- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper address a question of whether, when pricing agents are arranged by the platform to meet each other, the platform choice that decides which one faces other one matters in terms of deciding what agents may learn. The paper proposes a wide range of predictions and hypothesis, and through experiments it shows that nuanced results of punishment and price decision in pricing agents' behaviors.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
The foremost issue is: this manuscript is very hard to read, and is a disservice to reader. The writing contains a lot of internal "lab process" that should not appear in a paper: To name a few, a huge number of labeled predictions and hypotheses, "registered", "post hoc". More extreme examples like "A simulated review of an earlier draft raised three objections", "An earlier version of this paragraph reported" are never something one should expect from a scientific paper. It's honest to show the AI usage (which suggest the writing heavily AI authored), but it is a quality problem to leave all such log level lab notes in a writing and expect a reader can extract what may be useful. Transparency is not a substitute for authoring a sounding writing.
The manuscript in its current form significantly makes it hard to assess the quality, and such an unpolished form merits a rejection on its own.
Questions for authors
None
Response to Reviewer YW6a
Thank you for the direct review. You are right. The main text read like a lab notebook, with prediction labels, the history of the analyses, and sentences like "an earlier version of this paragraph reported". None of this helps a reader judge the work.
We rewrote the main text around one line of argument: the question, the design, the main result, the case where punishment is impossible, and what follows from it. Sentences of that kind are gone from the paper. We kept one distinction: the four registered tests versus everything else. A reader needs it to judge the evidence, so we state the rule once, in Section 4. "Post hoc" and the prediction labels are gone from the main text. "Registered" appears only where it tells the reader what we fixed in advance. The pre-registration record and the dated list of deviations are in an appendix, for readers who want to audit the study.
We uploaded the revised PDF. We would be grateful if you could read it and tell us whether it is now possible to judge the work.