- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
CoMesh is a framework for generating engineering surface meshes through progressive refinement of a prescribed, constraint-encoding seed mesh. Its main component, Forward Refinement Fitting (FRF), constructs training trajectories by refining the seed toward a target surface using the same deterministic edge-selection rule employed during generation. Each refinement action is represented as a two-dimensional displacement in an edge-local coordinate frame, or a stopping decision, enabling a compact model conditioned on local mesh geometry. The paper also derives sufficient conditions for self-intersection-free interior refinement and uses a simplified dihedral-based heuristic in practice. Experiments on mounting brackets, transonic wings, and ship hulls evaluate constraint preservation, mesh quality, diversity, and computational efficiency.
Critical strengths
- A well-motivated formulation that reduces the learning burden while preserving explicit constraints. By combining a prescribed seed mesh, deterministic edge selection, and fixed connectivity updates, CoMesh avoids learning operation locations and connectivity indices. Existing vertices are preserved throughout refinement, providing a direct mechanism for maintaining seed-vertex constraints. This decomposition is particularly suitable for engineering shape families with prescribed interfaces and fixed topology, and enables a compact local model.
- Substantial empirical improvements across multiple engineering shape families. The experiments show considerably fewer self-intersections and invalid outputs than several evaluated baselines, together with substantial reductions in generation time. The FRF/state versus PM/causal comparisons also provide useful evidence that the overall representation and modeling choices matter. These results suggest that the proposed formulation is a promising alternative to general-purpose mesh generators for the targeted constrained-design setting.
Critical weaknesses
1.The claim of stable mesh quality across resolutions needs qualification. Although the face-level self-intersection ratios remain low, Table 7 shows that the non-clear rate for wings increases from 3% at 768 faces to 16% at full resolution. Since this metric includes generation failures, degeneracy, and samples containing self-intersections, the increase raises a concern about sample-level reliability that is not adequately conveyed by the statement that mesh quality remains stable as resolution increases. Moreover, the bending-energy and normal-variation metrics in Appendix E.3 are resolution-dependent, so their decrease does not by itself establish improved geometric quality. A breakdown of non-clear outcomes and a clearer distinction between face-level quality and sample-level validity would help substantiate the scalability claim.
Questions for authors
Could you clarify how the claim of stable mesh quality across resolutions should be interpreted given that the wing non-clear rate in Table 7 increases from 3% at 768 faces to 16% at full resolution? In particular, could you break down these outcomes into generation failures, degeneracy, and self-intersections, indicating any overlap? This would help distinguish low face-level error rates from sample-level reliability and assess the practical implications of increasing resolution.
3 comments
Thank you for the detailed response. The breakdown of invalid outcomes clearly shows that the increase at higher resolution comes mainly from self-intersections, and the added FEM/CFD downstream evaluations and the revised role of bending energy and normal variation address my concerns about how the quality claims should be interpreted. I would still encourage the authors to state explicitly in the main text that sample-level validity degrades with resolution (2.02% → 12.53% invalid for wings), and to list this as a limitation alongside the lower downstream success rate for wings (86.3%). Overall, I maintain my positive assessment and keep my score.
Thanks for your positive feedback. We will update the manuscript to explicitly state the numbers and clarify the limitations. As the first work targeting this constrained generation task, we believe these results already provide a promising starting point, with further improvements possible through parameter tuning.
We thank the reviewer for recognizing the value and methodological strengths of our approach. We also appreciate your careful reading of the resolution-scaling results, which has helped us clarify our claim and strengthen the evidence for practical use.
(1) Clarifying "stable mesh quality" and decomposing invalid outcomes. We agree that our original wording was insufficiently precise. Following your suggestion, we break down CoMesh's failure modes below and in the full-report tables in the manuscript. The results are updated to the mean of three training-seed experiments, so the values differ from the original report, but the trend remains the same.
The invalid rate increases from 2.02% to 12.53% in the updated experiments and is primarily due to more intersections. The distinction between face-level and sample-level failures is also important: even a small fraction of intersecting faces can make an entire mesh unusable. Nevertheless, CoMesh retains a substantial advantage over the evaluated wing baselines, whose invalid rates exceed 50% even at 768 faces. Their reliance on global context at each generation step also makes scaling to higher resolutions difficult.
(2) Practical implications and an end-to-end route to physical analysis. To further demonstrate the usability of CoMesh-generated meshes, we have added downstream evaluations using the outputs directly in FEM/CFD analysis:
Example simulation results are shown in Figures 24 (open the figure) and 25 (open the figure).
These experiments demonstrate how CoMesh's end-to-end generation of a design surface connects to physical analysis.
(3) Revising the role of bending energy and normal variation. We agree that their decrease with refinement alone cannot establish improved geometric quality. The revised main comparison therefore replaces the previous emphasis on smoothness with sliver-triangle ratio. We retain bending energy and the discussion of normal variation in the appendix as supplementary diagnostics. We have also added close-ups of bracket mounting interfaces (open the figure), hull deck alignment (open the figure), and wing triangle crossings (open the figure) in the revised Figure 6 (open the figure).