acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Rollback the World, Keep the Reflection: Rollback-Induced Reflection for Long-Horizon LLM Agents

Abstract

Large language model (LLM) agents increasingly tackle long-horizon tasks through multi-step environment interaction, yet a single erroneous action can alter subsequent states and observations, causing errors to compound over time. Existing methods either correct the context without repairing altered environment states or restore earlier states while discarding useful experience, making it difficult to both eliminate failure conditions and avoid repeating past mistakes. We argue that reliable recovery should instead be treated as a rollback-boundary control problem that jointly determines to intervene, to resume, and information should survive recovery. Based on this view, we propose Rollback-Induced Reflection (RIR), a unified recovery framework that restores execution to a selected prior state while carrying forward reusable knowledge distilled from the abandoned trajectory to guide subsequent decisions. We further characterize recovery through a unified operator over rollback depth and retained memory, providing a general view of state restoration and knowledge retention. Experiments on three long-horizon benchmarks show that RIR consistently improves average task performance across multiple LLM backbones, with structured reflection memory preserving useful experience and selective rollback enabling efficient recovery.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
LLM agents, rollback and error recovery, self-reflection, self-correction, agent memory

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_ZH66OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

Rollback-Induced Reflection (RIR) coordinates when an agent should review its progress, which checkpoint it should return to, and what information should survive the rollback. The environment and branch-specific context are restored, while useful reflections are retained without preserving stale claims about the current state. The paper evaluates this recovery mechanism on ALFWorld, ScienceWorld, and GAIA with three backbones.

Critical strengths
  1. The separation of reusable knowledge from rollback-invalidated state is thoughtful. An agent that undoes an action but still remembers the resulting state as current can immediately repeat its mistake; the proposed memory interface addresses this failure directly.
  2. The presentation is good. The when/where/what organization is clear, and the component ablations help explain the design. The paper gives a reasonably concrete account of implementing restoration in the tested environments.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Interaction steps and auxiliary model calls do not capture the complete cost of restoration. Reset-and-replay, file snapshots, and all generated tokens can matter. The applicability to irreversible external actions is also more limited than the general agent framing suggests.
  2. The incremental contribution needs a stronger direct comparison. GA-Rollback already combines error detection with rollback and explicitly evaluates a GA-Rollback + Reflexion variant. Comparing RIR with the individual components does not establish an advantage over this closest existing combination.
Questions for authors

Please refer to critical weakness.

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer ZH66 (Part 1 of 2)

We thank the reviewer for the positive assessment of the presentation, restoration implementation, and cross-rollback memory design. The concerns about complete restoration costs and comparison with the closest existing combination help sharpen the assessment of RIR’s practical value. We address them below.

W1: Restoration costs and practical applicability

Cost accounting. We agree that interaction steps and auxiliary model calls alone do not fully characterize restoration cost. To provide more direct quantitative evidence, we additionally analyze the DeepSeek-V3 execution logs for the ALFWorld dataset, comparing RIR with GA-Rollback in terms of environment replay work and historical trajectory-text overhead.

MetricGA-RollbackRIR
Auxiliary model calls per task19.985.55
Total additional replayed environment actions679356
Replayed environment actions per task5.072.66
Replayed environment actions per rollback22.634.05
Estimated cumulative historical trajectory input per task33.13k tokens16.08k tokens

For reset-and-replay, RIR reduces cumulative environment-action replay by 47.6% relative to GA-Rollback. These replays execute saved action prefixes without fresh model generation. For the historical trajectory-text component of actor inputs, we used the DeepSeek-V3 tokenizer to count the retained reasoning, action, and observation text before each invocation, removing abandoned suffixes after rollback. Under this common accounting procedure, RIR reduces the estimated cumulative trajectory-token volume from 33.13k to 16.08k per task, approximately 51.5%. Thus, this experiment provides evidence of reduced environment replay work and a smaller historical trajectory-text burden, alongside fewer auxiliary calls.

For GAIA workspace restoration, we use Git’s content-addressed object storage to share identical content across checkpoints rather than saving an independent full directory copy for each checkpoint. This design avoids duplicate storage through content reuse; actual snapshot and restoration overhead depends on workspace size and file changes.

Applicability. RIR assumes that the task provides a restorable execution interface. In ALFWorld and ScienceWorld, this is implemented through environment reset and replay of the retained action prefix. In GAIA, restoration includes the agent context and local workspace. This capability has a practical engineering basis. We have contributed functionality for selectively restoring context, memory, and workspace files to a widely used open-source agent system. RIR builds on such restoration interfaces to study how an agent can autonomously decide when to recover, where to resume, and which knowledge to retain.

We do not claim that checkpoints can undo irreversible external actions, such as an email that has already been sent. This is a general boundary of agent interaction with external systems: restoring the agent’s state does not automatically undo an action already completed outside it. Appendix C.4 now explicitly states this applicability boundary alongside the benchmark-specific restoration mechanisms.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer ZH66 (Part 2 of 2)

W2: Direct comparison with GA-Rollback + Reflexion

We thank the reviewer for identifying this closely related combination. The Rollback only ablation in Tables 3, 6, and 7 retains RIR’s recovery control while withholding the reflection briefing from the acting agent. It therefore tests the incremental contribution of generator-facing reflection, but does not replace a direct comparison with GA-Rollback + Reflexion.

To address this question, we have added a direct comparison with GA-Rollback + Reflexion across two backbones and three benchmarks in Appendix D.4, together with the experimental setup and result analysis:

BackboneMethodALFWorld SR (%)ScienceWorld SR (%)GAIA SR (%)Avg. SR (%)
Qwen3.8-27BGA-Rollback + Reflexion97.7675.2851.3274.79
Qwen3.8-27BRIR99.2579.7050.6676.54
DeepSeek-V3GA-Rollback + Reflexion79.8568.2735.5361.22
DeepSeek-V3RIR94.0376.7537.5069.43

RIR improves average SR by 1.75 percentage points on Qwen3.8-27B and 8.21 points on DeepSeek-V3. On DeepSeek-V3, it improves all three benchmarks, including gains of 14.18 points on ALFWorld and 8.48 points on ScienceWorld. On Qwen3.8-27B, the combination leads by 0.66 points on GAIA, while RIR leads by 1.49 points on ALFWorld and 4.42 points on ScienceWorld, retaining the higher overall average.

This additional comparison directly tests whether RIR’s advantage comes merely from having both rollback and reflection. GA-Rollback + Reflexion already includes both, yet RIR achieves higher average performance on both backbones. Together with the existing component ablations, these results support the incremental value of coordinating review timing, restore-point selection, and cross-recovery information retention, beyond using rollback and reflection alongside each other.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Thank you again for your feedback

Thank you again for your feedback. We would appreciate hearing whether our responses and additional experiments have addressed your concerns. We would be happy to clarify any remaining points.

We wanted to briefly follow up on our response, particularly the restoration-cost analysis and the added comparison with GA-Rollback + Reflexion. If you have had a chance to review these results, we would appreciate any feedback on whether they address your concerns. We would be happy to clarify any remaining points.

Reviewer_qKzFOpenReview ↗
Rating
2(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes RIR, a recovery framework for long-horizon LLM agents that couples state-level rollback with information-level reflection. A controller decides when to intervene, where to restore the trajectory, and what knowledge to retain across the rollback. Experiments report improvements over ReAct, Reflexion, and LATS baselines, with ablations over the review-timing and localization components.

Critical strengths
  1. Coupling rollback for state recovery with reflection for information retention is an intuitive and useful framing for long-horizon agents.
  2. The ablations have reasonable breadth, covering review timing, localization, and memory, which gives some view into the component roles.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper concedes in Related Work that GA-Rollback (Li et al., 2025) already performs state-level rollback, and distinguishes itself only in prose while treating GA-Rollback as a black-box baseline in Table 1, with no "RIR minus reflection-memory ≈ GA-Rollback" ablation to isolate the claimed core novelty. The when/where/what framework repackages existing components: "when" is Reflexion-style (Shinn et al., 2023) reflection plus periodic review scheduling, "where" is GA-Rollback / WebRollback (Zhang et al., 2026c) restore-point selection split into a coarse-to-fine two-call form, and "what" is ExpeL (Zhao et al., 2024) / G-Memory (Zhang et al., 2026a) structured experience memory. The "unified recovery operator" with Proposition 1 and Corollary 1 (§4.5, Appendix B) is a trivial set-inclusion result, a larger policy class has a supremum no smaller than its subset's, which holds for any superset and has nothing specific to rollback, and the authors concede it is "a capacity statement rather than a performance guarantee", so presenting it as a theoretical contribution overstates the novelty. Relevant backtracking work is also under-engaged: Tree of Thoughts is not cited at all despite the method being backtracking-based tree search, and BacktrackAgent (Wu et al., 2025), whose name nearly matches RIR's "error detection + backtracking," is differentiated in one sentence with no comparison.
  2. The significance is undermined by the experimental design. The strongest improvement (6.57%) appears only on a single backbone (DeepSeek-V3), where the baselines are anomalously weak, GA-Rollback's average success rate (47.72%) is lower than plain ReAct's (62.86%), i.e. a state-level rollback method scoring 15% below no-recovery ReAct, which strongly suggests mis-tuned or mis-implemented baselines and makes the "large lead" hard to trust. On the stronger Qwen3.8-27B the gain shrinks to 3.04% and Reflexion actually beats RIR by 1.97pp on the GAIA subset, so the benefit decays as the backbone improves, suggesting the method may be absorbed by model capability. The "keep the reflection" payoff is shown only in that same collapsed-baseline setting.
  3. The baseline comparison is unfair. RIR relies on memory infrastructure that the ReAct, Reflexion, and LATS baselines do not have, which confounds RIR's algorithmic contribution with an infrastructure advantage, so the Table 2 main results do not isolate the method's effect.
  4. The core mechanism rests on circular reasoning. The agent can request rollback when it detects failure. If the agent reliably self-diagnoses, the scheduled review is redundant, and if it does not, the framework reduces to scheduled-only review. The paper claims the two signals are "complementary" but provides no breakdown of which failures each signal catches.
  5. There is a mismatch between the method and the experiments. The Coarse-to-Fine Restore Localization is described as a multi-stage LLM-based selector, yet RIR is reported to use fewer auxiliary LLM calls than the baselines in some cases, and a multi-stage LLM selector using fewer calls than the baselines needs explanation.
  6. The qualitative examples show selection bias: the trajectory examples show only successful rollbacks, with no case where coarse-to-fine localization picks the wrong checkpoint.
  7. Missing Reference [1-4].

[1] Tree of thoughts: Deliberate problem solving with large language models.

[2] Backtrackagent: Enhancing gui agent with error detection and backtracking mechanism.

[3] Towards reasoning era: A survey of long chain-of-thought for reasoning large language models.

[4] From system 1 to system 2: A survey of reasoning large language models.

Questions for authors

See Weakness.

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer qKzF (Part 1 of 3)

We thank the reviewer for the detailed questions and comments. We would like to clarify several points that materially affect the assessment and explain more precisely how RIR differs from prior work. In particular, we draw attention to the experimental controls, component ablations, and failure-case analyses already included in the submission, which help resolve several concerns raised in the review.

W1: Novelty, distinctions from prior work, and the role of the theoretical analysis

RIR does not claim to introduce rollback, reflection, or structured memory individually. It addresses a specific problem at their intersection: when the environment and trajectory context are restored to the past, which information should remain, and how can memory avoid reintroducing state claims invalidated by restoration? Its contribution therefore cannot be assessed solely by whether individual components have appeared separately in previous work.

The three components address different aspects of this recovery boundary:

  • When: An agent-issued rollback call is a soft request to the reviewer, not an immediate restoration command. Agent requests and adaptive external reviews share a decision mechanism while providing different opportunities for intervention.
  • Where: The selector does more than predict an erroneous step. It compares checkpoint states against a conditioned failure diagnosis to select a state that removes the obstruction while preserving a useful prefix. Coarse-to-fine localization implements this state-aware comparison.
  • What: Reflection Memory is not merely experience stored in structured fields. It separates current branch state from knowledge that survives recovery: current state is restored with the checkpoint, environment knowledge accumulates across branches, attained milestones are retained as historical records, and the latest failure analysis replaces its predecessor. Consequently, “an earlier attempt acquired an object” is not directly treated as “the agent still holds that object after recovery.”

GA-Rollback already includes error diagnosis, state rollback, and retry feedback; we do not dispute this. However, removing generator-facing reflection from RIR still leaves its review and restore-selection mechanisms intact. Thus, “RIR minus reflection = GA-Rollback” is not a mechanistic equivalence. The corresponding controlled ablation is already reported as Rollback only in Tables 3, 6, and 7. It retains recovery control while withholding the reflection briefing from the acting agent:

BackboneRollback onlyRIRImprovement
Qwen3-14B35.42%36.67%+1.25 pp
DeepSeek-V369.37%76.75%+7.38 pp
Qwen3.8-27B74.17%79.70%+5.53 pp

This comparison directly tests the value of delivering cross-recovery reflection to the acting agent while retaining RIR’s other recovery mechanisms. The evaluation therefore includes component-level evidence beyond a black-box comparison with GA-Rollback.

Regarding theory, we agree that optimal-value monotonicity follows directly once policy-class containment is established. Its purpose is to specify the unified recovery space and the conditions of comparison, not to provide an unconditional performance guarantee for the implemented LLM controller. In particular, rollback depth determines the abandoned suffix, and the available memory update depends on that suffix; restoration and retention therefore require a joint definition. The formal result therefore characterizes the available recovery-policy space, while the effectiveness of the implemented controller is assessed through the empirical comparisons and controlled ablations.

Due to the length of the main text, we did not provide a detailed comparison of the differences between other works and our own in the "Related Work" section .We have expanded Section 2 with explicit comparisons to Tree of Thoughts and BacktrackAgent. RIR follows one active trajectory with selective recovery, rather than explicitly maintaining candidate branches as a tree-search method does. Its distinction from other error-detection and backtracking approaches should be explained through the restoration interface, restore-selection criteria, and treatment of information across recovery.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer qKzF (Part 2 of 3)

W2: Whether the gains depend on weak baselines or disappear with stronger models

This concern involves three distinct questions: whether RIR’s advantage depends on GA-Rollback’s lower performance, whether the gains disappear with stronger models, and whether reflection memory is beneficial only on DeepSeek-V3.

First, the reported 6.57-point improvement on DeepSeek-V3 is measured against ReAct, the strongest baseline in that setting, at 62.86%, not against GA-Rollback at 47.72%. RIR achieves 69.43% average SR. This main advantage therefore remains even if GA-Rollback is excluded entirely and cannot be attributed to the weak performance of a single baseline.

Second, the results do not support a monotonic disappearance of gains with model capability. Relative to the strongest baseline for each backbone, RIR improves average SR by 3.09, 6.57, and 3.04 percentage points on Qwen3-14B, DeepSeek-V3, and Qwen3.8-27B, respectively, achieving the highest average SR under all three backbones. Comparisons across model families are not a controlled scaling experiment, but the results clearly show that RIR’s gains persist on the stronger Qwen3.8-27B. GAIA with Qwen3.8-27B is indeed an exception: Reflexion exceeds RIR by 1.97 points, as explicitly discussed in the main text. On the same backbone, however, RIR achieves 99.25% SR on ALFWorld and 79.70% on ScienceWorld, retaining a 3.04-point average advantage over the strongest baseline. This exception demonstrates task-dependent benefits; it does not establish that model capability has generally subsumed recovery.

Third, the contribution of reflection memory is supported by controlled ablations across backbones, not only on DeepSeek-V3. Tables 3, 6, and 7 compare full RIR with Rollback only, which retains recovery control while withholding generator-facing reflection. Full RIR improves ScienceWorld SR by 1.25, 7.38, and 5.53 points on Qwen3-14B, DeepSeek-V3, and Qwen3.8-27B, respectively. In particular, the 5.53-point gain on Qwen3.8-27B directly demonstrates that a stronger model still benefits from reflection retained across recovery.

Finally, GA-Rollback performing below ReAct is not, by itself, evidence of an implementation error. The original GA-Rollback paper also reports degradation when combined with ReAct due to conflicting reasoning between the generator and assistant; adding rollback therefore does not automatically improve performance. Our Figure 2 further shows that, on ScienceWorld, GA-Rollback uses more interaction steps and auxiliary calls while achieving lower success. This pattern is consistent with inefficient intervention and repeated exploration, although aggregate results alone cannot establish its cause. Our assessment of RIR therefore rests on gains over the strongest baselines, consistent results across backbones, and controlled internal ablations, rather than on GA-Rollback’s degradation.

W3: Whether memory infrastructure creates an unfair advantage

We distinguish shared execution infrastructure from method-specific algorithmic components. The methods access task environments, executors, and tool interfaces through the common framework; their reflection, memory, search, and recovery policies remain method-specific. Reflexion includes cross-trial verbal memory, and LATS includes search and reflection mechanisms, so these baselines are not uniformly memory-free.

RIR’s particular Reflection Memory is part of the algorithm being evaluated. Giving it unchanged to every baseline would modify those methods. To examine its contribution more directly, Tables 3, 6, and 7 retain RIR’s review and localization mechanisms while withholding generator-facing reflection.

The main experiments therefore compare complete methods, while the internal ablations examine the incremental contribution of RIR’s components. These provide complementary evidence. The complete-method comparisons and internal ablations therefore answer different questions: the former compare the methods as implemented, while the latter isolate the contribution of generator-facing reflection within RIR.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer qKzF (Part 3 of 3)

W4: Whether agent-initiated and scheduled reviews involve circular reasoning

This concern implicitly divides self-diagnosis into two extremes: either it is always reliable or it is ineffective. In practice, an agent’s ability to recognize failure varies across tasks and execution stages. It may identify an explicit mistake while overlooking a deviation that develops through several actions. Useful self-diagnosis therefore does not make external review redundant, and imperfect self-diagnosis does not reduce the framework to scheduled-only review.

The channels serve different roles. An agent request allows review before the scheduled horizon when the agent notices a problem. Scheduled review covers branches for which no request is issued. Both are adjudicated by the reviewer; a request does not itself execute rollback.

Table 3 provides controlled evidence. On ScienceWorld with DeepSeek-V3, Agent-only achieves 73.43% SR, Scheduled-only adaptive achieves 72.32%, and Hybrid adaptive reaches 76.75%, improving by 3.32 and 4.43 points, respectively. Appendix E.1.3 also illustrates the specific role of scheduled review. In that GAIA case, the agent never requests rollback but continues attempting unavailable parsing routes. A horizon-triggered review terminates this branch, after which execution switches to a dependency-free strategy. Scheduled review thus supplies a recovery opportunity that the acting agent did not initiate.

W5: Why a two-stage selector can still require fewer auxiliary calls

The distinction is between calls per recovery event and cumulative calls per task. The two-stage selector runs only when recovery is entered, not at every environment step.

A normal full recovery involves one review, two selection calls, and one reflection-patching call. When review returns CONTINUE, selection and patching are not invoked. Total auxiliary cost therefore depends on both review frequency and how often recovery is entered, rather than on the number of selector stages alone.

For example, the DeepSeek-V3 results in Table 3 report 7.08 reviews and 0.92 rollbacks per task. An approximate decomposition using the normal recovery path gives:

$ 7.08 + 0.92\times(2+1)\approx 9.84, $

consistent with the reported 9.85 auxiliary calls. This approximation explains the sources of calls rather than replacing invocation-level accounting.

By contrast, GA-Rollback’s assistant continues inspecting the trajectory after its wait-k condition is met. More frequent reviews and recoveries can therefore produce a larger task-level total. There is no contradiction between two-stage localization and fewer cumulative auxiliary calls: Figure 2 reports the resulting task-level overhead, not the cost of a single localization event.

W6: Whether the qualitative analysis includes only successful recoveries

There appears to be an omission here: Appendix E.2 of the submitted manuscript already contains two detailed failure cases.

  • B1 / Figure 14 illustrates incorrect diagnosis and unsuitable early restore points. Early rollbacks preserve the occupied-hand state responsible for the obstruction. Even after a later rollback reaches an earlier checkpoint, misleading persistent memory helps reconstruct the failed branch.
  • B2 / Figure 15 illustrates largely reasonable restore points but ineffective reflection. The agent repeatedly varies object references without attempting the operation explicitly specified by the recipe.

The existing analysis therefore covers both incorrect localization and ineffective knowledge retention.

W7: Related references

We have expanded Section 2 with explicit comparisons to Tree of Thoughts and BacktrackAgent. BacktrackAgent was already included in the submitted reference list; the revision makes its relationship to RIR explicit in the main discussion, focusing on backtracking mechanisms and the treatment of information across recovery.

Reviewer_R9VLOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3(+1)
Read review
Paper summary

The manuscript proposes RIR, which is a training-free rollback-based recovery framework for LLM agents. RIR address three recovery decision dimensions: when to intervene, where to rstore, and what information to retain. Based on reflection memory and rollback interface, RIR restores the state and llm context to the latest checkpoint that removes the diagnosed failure condition while preserving knowledge from the failure itself. Evaluation on three benchmakrs and three llm backbones shows consistent improvements over the baselines.

Critical strengths

The manuscript clearly identifies the limitations of previous recovery mechanism (reflection-only and rollback-only), and frames the problem into three intuitive dimensions: when to intervene, where to rstore, and what information to retain. The design of propoased method is consistent with this framing.

Critical weaknesses

RIR assumes the possibility of 'rollback': it can resotre states to arbitrary previous ones. However, this is typically infeasible in real-world settings. Despite this strong assumption, the comparison focus on rollback-based methods, with relatively 'naive' non-rollback oens (ReAct, self-refine, reflexion). There are noticeable recent efforts to improve performance without rollback (https://arxiv.org/abs/2508.19076 as just an example). Given the substantial advantage provided by rollback possibility, RIR should be compared against recent non-rollback approaches and demonstrate sufficiently large gains to justify this restrictive assumption.

RIR is sensitive to (L_{min}, L_{max}). SR varies from approx. 69% to 77.5% (figure 3). Also, the contribution of adaptive scheduling is not sufficiently justified. While the authors explain the adaptive horizon \rho concentrates review effort on uncertain trajectories while allowing stable branches longer uninterrupted exploration, this explanation remains an unverified hypothesis. By connecting figure 3 and adding the analysis of \rho (distribution, correlation, etc), the contribution about 'when' can become better justified.

In figure 4, the coarse-to-fine restore localization mechanism achieves only +1.84%p over "Restart" (restart from the initial state). Given the additional complexity of the proposed mechanism, this relatively small gain raises concern to the contribution about 'where'.

Questions for authors

Please see weaknesses.

9 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer R9VL (Part 1 of 2)

We appreciate the reviewer’s recognition of the consistency between RIR’s problem formulation and its design. Below, we address the applicability of rollback, comparisons with recent non-rollback methods, adaptive review, and restore-point localization.

W1: Practical applicability of rollback and comparison with recent non-rollback methods

We would like to clarify that RIR assumes the ability to restore controlled execution state, rather than reverse arbitrary real-world actions. In our experiments, ALFWorld and ScienceWorld restore state through environment reset and replay of the retained action prefix, while GAIA restores the agent context and local task workspace. We do not claim that checkpoints can undo irreversible external actions, such as an email that has already been sent. This is a general limitation of all agent systems: restoring the agent’s state does not undo an action already completed in the outside world. The restoration interface in RIR also has a practical engineering basis. We have contributed functionality for selectively restoring agent context, memory, and workspace files to a widely used open-source agent system. This practical experience motivated our work, while RIR studies the further problem of autonomously deciding when to recover, where to resume, and which knowledge should survive recovery.

To directly address the reviewer’s suggestion, we have added comparisons with HiPlan and ReflAct (EMNLP 2025) in Appendix D.3. HiPlan improves forward execution through hierarchical global–local planning, whereas ReflAct uses continuous goal-state reflection to improve action selection.

BackboneMethodALFWorld SR (%)ScienceWorld SR (%)GAIA SR (%)Avg. SR (%)
Qwen3.8-27BHiPlan97.0173.8049.3473.38
Qwen3.8-27BReflAct95.5275.6550.0173.73
Qwen3.8-27BRIR99.2579.7050.6676.54
DeepSeek-V3HiPlan83.5868.8733.5762.01
DeepSeek-V3ReflAct88.0666.7935.5263.45
DeepSeek-V3RIR94.0376.7537.5069.43

RIR achieves the highest SR in all six backbone–benchmark comparisons. Relative to the stronger added baseline by average SR, RIR improves by 2.81 percentage points on Qwen3.8-27B and 5.98 points on DeepSeek-V3. These results show that selective recovery provides additional benefits even against stronger non-rollback planning and reflection methods. Appendix C.4 now explicitly states the scope of the restoration interface, while Appendix D.3 provides additional evidence of RIR’s effectiveness against non-rollback methods within that scope.

[1] HiPlan: Hierarchical Planning for LLM-Based Agents with Adaptive Global-Local Guidance

[2] Reflact: World-grounded decision making in llm agents via goal-state reflection

W2: Incremental value of coarse-to-fine localization over Restart

The "Restart" variant in Figure 4 (Figure 3 in the revised manuscript) is a strong control that retains the full review and reflection mechanisms. It shares RIR’s "when" and "what" components, but always restores the initial checkpoint rather than selecting an intermediate restore point. This experiment therefore isolates the incremental value of selective recovery over restarting with reflection.

On ScienceWorld with DeepSeek-V3, the results are:

MetricRestartRIR
SR (%) ↑74.9176.75
Dense reward ↑0.7950.813
Average interaction steps ↓45.642.4
Average rollbacks ↓1.290.92

Beyond the 1.84-point SR improvement, RIR increases dense reward while reducing interaction steps by 3.2 (approximately 7.0%) and rollbacks by 0.37 (approximately 28.7%). We therefore assess this component through the joint improvement in task completion, partial progress, and interaction overhead, rather than SR alone.

Restore-point localization affects execution only when recovery occurs, whereas aggregate SR also includes tasks that require no recovery. Its purpose is to remove the current obstruction while preserving a useful trajectory prefix. The results are consistent with this objective: selecting an intermediate checkpoint achieves better task performance with fewer interactions and recovery events than restarting from the beginning.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer R9VL (Part 2 of 2)

W3: Contribution of adaptive review and sensitivity to the horizon range

We thank the reviewer for raising this question. We address it in two parts: first, how the choice of review range affects performance; and second, whether adaptive scheduling driven by ρ\rho provides practical benefits.

Figure 3 in the original submission (Figure 4 in the revised manuscript) shows that the review range matters. A larger Lmin⁡L_{\min} limits how soon the system can review the trajectory again, while a smaller Lmax⁡L_{\max} limits uninterrupted exploration between reviews. This is consistent with our design motivation of balancing timely intervention with sustained exploration. The default setting, (4,8)(4,8), achieves 76.75% SR, only 0.74 percentage points below the best measured setting, (2,8)(2,8), at 77.49%. Thus, although performance depends on the range, the default configuration remains competitive among the measured settings without using the best-performing parameter choice.

Table 3 further compares adaptive and fixed scheduling. With both review channels and the other recovery components retained, Hybrid adaptive improves SR from 69.00% to 76.75% over Hybrid fixed, while reducing average reviews (7.79 → 7.08), rollbacks (1.17 → 0.92), and auxiliary LLM calls (11.32 → 9.85). Adaptive scheduling therefore achieves better task performance with fewer interventions, rather than obtaining its gains by increasing intervention frequency.

Mechanistically, ρ\rho controls when to review again, rather than directly deciding whether to roll back. Under Equation (5), higher review urgency shortens the next review interval, allowing the system to reassess a questionable branch sooner, while lower urgency permits longer uninterrupted exploration. The review range bounds this adjustment: even a low-urgency branch is reviewed again within Lmax⁡L_{\max}, while a high-urgency branch still receives an exploration window of at least Lmin⁡L_{\min}. Together with the higher success rate and fewer reviews and rollbacks in Table 3, these results are consistent with adaptive scheduling improving performance through better intervention timing rather than greater intervention frequency. We have expanded Section 5.3 to connect Figure 3 (Figure 4 in the revised manuscript) with Equation (5) and the adaptive-versus-fixed comparison in Table 3, clarifying how the review range bounds adaptive scheduling.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Thank you again for your feedback

Thank you again for your feedback. We would appreciate any further thoughts on our responses and the additional results. Please let us know if any concerns remain or if further clarification would be helpful.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.