- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes RLOR for repairing errors in long reasoning trajectories. It identifies an early deviation, generates an observation-based explanation, and repairs the continuation while preserving the preceding prefix. Training combines a three-stage SFT curriculum with pivot-aware GSPO updates. Experiments on five benchmarks report improvements in accuracy and token efficiency.
Critical strengths
The experiments report consistent accuracy gains over GSPO across five benchmarks using the same backbone and evaluation harness. The reduction in token usage is also encouraging. Together, these results suggest that the proposed training approach has practical value.
Critical weaknesses
-
The contribution relative to recent work is insufficiently established. Several closely related methods are missing from both the discussion and comparisons. PivoARL [1] combines error localization, prefix reuse, local retries, and pivotal credit assignment. Search-R2 [2] repairs faulty suffixes and removes its refiner at deployment. ELPO [3] focuses corrective updates on critical errors and their suffixes. The SFT component also overlaps with recent work. InT [4] internalizes targeted interventions through SFT before further RL training. P-BRIDGE [5] distills teacher-guided error diagnosis and prefix-preserving repairs, while masking the prefix loss during SFT. These methods differ from RLOR in important details. However, the paper does not establish what its particular combination adds. The current baselines leave this central question unresolved.
-
The deployment procedure is underspecified. The teacher locates pivots by inspecting completed trajectories. The trained policy is then claimed to detect deviations during generation. It is unclear how this transition is implemented. In particular, does inference truncate an earlier suffix, or append a correction to the current history? This distinction matters for understanding both the repair mechanism and its reported efficiency.
[1] Agent Reinforcement Learning via Pivotal-Aware Self-Feedback Retry
[2] Search-R2: Enhancing Search-Integrated Reasoning via Actor-Refiner Collaboration
[3] Learning from the Irrecoverable: Error-Localized Policy Optimization for Tool-Integrated LLM Reasoning
[4] InT: Self-Proposed Interventions Enable Credit Assignment in LLM Reasoning
[5] Failures are Treasures: Constructing a Pedagogical Bridge for Agentic Strategy Distillation
Questions for authors
-
What distinguishes RLOR’s repair training from InT and P-BRIDGE, and its policy optimization from PivoARL, Search-R2, and ELPO? What controlled comparisons or ablations establish these differences as meaningful contributions?
-
Could you provide the deployment algorithm and an example from the trained policy? Please specify when pivots are generated, what context is retained, and whether tool interactions are replayed.
6 comments
Response to Reviewer UYuX - Part 2
For W2&Q2:
Thank you for pointing out this ambiguity. We clarify that offline suffix replacement is used only for SFT data construction, whereas online deployment follows an append-only correction mechanism. The teacher identifies intervention points retrospectively to construct supervision, but the trained policy autonomously generates pivots and corrective continuations during inference. We distinguish these two procedures below.
(1) SFT data construction
During offline data construction, the teacher examines completed trajectories to identify intervention points. The question (x) and retained trajectory prefix (h) are used as the shared conditioning context, while the original off-track suffix is replaced by the corresponding supervision target.
All stages share the question–prefix input; Stage 3 retains only successful repairs.
| Stage | Model input | Supervised output | Single-round examples | Additional later-round examples | Multi-round total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Pivot localization | x + h | P | 4,609 | 2,517 | 7,126 |
| 2. Pivot-reason generation | x + h | P + r | 4,609 | 2,517 | 7,126 |
| 3. Continuation repair | x + h | P + r + s+ | 2,762 | 1,965 | 4,727 |
Each stage trains for eight epochs (learning rate 10⁻⁵, cosine schedule, warmup ratio 0.05); subsequent stages use the preceding final checkpoint. No validation-based switching or checkpoint selection is used.
This schematic adapts Figure 9 to illustrate the supervision formats; it is neither a serialized training sample nor an autonomous RLOR rollout.
Shared input: question x + retained history h
x:
Which person represented the association acknowledged by the
target early-2020s article on mining and water impacts?
h (abridged):
IMWA has been considered as a candidate association, but the target
article and its acknowledgements have not yet been verified.
P:
<|PIVOT_INTERVENTION|>
r (abridged):
Narrowing the search to IMWA is unsupported. Identify the target
article and use its acknowledgements to determine the association
and its representative.
s+ (abridged):
Assistant: Search for the target article and inspect its acknowledgements.
Tool: ... AWARD ... under the directorship of Sharon Pollard ...
Assistant: Verify the co-author's leadership appointment.
Tool: ... appointed Executive Director of AWARD in August 2023 ...
Assistant: Answer: Sharon Pollard.
Stage 1 target: P
Stage 2 target: P + r
Stage 3 target: P + r + s+
In all three stages, the question and retained prefix are conditioning context and receive no SFT loss. Only target assistant tokens are supervised; tool observations are excluded from the loss. We will add representative serialized training examples for all three stages to the appendix, including their input–target boundaries and token-level loss masks.
(2) Online deployment
Unlike offline data construction, deployment does not involve teacher intervention or retrospective suffix replacement. Instead, the trained policy generates pivot markers as part of its own autoregressive generation. When a pivot is produced, the policy continues with an observation-based reason and corrective actions, conditioned on the accumulated history.
In the testing phase, RLOR generates its own pivot, observation-based reason, and corrective continuation within the current rollout. Correction is append-only: all history is retained, with no teacher, truncation, or automatic tool replay.
H ← question and interaction history
while within 128k tokens and 256 assistant turns:
Generate the policy’s next output and append it to H.
If a pivot appears, continue with its reason and corrective actions.
If a final answer is emitted, return it.
Execute new tool calls, with at most three running concurrently.
Append observations to H; they count toward the token limit.
The curriculum progressively supervises P,P+r, andP+r+s⁺ from the same question–prefix input, teaching the policy to generate the intervention rather than receive it externally. Offline suffix replacement constructs training targets; deployment redirects future generation without rewriting history. We will add a policy-generated trace to distinguish this behavior from the offline teacher-intervention example in Figure 9.
Thank you for the detailed clarification and additional controls. The SFT comparisons and randomized RL controls provide stronger evidence that structured repair supervision and pivot-conditioned updates are useful. The explanation that deployment is append-only, retains the full history, and involves no automatic tool replay also resolves my question about the inference procedure.
My central concern remains whether the contribution relative to the closest existing methods is sufficiently established. The comparison table identifies concrete differences from InT, P-BRIDGE, PivoARL, Search-R2, and ELPO. However, the additional experiments primarily establish the usefulness of the proposed components relative to success-only SFT, ordinary GSPO, and randomized update schemes. Their implications for the claimed distinctions from prior repair and credit-assignment methods remain limited.
For example, outperforming random suffix boundaries supports the value of informed update allocation, but does not establish the advantage of RLOR’s particular allocation rule relative to existing localization-aware approaches. Likewise, the curriculum controls support staged repair learning, while leaving the value of its specific differences from closely related intervention-based training insufficiently isolated. A controlled comparison with a representative close method, or an ablation directly testing a claimed distinguishing choice, would provide stronger evidence on this central issue.
The requested example from the deployed policy also remains outstanding. The response explicitly describes the supplied example as an offline supervision schematic and promises a policy-generated trace. The teacher-assisted intervention diagnostics are informative, but do not directly demonstrate how the trained policy autonomously generates and uses a pivot during an actual rollout. The requested trace would help connect the clarified deployment procedure to the claimed behavior.
I acknowledge that the rebuttal improves the experimental support and resolves the procedural ambiguity. However, my main concern about the distinct contribution remains insufficiently addressed, so I maintain my rating.
Response to Reviewer UYuX - Part 1
For W1&Q1:
We thank the reviewer for requesting a clearer explanation of what RLOR adds and whether its design choices matter. RLOR combines staged learning of explicit repair representations with pivot-conditioned update allocation based on terminal rewards. This integration trains the policy to generate its own corrective guidance and continue reasoning within an ongoing trajectory.
1. Differences from the five methods
2. Evidence from the manuscript and additional controls
Figures 2 and 7 support the utility of pivot localization and semantically aligned reasons through teacher-assisted intervention diagnostics. Tables 4 and 8 show the benefit of progressively learning localization, reasons, and continuation over mixed or continuation-only training; Table 11 shows that the curriculum’s macro-average advantage persists across the evaluated policy–trajectory-source combinations. Figure 3 and Table 2 further support improved accuracy–token-cost trade-offs, rather than gains obtained simply through longer reasoning.
To further test these design choices, we added same-backbone SFT controls and RL controls sharing the same Stage-SFT initialization.
Rejection-Sampling SFT retains correct trajectories from five unassisted rollouts per question on the same pool, matching the curriculum’s total training-example presentations. Success-SFT removes all pivot markers and associated reasons from the same successful student repairs. The plain-text control replaces markers with natural language, retaining localization semantics, reasons, continuations, and stage order. Annotation-only trains only Stages 1–2 with GPT-5.2 annotations; Student-Annotation uses Qwen3.5-35B-A3B annotations. Mixture-SFT mixes tasks instead of training stages sequentially.
Our curriculum-based Stage-SFT achieves the best overall performance, highlighting the benefits of progressive, structured repair learning over alternative training strategies.
Random masking preserves the updated-token count per trajectory; random boundaries select arbitrary assistant-step suffixes. Unselected assistant tokens receive weak KL.
RLOR outperforms GSPO and both controls, supporting pivot-aware updates beyond token-count reduction or arbitrary suffix selection.
Taken together, the SFT comparisons support the value of staged learning of explicit repair representations, while the RL controls support pivot-conditioned update allocation beyond ordinary GSPO or the tested randomized update schemes. These findings support RLOR’s specific training design: learning to generate corrective guidance, then using terminal rewards to optimize pivot-conditioned continuations within an ongoing trajectory.