. The results are presented below.
Both EEG Shuffling and Category-only lead to performance degradation across all five reconstruction metrics. These results demonstrate that EEG-specific information makes a meaningful contribution to 3D reconstruction beyond category priors and learned generative priors.
We include these additional experiments in Appendix A.7 of the revised manuscript.