- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
EasyCalib is a spatial-temporal method for calibrating the extrinsic between a camera and radar sensor and the time offset between their respective data sequences. Specifically, EasyCalib uses a BEV-like representation, denoted as XYT, to accomplish this joint task. For evaluation, they evaluate on NuScenes and perturb the ground-truth extrinsic with previous works' perturbation values and demonstrate that their method outperforms previous baselines. Other experiments and ablation validate their 3 stage coarse to final processing and other architecture decisions.
Critical strengths
The model is able to output the extrinsic between the camera and radar sensors and also output the time offset. The model indeed outperforms its baselines in both reproduced results and results reported by earlier works.
Critical weaknesses
Although the EasyCalib does outperform its baselines, its translation error is at least 30 cm. In the context of calibration, translation is indeed a much harder task compared to rotation, and the high error could partly be explained by the larger perturbation R2-D2. Still, it remains unexplained why EasyCalib struggles on the translation correction. Additionally, assuming the y-axis corresponds to the height dimension (if extrinsic is w.r.t the camera frame), the y-axis error being lower than the x and z axes is a surprising considering that the domination representation is BEV-like.
More broadly, table results are provided but are not elaborated on. For example, in Table 1, it is not surprising that the more difficult R4-D4 perturbation level yields worse calibration. Aside from that, what are the takeaways?
Questions for authors
Could the authors provide reasoning for why EasyCalib struggles with high error on the evaluation benchmark?
Are baselines such as LCCNet and CalibDepth, which are trained for lidar-camera calibration, retrained on NuScenes for the camera-radar calibration task?
Could the authors clarify the difference between previously-developed BEV representation and XYT representation? Is the only difference the time dimension?
Could qualitative visualizations be provided to visually observe the calibration quality?
Response to Reviewer fEpM and withdrawal
Thank you for your careful review and constructive suggestions. Your questions helped us identify where the results and the calibration mechanism needed clearer explanation.
Translation error and coordinate frames. Monocular depth uncertainty and the difference between visual detection centers and radar scattering points are relevant sources of translation error. The output errors use the optical camera frame (x right, y down, z forward), whose axes differ from the planar X and Y used in XYT. Visual height is retained as an input attribute, and the model also receives nominal mounting information. A planar positional encoding therefore does not mean that vertical information is absent; attributing the smaller y-axis error to a particular input requires a controlled ablation.
Baseline provenance. We did not retrain LCCNet or CalibDepth for the submitted tables. Their values were taken from the published comparison in RC-AutoCalib. The source of these numbers and the differences in evaluation protocol should have been clearer in our presentation.
XYT and BEV. XYT represents irregular object observations using planar position and reported time, while retaining visual height as an attribute. It is not a rasterized BEV occupancy map. Its role is to organize asynchronous observations over a window for spatial correction, followed by temporal association after spatial compensation. We agree that this role needs to be explained through the complete calibration mechanism, rather than through the addition of a time coordinate alone.
Interpretation and visualization. The coarse-to-refined comparison demonstrates the benefit of spatial refinement; temporal estimation needs its own controlled evaluation. We appreciate your suggestion to show real observations before correction, after spatial correction, and after temporal correction. Such examples are important for connecting the numerical results to observable calibration quality.
After considering the reviews, we have decided to withdraw this submission from ICLR 2027. Thank you again for the time and guidance you have given this work.