- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
Thermo-hydro-mechanical simulations couple the heat transfer, fluid flow, and rock deformation changes in geothermal reservoirs. This paper introduces a thermo-hydro-mechanical emulator for coupled INTERSECT–VISAGE simulation. The paper proposes a Fourier neural operator to operate on the grid, then a CNN to correct the prediction near to well regions, and finally a standalone GNN to operate on the object-level in the reservoir to predict additional information. The method is evaluated on a dataset generated from INTERSECT–VISAGE simulation and compared to several implemented neural networks as baselines.
Critical strengths
- The model achieved good performance in emulating with a significant gain in speed against the reference finite-element solver.
Critical weaknesses
This paper should be clearly rejected.
- The method (to be honest, the whole paper) is very difficult to understand with many missing details e.g. the paper refers to the supplementary materials which do not exist, and it assumes that the reader has a perfect knowledge about thermo-hydro-mechanical without giving background or conceptual explanation about what the paper is aiming for. In summary, the paper is unpolished and imprecise and thus results are not reproducible.
- The proposed method does not support a sufficient contribution to the field. Where is the novelty aspect of this work?
Questions for authors
- Why did you choose Fourier neural operator?
- Do you think the results presented are significant in comparison to FNO/U-FNO? And why grid GCN performs so badly? Given the model capacity, I do not think the comparison between the models is fair.
- Can you clarify the novelty aspect of this paper? Is it only about that ECHO differs adds a fracture-specific prediction instead of having a one join model?