- Rating
- 2(−1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes SAR-DiSCO, which optimizes target-surface scattering coefficients through a differentiable SAR renderer while keeping geometry fixed. Experiments on simulated vehicle data report an average view-specific fooling rate of 88.96% across five classifiers, alongside cross-model transfer and shared multi-view evaluations.
Critical strengths
Treating surface scattering coefficients as learnable parameters connects adversarial optimization to target-level changes rather than image pixels alone. This allows classification gradients to directly update the simulated surface response while preserving target geometry.
Critical weaknesses
The paper acknowledges that physical realizability remains unverified, but does not establish how the optimized coefficients could be implemented on real targets. Their sensitivity to imperfect material control is also unexplored. This limits the practical significance of the results beyond the adopted simulator.
Questions for authors
-
The experiments remain simulation-based, without a demonstrated way to realize the optimized surface coefficients physically. Precisely controlling these coefficients on a real target would be difficult, yet attack effectiveness under coefficient fluctuations or implementation errors is not evaluated.
-
The evaluation covers only five classification architectures. the limited model coverage leaves the generality of the attack insufficiently established.
-
The External setting does not clearly specify whether the component’s coefficients are optimized independently for each view or shared across multiple views.
-
In Table 2, Multi-view achieves a higher fooling rate than View-specific on Bus (54.17% versus 42.78%), unlike the other categories. why?
-
The paper states that a common ground background is included, but Figures 2, 4, and 7 do not clearly show how background returns contribute to the classifier inputs. The evaluation does not establish attack effectiveness in more realistic scenes containing varied backgrounds and clutter.
Response to Reviewer Zefw
We thank the reviewer for recognizing the value of optimizing target-surface scattering coefficients and for the constructive feedback on physical implementation and evaluation. We have uploaded a revised manuscript with changes highlighted in red. We address the five questions below.
Q1. Physical realization and sensitivity to coefficient errors
Physical realization. SAR-DiSCO optimizes effective surface-scattering coefficients. Physically realizing them requires mapping the optimized values to material or component parameters and calibrating their scattering responses. This mapping and a physical demonstration have not yet been established. Our External experiment offers a potential direction for localized implementation, achieving 47.11% mean FR by optimizing only an attached component’s coefficients within the simulator.
Sensitivity to coefficient errors. We added an experiment that perturbs saved adversarial coefficients without re-optimization,
t=clip(tadv+ϵ,0,1),ϵv∼U(−δ,δ).
Errors are applied independently to the effective third coefficient channel. We re-render all 1,800 test samples per classifier while keeping the geometry, background, observation configurations, and classifier fixed. The resulting FR (%) is reported below and in Section 4.6 and Appendix I (Table 10).
Mean FR remains 83.86% at δ=0.01, compared with 88.96% without errors, and decreases to 32.72% at δ=0.1. Thus, the attacks retain substantial effectiveness under the smallest tested nonzero error bound, while larger deviations reduce their effectiveness. These results measure coefficient sensitivity within the simulator; interpreting δ as a physical manufacturing tolerance requires material-specific calibration.
Q2. Architecture coverage and cross-model transfer
Our evaluation covers three CNNs (ResNet-50, VGG-16, and EfficientNetV2-S) and two Transformers (ViT-B/16 and Swin-V2-S). SAR-DiSCO achieves FRs of 77.22%–94.22%, averaging 88.96% (Table 1). Figure 3 further reports all 20 cross-model transfer combinations, with FRs of 36.44%–67.39% without accessing target-model parameters or gradients or re-optimizing the attacks. These results demonstrate effectiveness across the tested architectures and transferability beyond the model used for optimization.
Q3. Shared or view-specific coefficients in External
In the External setting, one component coefficient field is shared and jointly optimized across multiple views of each target. Only these shared coefficients are updated; the target body’s coefficients and the assembled geometry remain fixed. We have clarified this protocol in Section 4.4 and Appendix G.
Q4. Why Multi-view performs better on Bus
In Multi-view, an update from one view also affects the attack on other views. Some updates may benefit several views, while others may improve one view at the expense of another. For Bus, where view-specific optimization is less effective, joint updates may help find a more effective coefficient configuration. For the other four categories, sharing coefficients may instead limit adjustments tailored to individual views. This offers a possible explanation for the differences across categories, although the reported results do not establish the specific cause of the improvement on Bus.
Q5. Ground returns, varied backgrounds, and clutter
The SAR images used for classifier evaluation include ground returns. Both the ground and target participate in ray intersections, and their returns are accumulated on the same imaging grid to form the classifier inputs. Ground parameters remain fixed during attacks; only the target or attached component’s scattering coefficients are optimized. We have clarified this in Section 4.1. Using a common background provides consistent scene conditions for comparing methods. The current evaluation does not cover varied backgrounds and complex clutter, so effectiveness in those settings remains to be assessed separately.