acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Skill Withdrawal in Self-Evolving Language Agents: A Causal Study of Non-Parametric Deskilling and Structural Dependency

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Large language model agents can acquire reusable behaviors without parameter updates by accumulating executable skills and persistent external state. Existing evaluations primarily measure performance while these resources remain available, so the effect of prolonged skill use on subsequent autonomous problem solving after skill withdrawal remains unclear. We define non-parametric deskilling as a counterfactual withdrawal gap: under an identical skill-free interface, a skill-exposed agent performs worse than a matched agent that has never received high-level skills, although both use the same frozen model, initial capability, task distribution, atomic tools, and evaluation budgets. We introduce a randomized longitudinal protocol with never-skilled, yoked-experience, information-matched, compute-matched, and state-reset controls to separate persistent behavioral changes from the immediate loss of external procedures, information, or computation. Versioned interventions on experience memory, retrieval statistics, planning templates, and controller state identify whether accumulated non-parametric state mediates withdrawal deficits. Exposure-dose randomization and post-withdrawal tracking characterize dependence, recovery sample complexity, and the area under the recovery-deficit curve. We further propose Interleaved Skill-Free Rehearsal (ISR), which hides the complete skill library during randomly selected exposure episodes and preserves trajectories of end-to-end task decomposition, atomic-tool use, execution, and verification within the same persistent state. We evaluate the framework across reproducible interactive environments and frozen model families using task success, constraint satisfaction, failure modes, state mediation, exposure dependence, and skill-free recovery. The framework supports controlled analysis and mitigation of persistent reliance on external skills while keeping model parameters fixed.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
skill withdrawal, non-parametric deskilling, LLM agents

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_4PP3OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies whether prolonged reliance on externally stored, reusable skills can impair an LLM agent's subsequent task-solving ability after those skills are withdrawn. The authors define non-parametric deskilling as a post-withdrawal performance gap between agents previously exposed to skills and matched agents that never received them. They propose a randomized longitudinal evaluation protocol with several control conditions and interventions on persistent agent state. The paper also introduces Interleaved Skill-Free Rehearsal, which periodically removes the skill library during the exposure phase to preserve skill-free trajectories.

Critical strengths

The paper investigates an important problem: whether prolonged reliance on external skills can undermine LLM agents' problem-solving capabilities after those skills are withdrawn. Understanding this potential form of non-parametric deskilling is relevant to the design of agents that rely on persistent memory and reusable skills, particularly for maintaining robust performance when external resources become unavailable.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Insufficient generalization across architectures. The self-evolution mechanism and agent architecture significantly influence outcomes. The paper fails to verify if the identified issue persists across diverse frameworks (e.g., Voyager, ExpeL, AutoSkill). Additional experiments on these baselines are required to rule out architecture-specific artifacts.
  2. Lack of reproducibility. Critical implementation details such as self-evolution framework, memory configuration, state updater, and skill extraction/retrieval are omitted. This undermines the reproducibility of the experiments.
  3. Outdated base models and questionable generalizability. The base models used (e.g., Llama-3.1-8B/70B, GPT-4o) are somewhat dated and do not reflect current frontier models for complex agent tasks. Given that ablation study shows the performance gap narrows with stronger models, does the reported "de-skilling" phenomenon still hold with today’s more capable base models?
Questions for authors

Please check the entire manuscript for writing issues. For example, in lines 321–322, the cited references are not displayed correctly.

Reviewer_CNk3OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper asks whether frozen-weight LLM agents that rely on an external skill library lose autonomous problem-solving ability once the library is withdrawn, a phenomenon the authors call "non-parametric deskilling." Using a randomized protocol with a never-skilled control, they report a 7.3-point withdrawal gap that is largely mediated by persisted planning templates. The proposed fix, Interleaved Skill-Free Rehearsal (ISR), reduces the gap to 2.0 points while keeping most of the benefit of skill use.

Critical strengths
  • Interesting question, the paper asks whether self-evolving agents lose autonomous problem-solving ability once their skill library is withdrawn, a question prior work may ignore.

  • Failure analysis, component-level state resets and case studies show that the degradation comes from steps that skills used to handle, such as preconditions, constraint checks, error recovery, and verification, rather than from lost knowledge.

Critical weaknesses
  • Unclear motivation, the paper does not explain when a real agent would lose its whole skill library (but hold all the experience context). When would this happen in practice, and why does the effect almost disappear on new tasks? (On new tasks with no matching skills, the gap is only 0.6 as shown in the paper).

  • Missing steups: in some cases, as discussed in the paper, the agent fails only because its saved plans still refer to skills that were removed. But it seems the paper never tries simply removing these old references.

  • It seems that the proposed method loses to a simple reset: Just resetting the agent's saved state to its earlier copy works better than ISR on every measure, according to Table 1.

Questions for authors

See weakness

Reviewer_DA8nOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies Agentic AI (LLM agents) and how the skill sets LLM agents build affects their performance. we know that frozen LLM agents, based on the experience they obtain from the environments (like the skills they build while performing many tasks, and the memory they construct from those) can learn and update themselves even though their parameters remain unchanged. Therefore, as time progresses, how much do these agents become dependent on the skill sets they have built?

In order to study such a question, the authors design some experimental setups. First, they analyze the effect of removing a skill on the overall performance of the agent, comparing it to another identical LLM agent that has never been exposed to any skill set (the rest of the conditions are the same). Moreover, the authors design additional experiments where, when the agent's skill is removed, they also reset its memory. Another setup they design is that they let the LLM agent observe the solutions and contents of a skill being used, but the agent can never directly call the skill. The authors show that under skill removal, the agents normally degrade significantly in terms of performance (compared to agents that have never been exposed to the skills). However, according to the results, state reset helps mitigate this.

They also design a new mechanism called Interleaved Skill-Free Rehearsal (ISR). This mechanism is very intuitive: when the agent works on tasks, sometimes they make the agent solve the task independently (not using the skills). In this way, they want to preserve the capability of the agent to solve a task independently while benefiting from skill use.

Critical strengths
  1. Problem definition is interesting as it raises the question of how much an agent becomes dependent on the skills they develop themselves. The answer to such a question can be insightful for agent design.

  2. The ablation for state reset in Figure 3 is informative.

Critical weaknesses
  1. According to Table 1 and Figure 3, it seems State-Reset is the most effective mechanism for mitigating the withdrawal gap. In fact, as shown in Figure 3, it seems no part of the memory can help the agent with the task while the skill is being removed. Therefore, one might ask why ISR has been introduced in the introduction as the main prevention mechanism?

  2. Section 4.4 provides the recovery time for ISR, but it is important to report the recovery time for State-Reset as well since it is the best method according to Table 1.

3.The paper can benefit from providing deeper insights into the results in Tables 1–3 by explaining why none of the mechanisms can help the agent outperform the Never-Skilled LLM agent.

  1. It seems that in Table 1, the exposure column for Abrupt Withdrawal and State-Reset should be the same, but as we can see, the numbers are slightly different (it's not technically a serious problem, but it helps with a better understanding of the paper because these two agents seem to be the same before withdrawal).

There are also several significant issues with the paper's presentation:

1.The paper never discusses Tables 1–3 in the main text. Section 4 discusses the results, but none of the tables are mentioned in the text. Also, some of the columns are not explained; for example, what is Constraint Satisfaction? Or, what is the upper bound? How can we compute that? What is the Always-Skilled row in Table 1, and why is it empty?

  1. Some terminologies need to be defined. For example, lines 423–424 mention "Negative-control tasks," but it's not clear what kind of negative control they mean. Also, Table 1 uses "Abrupt Withdrawal," but it has not been explained in the main text (probably they mean "skill exposure," which is defined in line 248). In line 347, they mention "We evaluate three frozen instruction-tuned model families: CLOSED-L, OPEN-70B, and OPEN-8B," but it's not clear what language models these are (although they are introduced in the Appendix). Also, they do not explain what they mean by "Information-matched documentation" and "compute-matched search reduce."

3.It seems the paper has some repetitive parts, which makes it a bit difficult to read. For example, the phrase "receive identical prompts, atomic tools, information..." has been repeated multiple times. Reducing them can improve readability.

  1. It seems Equations 2 and 4 are defined but are not used anywhere in the paper. Moreover, Equation 5 already explains DnD_n, but in Line 362, the equation for $D_1 $ is written again.

Overall, the paper would benefit from a thoughtful revision.

Questions for authors
  1. What is the benfit of ISR comparing to the State Reset?
  2. Please see the critical Weaknesses.

Comments on the paper

1 comment

Nice way of concealing pure claude output papers!

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.