- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
I found this paper quite difficult to follow and gave up halfway through, so to be honest I'm not even very sure what the paper was proposing, but my understanding is that it is attempting to quantify the ability of agents to take proactive preventative actions towards failures that appear later in the trajectory.
Critical strengths
The paper was quite opaque, so I didn't get far enough to understand the strengths.
Critical weaknesses
The paper is very difficult to follow.
Section 3 is an example of this, for instance just to grab a few phrases in the section that are not easy to follow:
- a cost-matched control b
- exogenous fault tapes
- the clean condition
- Our primary object is the profile of ∆ins over fault types and severities (these are just in the first few paragraphs).
Furthermore, while section 3 did have some equations, they were not tied back to what we already know about this sort of long-term credit assignment from the RL literature, which would've been helpful for clarity.
The intro is also quite difficult to understand from a motivation perspective.
I think that the paper needs a clear pass for clarity before the readers will be able to follow what the authors are trying to say.
Questions for authors
None in particular.